Twin Peaks: The Definitive Gold Box Edition (The Complete Series)
#51
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ
Is it possible that David Lynch doesn't want the deleted scenes released at all and rather than looking like a complete dick to his fans he comes up with the unreasonable excuse of restoring the scenes knowing full well that the studio will never go for it?
Lynch wins either way, he doesn't look like a prick to his fans, his scenes stay in the vault, and the studio is made to look like the unreasonable ones.
Lynch wins either way, he doesn't look like a prick to his fans, his scenes stay in the vault, and the studio is made to look like the unreasonable ones.
#53
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 2,429
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Josh Z
If that were his plan, it isn't working. Most of his fans do think he looks like a prick about this.
While I'm fascinated to see the "Fire Walk With Me" deleted scenes - as I was with those from "Dune" - in most instances I prefer that these remain, as they say, "on the cutting room floor". I suspect there are some intriguing remnants from "Blue Velvet", but as I believe it's a perfect film already and so edited into its final form by Lynch, I believe these can only detract from the finished work. At least for myself.
The situation is of course quite different when it comes to forced cuts, as in "Dune". But, even here, the attempt to re-edit the film - save for the initial sequences on Arrakis that followed the shooting script - was a complete failure. Similarly, the deleted scenes included on the new disc would have been much more appreciated had they been "completed" (and, for that matter, anamorphically-enhanced). Hearing Lynch intone the chanted Bene Geserit response off-camera, or failing to stick a starfield in the background of the long-form intro make these sequences far less interesting than they would be with even the tiniest bit of post-production.
So "prick" is not a word I'd use to describe Lynch. Perfectionist, more likely. Eccentric, perhaps. But "prick"? No. The man has brought too much wonder into my life for me to start hurling epithets his way.
#54
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: A National Park
Posts: 4,964
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Just to go against the grain and to show not EVERYONE loves this show; me and a few others watched it recentley and NO ONE liked it.
I blind bought season 1 and couldnt wait to see it. After seeing it, Im really dissapointed. It was just a soap opera. Infact I think it was an inside joke at how cheesy and corny it is as the whole town is engulfed in some stupid soap opera within itself. Plus they play that annoying piano music when people die or make out; not to mention everyone is having an affair. We laughed so much at this show. The acting aint that great either. However, I am interested to see how it all ends as I wasted my time seeing S1, I might as well see the rest. Though I consider this a one time view and dont see its attraction.
I blind bought season 1 and couldnt wait to see it. After seeing it, Im really dissapointed. It was just a soap opera. Infact I think it was an inside joke at how cheesy and corny it is as the whole town is engulfed in some stupid soap opera within itself. Plus they play that annoying piano music when people die or make out; not to mention everyone is having an affair. We laughed so much at this show. The acting aint that great either. However, I am interested to see how it all ends as I wasted my time seeing S1, I might as well see the rest. Though I consider this a one time view and dont see its attraction.
#55
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Different strokes for different folks, I guess -- it *is* just a soap opera, of course, but it's the execution that's made it stick in my mind for 15+ years now. Can't wait to pick this up.
#56
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Richard Malloy
While I'm fascinated to see the "Fire Walk With Me" deleted scenes - as I was with those from "Dune" - in most instances I prefer that these remain, as they say, "on the cutting room floor". I suspect there are some intriguing remnants from "Blue Velvet", but as I believe it's a perfect film already and so edited into its final form by Lynch, I believe these can only detract from the finished work. At least for myself.
#57
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Originally Posted by Ravenous
Just to go against the grain and to show not EVERYONE loves this show; me and a few others watched it recentley and NO ONE liked it.
I blind bought season 1 and couldnt wait to see it. After seeing it, Im really dissapointed. It was just a soap opera. Infact I think it was an inside joke at how cheesy and corny it is as the whole town is engulfed in some stupid soap opera within itself. Plus they play that annoying piano music when people die or make out; not to mention everyone is having an affair. We laughed so much at this show. The acting aint that great either. However, I am interested to see how it all ends as I wasted my time seeing S1, I might as well see the rest. Though I consider this a one time view and dont see its attraction.
I blind bought season 1 and couldnt wait to see it. After seeing it, Im really dissapointed. It was just a soap opera. Infact I think it was an inside joke at how cheesy and corny it is as the whole town is engulfed in some stupid soap opera within itself. Plus they play that annoying piano music when people die or make out; not to mention everyone is having an affair. We laughed so much at this show. The acting aint that great either. However, I am interested to see how it all ends as I wasted my time seeing S1, I might as well see the rest. Though I consider this a one time view and dont see its attraction.
Kidding aside, I will be picking it up as a blind buy. I'm about 98% on blind buys, and I trust most of the opinions of the regulars here on DVDTalk.
