DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   DVD ethics question (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/517295-dvd-ethics-question.html)

jjcool 11-15-07 11:44 AM

Wow, bunch of thieves here.

Duality 11-15-07 12:21 PM


Originally Posted by FILMCZY
I switched out my full-screen "Psycho 2" dvd for the widescreen rental copy at Blockbuster.

Am I hellbound?

Well, I don't believe in "Hell". However, I wouldn't put a lot of trust in you. I've made stupid, dishonest decisions too. I've tried to make those things "right" and I can live with myself.

toddly6666 11-15-07 12:32 PM

The question is would Jesus be bringing new DVDs or used DVDs to homeless shelters (homeless shelters with surround sound home theaters of course)?

SterlingBen 11-15-07 01:27 PM


Originally Posted by nemein
You're joking right? I've used BB's 4 for $20 several times for DVDs that are still about $20/ea.

You aren't getting your dvds in the right places

To OP ever thought about getting it resurfaced at a game store?

nemein 11-15-07 02:52 PM


Originally Posted by Trevor
Slightly cheaper brand new thru CH. :)

Ah, gotcha... I burned out on doing all that multiple account juggling stuff (and CH in general) pretty quickly.

Doc MacGyver 11-15-07 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by oldboy87
dude, you're not alone, I've done that too.
i justified it to myself by thinking that given that it's a relatively old title (species 2), chances of it being rented again were probably slim, given the volume of new movies and tv shows that the store gets every week ...
But, yeah, it's not the most honest or ethical thing in the world. but probably less bad than driving away after running someone over on a dark and deserted road.

The second time it happened, I couldn't find my receipt, but the woman working at the shop remembered me buying the scratched up pvd (Talladega Nights) as I had bought a stack of movies there that day, and let me exchange it for a less scratched, working copy.


Well, while you're a thief for perpetrating these abhorent practices... you're a down right worthless human being for purchasing these abhorent movies ;)


-Doc

gotrice487 11-15-07 03:26 PM


Originally Posted by Alan Smithee
I've never seen a used DVD at a low enough price to buy used instead of new.

Me neither

billz 11-15-07 07:01 PM

I've never had a problem with a PVD purchase, and most I buy are in nearly new condition without inspection in the store. Unless we're talking about CH enrollments, I don't understand the economics of buying new over slightly used. I buy PVDs that are only a few weeks old for an average of $7 when Hastings has their "buy 2 get 1 for a penny" deal. That's much better than $20 for new titles. Over the course of a month I can own 6-8 more movies for the same amount of money that way.

If it's one of my favorite movies, I'll usually buy new because I want a pristine copy and I don't want to wait to buy it. Otherwise I see no reason to turn my nose up at used titles.

gcbma 11-15-07 07:11 PM

Bad, bad, bad, bad.

7Keys 11-15-07 07:11 PM


Originally Posted by jjcool
Wow, bunch of thieves here.

That's what I'm thinking. It's a pretty crappy thing to do, since when those people who rent your scratched disc or going to be pretty annoyed when they get home with a disc that won't play. Then they have to take it back and complain to the store. Then the store has to pay for a new one.

So, yes, you guys who does this are jerks. You screwed up, so take the $5 or whatever hit.

gcbma 11-15-07 07:14 PM

I can't believe no one else has asked yet: what's a PVD?

lamphorn 11-15-07 07:17 PM


Originally Posted by superdeluxe
I have a dvd ethics question.

I once bought a PVD from a hollywood video. Problem was I lost my receipt, so I couldnt take it back to exchange it. The PVD was badly scratched. Several weeks later after trying to figure out how to handle the situation, I rented a copy of the movie and switched discs.

I know that is extremely shady ass, but what else could I have done..?

What else could you have done? Be responsible and check out the disc before losing the receipt several weeks later. Try talking to the store and see if you have any luck getting a replacement.

It's not murder or robbing a bank, but it is lame.

billz 11-15-07 07:44 PM

I always tuck my receipt into the clip inside the case so I don't misplace it. Then when I watch the movie and verify it is fine I toss the receipt.

kunert 11-15-07 08:05 PM


Originally Posted by Alan Smithee
I've never seen a used DVD at a low enough price to buy used instead of new.

I seen 'em low enough that they are cheaper to buy and throw away than to rent and bring back. I'm talking $2 for something like American Dreamz.

jpdude 11-15-07 08:31 PM


Originally Posted by gcbma
I can't believe no one else has asked yet: what's a PVD?

Previously Viewed Disc

YGT? ;)

EdTheRipper 11-15-07 08:41 PM


Originally Posted by TheMovieman
I thought Hollywood Video had lifetime guarantees on their PVD DVDs.


You're probably right. I haven't bought anything pre-viewed there in a long time.

hindolio 11-16-07 12:44 AM


Originally Posted by billz
I always tuck my receipt into the clip inside the case so I don't misplace it. Then when I watch the movie and verify it is fine I toss the receipt.

what do you do when you buy more than one dvd at a time?


Originally Posted by superdeluxe
I have a dvd ethics question.

I once bought a PVD from a hollywood video. Problem was I lost my receipt, so I couldnt take it back to exchange it. The PVD was badly scratched. Several weeks later after trying to figure out how to handle the situation, I rented a copy of the movie and switched discs.

I know that is extremely shady ass, but what else could I have done..?

shady yesh imho, but who cares what i or whomever else thinks? but you otoh, obviously have at least a bit of guilt for posting the question in the first place. decide whether what you did was ok for yourself or not, then let it go :D

Alan Smithee 11-16-07 03:30 AM


I'm talking $2 for something like American Dreamz.
Which I bought NEW for $3.99. No reason to buy used to save 2 bucks.

Alan Smithee 11-16-07 03:31 AM

I did rent Finding Nemo and returned it with Backdoor Sluts 9 in the case instead, is that bad? ;)

fiver 11-16-07 09:01 AM

I wonder how much of a deal this disc was if the OP had to pay money to rent a second copy just to make the switch - I haven't rented a movie outside of netflix in years - how much is it these days? $3.99? $5.00 ? ;)

Never bought a PVD through a known rental location. Bought them successfully off of Amazon used *knock on wood* - After seeing some of the discs that come in from Netflix, there's no way I would want to risk it. Most people treat their property like crap.

Oh, and don't do it again *raps knuckles with ruler*

Michael

domino harvey 11-16-07 12:18 PM

I am having trouble figuring out why anyone should feel bad about this. Either disc could have been the disc he bought originally and just by chance he gets the bad one. It's not like the company won't order a replacement copy for the rental.

Trevor 11-16-07 12:24 PM


Originally Posted by domino harvey
I am having trouble figuring out why anyone should feel bad about this. Either disc could have been the disc he bought originally and just by chance he gets the bad one. It's not like the company won't order a replacement copy for the rental.

Are you kidding? Think of the person going in and renting the defective copy: a wasted trip, aggravation, driving back to the store, etc.

I'm not saying I'm always an angel, but how could anyone not feel bad about this?

domino harvey 11-16-07 12:34 PM

If you still rent at a B+M, you get what you deserve

7Keys 11-16-07 10:03 PM


Originally Posted by domino harvey
If you still rent at a B+M, you get what you deserve

Yeah, because no one ever has problems with Netflix or Blockbuster or any other online rental place.

billz 11-16-07 11:49 PM


Originally Posted by hindolio
what do you do when you buy more than one dvd at a time?

I actually move it from case to case, since I keep all of my unwatched DVDs in a big stack (that is always threatening to rise beyond my reach).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:32 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.