DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Comic Book DVD's (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/469289-comic-book-dvds.html)

PerpleNerple 06-20-06 12:22 AM

Comic Book DVD's
 
Was wondering if anyone had a list of all DVD's that came from Comic Books?

I'm updating my list, I am of course only collecting the newer ones.

I have so far:
Hellboy
Spidey 1:2
X-men 1:2
Electra
Daredevil
Batman Begins
Heavy Metal 1:2
Fantastic 4
Underworld 1:2
Spawn
Hulk
Blade
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
Mystery Men (Heard this was, so I'm not sure)
Bulletproof Monk (Another one, not sure of)
The Road to Perdition (Not Sure)

I don't have, but getting soon: Catwoman, Ultraviolet

Is the Riddick Trilogy from Comics or Illustrated Novel?

takingchase 06-20-06 01:12 AM

don't get catwoman even if your collecting comic book movies, it's so terrible.


Two really good comic book movies you should look into though are constantine and sin city.

Swy 06-20-06 01:21 AM

I'm gonna have to reccommend you get Sin City instead of Catwoman...Please!

zachip 06-20-06 02:01 AM

ok, here is a clarfication.

Bulletproof Monk (it's based on chinese comic)
The Road to Perdition (based on graphic novel)
about, Mystery Men (i don't think it's based on something, maybe superhero
inspired/spoof film). is Underworld a comic book? didn't hear. i think not.
ultraviolet is not a comic and riddick is not a comic.
and heavy metal films are based on magazine illustration stories,
so basically it's not a comic book.

more comics films are:
old ones:
superman
supergirl
the crow
from hell

new ones:
history of violence (based on graphic novel)
sin city
constantine

future ones:
30 days of night

Indoor Kid 06-20-06 05:46 AM

Ummm... it's a massive list.

Clarification of some, and a couple new ones:

I'd classify Heavy Metal as a comic considering it is printed sequential comics but in a magazine format.
Bulletproof Monk (AMERICAN comic book by Michael Avon Oeming, better than the movie)
Mystery Men is based on some small characters from 'Flaming Carrot' so yeah, it's based on a comic.
Road To Perdition is of course based on the famous Graphic Novel.
Blueberry, western, not sure if this is out in America but based on the french comic.
Ghost World, based on the comic.
American Splendor, if you've seen this then it's obviously based on a comic.

I have alot more but not an actual list.

crabbit 06-20-06 06:25 AM

Ghost World
Dick Tracy
both Punisher movies
Steel (haha...it'll make catwoman seem like a classic at least)
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles
Supergirl (though I think the DVD is pretty hard to get nowadays)
Men in Black
that Captain America movie with the rubber ears and whatnot

joltman 06-20-06 06:44 AM

A few I can remember off the top of my head

Man-Thing
The Mask (Jim Carrey)
Howard the Duck

and while it's not officially based on a comic, I think Comic Book: the Movie should get an honorable mention :)

I just found this - <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_movies_based_on_comic_books">List of movies based on comic books</a> at the Wikipedia

speedy1961 06-20-06 07:16 AM

Swamp Thing
Man-Thing

MovieExchange 06-20-06 07:53 AM

Why only the newer ones?

The older ones might be cheesy, but no moreso than crap-fests like Catwoman, Electra, Hulk and LXG.

PerpleNerple 06-20-06 10:53 AM

The Newer Ones? Well, because the Special Effects are more realistic looking these days, compared to say the Superman Series with Christopher Reeves. I know, I know, I shouldn't be that way, but I am. Yes, some are still Cheesy, but they look better. I guess you can say I have screwed up taste, but I do like the newer ones than the old. Like Batman Begins compared to the old ones, the newer one to me is darker like it should be, and well basically just blows the old ones away.

exharrison 06-20-06 11:00 AM


Originally Posted by PerpleNerple
The Newer Ones? Well, because the Special Effects are more realistic looking these days, compared to say the Superman Series with Christopher Reeves. I know, I know, I shouldn't be that way, but I am. Yes, some are still Cheesy, but they look better. I guess you can say I have screwed up taste, but I do like the newer ones than the old. Like Batman Begins compared to the old ones, the newer one to me is darker like it should be, and well basically just blows the old ones away.

How can you possible say that Batman Begins was better than Batman and Robin? I mean, anatomically correct rubber suits, come on.

