DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Battle Royale R1 coming! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/501046-battle-royale-r1-coming.html)

Steve 05-19-07 02:25 PM

Battle Royale R1 coming!
 
I just found this on amazone.. 5/29th release date.

http://amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B...dvdpricesearch
(I and II)

Starmax release - no specs.. but is this a new NTSC transfer? A port from the OOP NTSC 5.1 version?

Anyone know anything about this?

tylergfoster 05-19-07 02:49 PM

In the descriptor tags it says "Import" and for Region it says "unknown" so I wouldn't get my hopes up. If it comes to the US on DVD I think someone a little bigger (even if it is specialty, like, say, Tartan) will get it.

Seantn 05-19-07 03:04 PM

Does any US company own the rights to the film at the moment, but just haven't released it yet?

animatedude 05-19-07 03:15 PM

booo nothing will top the UK Tartan Tin version....whatever happened to the american remake?

Seantn 05-19-07 03:18 PM

Virginia Tech.

Right after that happened I read that it was being shelved. I don't think it'll ever get made in the US because there will always be some kind of big tragedy involving guns that will have happened within 1 or 2 years that studios will use as an excuse to not make the film.

animatedude 05-19-07 03:33 PM

it's sad cos the american remake could turn out to be a masterpiece if it was done right.

visitor Q 05-19-07 03:39 PM


Originally Posted by Seantn
I read that it was being shelved.

I was going to say "excellent" as I'm typically not a fan of remakes ..at all, but it would be very interesting to see how New Line would handle it. With my lack of faith in Hollywood studios in general, they would probably make BR end up looking like Bad Boys 2 or something similar.

visitor Q 05-19-07 03:41 PM


Originally Posted by animatedude
it's sad cos the american remake could turn out to be a masterpiece if it was done right.

Don't hold your breath.

By the way, what's wrong with Fukasaku's version?

project86 05-19-07 03:42 PM

The one good thing a remake would bring is probably an R1 release of the original. Usually the original gets a big release whenever the remake is about to hit theaters.

bahhh

xage 05-19-07 03:53 PM


Originally Posted by Steve
I just found this on amazone.. 5/29th release date.

http://amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/B...dvdpricesearch
(I and II)

Starmax release - no specs.. but is this a new NTSC transfer? A port from the OOP NTSC 5.1 version?

Anyone know anything about this?

Looks like similar to the one sold at Hot Topic a year ago.

http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b221/xage00/BR.jpg

And its by Wision Entertainment (import from Korea) .. its NTSC and Region Code free

*edited 5/19/2007 6:25pm

Kguy1326 05-19-07 05:39 PM


Originally Posted by animatedude
it's sad cos the american remake could turn out to be a masterpiece if it was done right.


If done right??? That's an understatement. It was beign done by Neil H. Moritz, the guy behind stuff like "Prison Break", "I know what you did last summer", etc. It was probably gonna be ruined, better that it's shelved now.

TomOpus 05-19-07 05:43 PM

I'm sorry, but IMO, no one could do it right if done in America. I don't think a studio would allow it and there would be so many compromises, it just wouldn't be worth it.

Zen Peckinpah 05-19-07 06:04 PM

If you think about it, Battle Royale would be undoable in America, Virginia Tech or not. However, I'd kill to see Zack Snyder or Paul Verhoeven take on the project. If Snyder put an ounce of energy like he did with 300 and Dawn of the Dead, we'd get an epic, no-holds-barred telling of the story (watch the DOTD opening credit scenes for proof). Verhoeven's BR, however, would be possibly the most excitingly badass project ever. Have him direct, Ed Neumeier on writing duties, and you've got a movie to join RoboCop and Starship Troopers. I can't even begin to picture Media Breaks in his version... :D

matome 05-19-07 06:10 PM

Yeah, I'm trying to remember the last time I saw a kid getting graphically killed in a U.S. movie. Robocop 2? I guess kids don't really get killed in real life.

tylergfoster 05-19-07 06:56 PM


Originally Posted by xage
Looks like similar to the one sold at Hot Topic a year ago.

http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b221/xage00/BR.jpg

And its by Starmax (import from Korea) .. its NTSC and Region Code free

That's a reasonably nice box. I wish I had known they were being sold but I don't go into Hot Topic.

zombeaner 05-19-07 07:33 PM

It is the same thing, it is the region free Korean import.

OldBoy 05-19-07 07:44 PM


Originally Posted by xage
Looks like similar to the one sold at Hot Topic a year ago.

http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b221/xage00/BR.jpg

And its by Starmax (import from Korea) .. its NTSC and Region Code free

so what is the difference between this and the Starmax R0 NTSC Director's Cut of the first film only? the one with the beige slipcase...

vedderone 05-19-07 07:58 PM

this is also available right now on hot topics website for $35

xage 05-19-07 08:21 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
so what is the difference between this and the Starmax R0 NTSC Director's Cut of the first film only? the one with the beige slipcase...

My apologies I stand corrected, this is a Wision Entertainment Release not Starmax

Cosmic Bus 05-19-07 09:22 PM

FYE is carrying this set now, too, along with a non-anamorphic Universe Laser release of the first movie.

beavis69 05-19-07 09:34 PM

So is that a legit release? Do the special features have english subtitles?

xage 05-20-07 09:23 AM


Originally Posted by beavis69
So is that a legit release? Do the special features have english subtitles?


Yes, its a legit release (produced,manufactured & imported from Korea). Unfortunately there were no English Sub for its special feature.

Kguy1326 05-20-07 05:27 PM


Originally Posted by Zen Peckinpah
If you think about it, Battle Royale would be undoable in America, Virginia Tech or not. However, I'd kill to see Zack Snyder or Paul Verhoeven take on the project. If Snyder put an ounce of energy like he did with 300 and Dawn of the Dead, we'd get an epic, no-holds-barred telling of the story (watch the DOTD opening credit scenes for proof). Verhoeven's BR, however, would be possibly the most excitingly badass project ever. Have him direct, Ed Neumeier on writing duties, and you've got a movie to join RoboCop and Starship Troopers. I can't even begin to picture Media Breaks in his version... :D

Well, too bad I'm not a film maker or anyone of importance. If I helmed the project, I'd make damn sure to stick to the book's roots and adhere strictly to age groups, violence, sex, plotlines etc. Yeah, I'm sure I'd have to chop it up for at least an R rating, but i'd want the studio to back me up into shooting the full film, book, and script with no compromise. I'll deliver them their mass audience version to make money, but cut a full version for the die hard fans. Sure that idealism sucks. If worse comes to worst, I'd at least split the (ideal 3 hour film in two) to keep everything in tact, and keep the rating and the graphicness.

xage 05-20-07 07:26 PM

Too bad, most members do insert the topic about the Movie Remake where this thread talks about the Region 1 DVD release

Anyways, should you voice out your opinion about the remake of Battle Royale in Hollywood here is the appropriate thread for you.

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showthread.php?t=468134

Wildo1966 05-20-07 07:40 PM


Originally Posted by droidguy1119
That's a reasonably nice box. I wish I had known they were being sold but I don't go into Hot Topic.

Don't worry about it droidguy, most normal people avoid Hot Topic like the plague....Like my wife says every time we go by a Hot Topic...."That store is for freaks"....Enough said...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:41 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.