#58
Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Houston
Posts: 209
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm going to have to get this and replace my hand-tapped videos! my interest in the show has returned after seeing snipets on the Chiller network.
now I wonder if "On the Air" will ever make it to DVD???
now I wonder if "On the Air" will ever make it to DVD???
#60
Member
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Camp Taji,Iraq/Brandon, Fl
Posts: 217
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
In the dying days of vhs, i managed to complete my Lynch collection with everything imaginable. Now with dvd, the only things I got is Blue Velvet, Elephant Man, Eraserhead (way too expansive) TP S1, TP pilot (crappy quality for the price) and FWWM. I waited on S2 when the rumors of this set came around. Hope they change the cover, it's horrible.
#61
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 541
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Sierra Disc
Different strokes for different folks, I guess -- it *is* just a soap opera, of course, but it's the execution that's made it stick in my mind for 15+ years now. Can't wait to pick this up.
I love it; used to have 20-30 people over every time it was on for viewing parties.
#62
Cool New Member
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: Urbandale, IA 50322
Posts: 41
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by gorgo99
True, it is very much a soap opera, but with a supernatural killer and a mysticism and pie obsessed FBI agent hunting him down. The overly melodramatic music, affairs, etc. was intentionally so, and an integral part, IMHO, to lace the grim proceedings with a dark sense of humor.
I love it; used to have 20-30 people over every time it was on for viewing parties.
I love it; used to have 20-30 people over every time it was on for viewing parties.
#63
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by billolmesdahl
I'm actually having a regular Twin Peaks night with 4-5 friends to watch the series through to the end. It's better with a few newbies, watching them try to figure out what the heck is going on.
#65
Senior Member
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Columbus, Ohio
Posts: 324
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by GoldenJCJ
Is it possible that David Lynch doesn't want the deleted scenes released at all and rather than looking like a complete dick to his fans he comes up with the unreasonable excuse of restoring the scenes knowing full well that the studio will never go for it?
Lynch wins either way, he doesn't look like a prick to his fans, his scenes stay in the vault, and the studio is made to look like the unreasonable ones.
Anyway, just thinking out loud.
Lynch wins either way, he doesn't look like a prick to his fans, his scenes stay in the vault, and the studio is made to look like the unreasonable ones.
Anyway, just thinking out loud.
#66
DVD Talk Hero
I think fans like us, who spend countless hours reading about all release developments might realize that Lynch is being a dick about the whole thing, but I'm guessing casual fans who only hear "the studio refused to put the deleted scenes on the set" will think Lynch is OK and the studio is at fault.
#67
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by drainout
In the dying days of vhs, i managed to complete my Lynch collection with everything imaginable. Now with dvd, the only things I got is Blue Velvet, Elephant Man, Eraserhead (way too expansive) TP S1, TP pilot (crappy quality for the price) and FWWM. I waited on S2 when the rumors of this set came around. Hope they change the cover, it's horrible.
Oh, and this will also be a blind buy for me.
#68
Senior Member
I've been watching my copy of the second season but seem to have lost interest since they've revealed who the killer is. I never watched this show when it was on television. Does anyone find that there's little value in watching after this point? The story is so disjointed.
#70
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by tboogie
I've been watching my copy of the second season but seem to have lost interest since they've revealed who the killer is. I never watched this show when it was on television. Does anyone find that there's little value in watching after this point? The story is so disjointed.
You'll need to see the whole series to really comprehend Fire Walk With Me.
#71
Needs to Contact Admin about multiple accounts
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Winston Salem, NC
Posts: 2,806
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Heard and read about the hype surrounding the show,b ut never actually saw it. I guess it'll be a blind buy for me.
What's the release date on it?
What's the release date on it?
#72
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by Josh Z
No one is asking for the scenes to be reinstated back into the movie. We'd like to see them as a supplement, a look into the development process of the movie, to see what sort of material was developed but eventually deemed not good enough to make the final cut. To that end, there's no need at all for the footage to be in perfect condition.
It seems like the rights-holders don't want to pony up a wheel barrow full of cash to remaster a bunch of deleted scenes.
Lynch won't let the scenes be shown without being remastered.
Maybe a long cut of FWWM would be a reasonable compromise to get the material out there. (Though I could see Lynch balking at recutting the movie.)
#74
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Josh-da-man
Would it be easier to get the scenes remastered if they would be cut into an extended version of the film?
That's, you know, interesting and all, but frankly people just want to see the footage and don't give a crap what they look like.
#75
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Longview, TX, USA
Posts: 1,214
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm really glad to see that this is being released. I missed out on Season 1 and last time I checked it was OOP, so I will definitely be picking this up the week it comes out.