Adiras 06-20-06 11:12 AM

V for Vendetta.

majorjoe23 06-20-06 12:19 PM

Some you've missed:
From Hell (Based on the comic by Alan Moore)
I can't recommed the Bruce Timm animated series (Batman, Batman Beyond, Superman, Justice League) enough. They are great.
Art School Confidential was based on a short comic, and should be announced on DVD soon.
The Lone Wolf & Cub series
Lady Snowblood movies
The Rockateer

speedy1961 06-20-06 12:36 PM

League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Mondo Kane 06-20-06 12:38 PM

Do manga adaptations count? If so, there's a MASSIVE list out there!

And give Swamp Thing and it's sequel a chance :D

dx23 06-20-06 01:24 PM

The Punisher ( both versions)
He-Man and the Masters of the Universe
From Hell
Howard the Duck

GuruTwo 06-20-06 01:40 PM


He-Man and the Masters of the Universe
That's based on a toy line, not a comic book. Sure, there were "He-Man" comic books but that certainly doesn't mean that it's BASED on a comic book, and if you were to consider it one you'd open up a whole can of worms where anything that was ever published in comic-book form would be eligible.

mrhan 06-20-06 01:46 PM

Oldboy
Ichi The Killer

They were based on comic books (manga).

joltman 06-20-06 01:51 PM


Originally Posted by PerpleNerple
The Newer Ones? Well, because the Special Effects are more realistic looking these days, compared to say the Superman Series with Christopher Reeves. I know, I know, I shouldn't be that way, but I am. Yes, some are still Cheesy, but they look better. I guess you can say I have screwed up taste, but I do like the newer ones than the old. Like Batman Begins compared to the old ones, the newer one to me is darker like it should be, and well basically just blows the old ones away.

On the subject of cheesiness in comic book movies, am I the only one who still thinks a couple of the fights scenes in Spider-man look a little cheesy? I'm talking about the one on one fights between Spider-Man and the Green Goblin, where they are physically fighting each other. I think it's the fact that it's two guys in suits fighting, I dunno.

Maxflier 06-20-06 03:07 PM

Conan the Barbarian and Red Sonja.

rdclark 06-20-06 03:29 PM


Originally Posted by Maxflier
Conan the Barbarian and Red Sonja.

Conan is based on the novels and stories of Robert E. Howard, as were the various comic book adaptations.

If Conan counts, then any movie based on a book that was first adapted as a Classics Illustrated comic would also have to count.

You could argue that Red Sonja is indeed based on a comic, since the Howard Sonja character was not really the same, and the movie was very intentionally based on the Roy Thomas comics character.

Has anyone mentioned Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles?

RichC

Maxflier 06-20-06 03:46 PM


Originally Posted by rdclark
Conan is based on the novels and stories of Robert E. Howard, as were the various comic book adaptations.

If Conan counts, then any movie based on a book that was first adapted as a Classics Illustrated comic would also have to count.

You could argue that Red Sonja is indeed based on a comic, since the Howard Sonja character was not really the same, and the movie was very intentionally based on the Roy Thomas comics character.

Yes, i know all that. I didn't realize we were being that technical. Either way both characters were in comic books series and movies, so i figured the OP might be interested in them.


Originally Posted by rdclark

Has anyone mentioned Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles?

Yes, in post #6.

majorjoe23 06-20-06 04:35 PM

Red Sonja is the comic character, Sonya is the Howard character, and Sonja is based on Sonya. There's actually a lawsuit about this going on now. It's confusing.

rdclark 06-20-06 07:02 PM


Originally Posted by Maxflier
Yes, i know all that. I didn't realize we were being that technical. Either way both characters were in comic books series and movies, so i figured the OP might be interested in them.

But it's no fun if you can't be technical and pedantic!

Characters that were in comic books series and movies:

The crews of the Enterprises
The characters of Battlestar Galactica and Firefly
Huey, Dewey, Louie, Scrooge, Donald...
The Old Man (and the Sea) (the series was "Classics Illustrated")
The Grateful Dead (the rock band)
Joe Mandela (and the other characters from Haldeman's "Forever War")
etc. etc. etc.

There are a lot of movies with what one might call a "comic book sensibility," some of which have so much of it that they become decent comic books. And other source material also qualifies -- how different are the Lara Croft or Doom or Aeon Flux movies from comic book movies, really?

The OP seemed to be clearly trying to limit his list to live-action features based on comics or graphic novels. But I agree with you that there are a ton of other movies that such a collector would also be interested in.

RichC

cruzness 06-20-06 08:44 PM

I don't think these two were mentioned:
Vampirella
Kull the Conqueror
and technically Aliens Vs. Predator - yes both characters were characters that were adapted to comics from the movies - but combining them was an idea that happened in comics first


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:48 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.