Worrying DVD lifespan for DVD collectors!
#1
Cool New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Worrying DVD lifespan for DVD collectors!
Check out my temp site on the A.I. Artificial Intelligence Widescreen DVD deterioration problem.
The temp site has all the images. The main image is the worrying one. Take a look and let me know what's the problem as I'm not sure what causes it.
It's worrying.
P.S. If my temp site bandwidth max out, here's the whole site in zip.
The temp site has all the images. The main image is the worrying one. Take a look and let me know what's the problem as I'm not sure what causes it.
It's worrying.
P.S. If my temp site bandwidth max out, here's the whole site in zip.
Last edited by AT71; 11-01-05 at 08:04 AM.
#2
Cool New Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 21
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Bandwidth ran out.
Anyway, here's what I wrote and posted at that temp site.
Recently, I did a random watch on one of DVDs in my growing collection over the years and discovered something worrying. It appears that the movie disc of A.I. is deteriorating (see DSCN5721.jpg). Looks like some oxidization occured inside the disc layer. Because of this, I'm having problem playing this disc on my DVD player. My DVD collection is kept inside a cupboard in room temperature (estimated 28ºC) and mild humidity of 50% (maybe higher). So far, only this disc has this problem. A lot of DVDs that I have acquired a few years earlier to this one and are still okay. Strangely, the bonus disc seems okay as seen in (see DSCN5722.jpg). I'm pondering whether I should replace it with another. Then again, the thought of some manufacturing problem in this line will spell the same problem.
Now, the real worrying question.
Will pre-recorded DVDs end up like this in the future?
It's worrying for avid DVD collectors.
Anyway, here's what I wrote and posted at that temp site.
Recently, I did a random watch on one of DVDs in my growing collection over the years and discovered something worrying. It appears that the movie disc of A.I. is deteriorating (see DSCN5721.jpg). Looks like some oxidization occured inside the disc layer. Because of this, I'm having problem playing this disc on my DVD player. My DVD collection is kept inside a cupboard in room temperature (estimated 28ºC) and mild humidity of 50% (maybe higher). So far, only this disc has this problem. A lot of DVDs that I have acquired a few years earlier to this one and are still okay. Strangely, the bonus disc seems okay as seen in (see DSCN5722.jpg). I'm pondering whether I should replace it with another. Then again, the thought of some manufacturing problem in this line will spell the same problem.
Now, the real worrying question.
Will pre-recorded DVDs end up like this in the future?
It's worrying for avid DVD collectors.
#5
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 2000
Location: Chicago, IL
Posts: 1,937
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is the first time I see a dvd looking that way
It looks as if the paint of the dvd case plastic is eating your dvd.
Does anyone know if the dvd cases are Acid Free like the comic book bags?
It looks as if the paint of the dvd case plastic is eating your dvd.
Does anyone know if the dvd cases are Acid Free like the comic book bags?
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by AT71
It ain't mildew, mold or measles. It's inside the disc layer.
#12
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2005
Posts: 488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You might want to consider contacting the WB and telling them you want a replacement since your disc has contracted some sort of DISEASE!
I found this: http://www2.warnerbros.com/web/main/...er_service.jsp
I found this: http://www2.warnerbros.com/web/main/...er_service.jsp
#15
DVD Talk Legend
It looks as though there is some kind of pattern to it... Does it correspond to something on the printed side of the disc?
#16
I watched my copy of AI not too long ago and it played fine, and I just checked the disc, and it's also fine. I am wondering if this is a case, like with the previous Anchor Bay fiasco, of a DVD being manufactured at two different plants, and one plant used a different glue for the dual layered disc than the other one did?
But whatever it is, that is just not something I've ever seen anybody complain about happening before. I'd be calling WB if I were you and asking for permission to email those pics to them or send them a link to the pics. But I would definately ask permission to send those pics first, whether as an attachment or a link, as they may not be willing to open attatchments or links from unsolicited sources.
And let us know what they say!
But whatever it is, that is just not something I've ever seen anybody complain about happening before. I'd be calling WB if I were you and asking for permission to email those pics to them or send them a link to the pics. But I would definately ask permission to send those pics first, whether as an attachment or a link, as they may not be willing to open attatchments or links from unsolicited sources.
And let us know what they say!
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 467
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Assuming that the big patch of black near the centre is just that, not a reflection or shadow, my guess is that there was an error in manufacture meaning that the disc layers were imperfectly bonded, or the lacquer layer not applied properly. This has allowed oxygen or moisture to penetrate to the data layer, perhaps because the layers have delaminated.
Sadly, no mass production process is 100% perfect, and just think of the number of discs they churned out.
I think you got unlucky and got a bad one.
I'd contact the issuing studio and tell them what's happened.
Sadly, no mass production process is 100% perfect, and just think of the number of discs they churned out.
I think you got unlucky and got a bad one.
I'd contact the issuing studio and tell them what's happened.
#22
DVD Talk Special Edition
Considering that this board has been around 5+ years since the early days of DVD, and this is the first time anyone has had a DVD that looked like that, I think it's fair to call yours an isolated case. I don't think its an indication of a larger problem (though I agree with everyone that it does have a contagious look about it... I wouldn't let it play with your other discs anymore ).