DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   "From the Earth to the Moon" - Anamorphic WS/DTS: 9/20/2005 (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/426814-earth-moon-anamorphic-ws-dts-9-20-2005-a.html)

Bill Needle 06-14-05 02:17 PM

"From the Earth to the Moon" - Anamorphic WS/DTS: 9/20/2005
 
From the bits:


Originally Posted by thedigitalbits
HBO has revealed that they're preparing a newly-updated DVD box set of Tom Hanks' From the Earth to the Moon mini-series for release on 9/20 (SRP $99.98). The original box was one of HBO's first ever DVD releases, and it was presented in the series' full frame aspect ratio. For the new 5-disc set, you'll get all the episodes in anamorphic widescreen video, complete with both Dolby Digital and DTS 5.1 audio. Extras will include a mix of new and old bonus material. We'll post the complete spec list when it's available. No doubt this updated set is connected to HBO's planned HD-DVD release of the mini-series due later in 2005 (and first announced back in January). Since the episodes had to be remastered in high-definition anamorphic widescreen for HD-DVD, why not reissue them in regular DVD anamorphic widescreen too?

This is a fabulous series, one I rank only below Band of Brothers. Can't wait.

animatedude 06-14-05 02:24 PM

than god i didn't buy the first boxset....but this one seems pricey to me...ah well

Giles 06-14-05 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by animatedude
than god i didn't buy the first boxset....but this one seems pricey to me...ah well

same here, swheet, gonna get some extra bonus Amazon points for this purchase - woohoo!

pilot 06-14-05 02:26 PM

I got the original set a LONG LONG time ago, and actually never managed to watch it all even though I really enjoyed the parts I watched.. I'm pretty ticked it's being re-released widescreen but not positive I'll buy it again, but I might..

Bill Needle 06-14-05 02:27 PM


Originally Posted by animatedude
than god i didn't buy the first boxset....but this one seems pricey to me...ah well

This is still in line with the first set cost, which yes, is also pricey.

Artman 06-14-05 02:29 PM

I caught about 1/2 an episode when it originally aired, and I remember thinking it was excellent. I just might go for this one if I can find a good deal on it.

Bill Needle 06-14-05 02:30 PM


Originally Posted by pilot
I got the original set a LONG LONG time ago, and actually never managed to watch it all even though I really enjoyed the parts I watched.. I'm pretty ticked it's being re-released widescreen but not positive I'll buy it again, but I might..

I hear ya, I have a similar history with my set, though I saw the entire series on HBO at least once through.

But now that I have the 61" widescreen, I don't see that I have much choice but to dip again. -wink-

jmj713 06-14-05 02:34 PM

But isn't 1.33:1 the OAR for this miniseries? I would assume so, since it originally aired in what, '96-97.

fitprod 06-14-05 02:39 PM

HBO re-formated it a few years back when they lauched HBO-HD...

Also, if you plan on getting into HD-DVD, this is supposed to be an early release....

fitprod

Bill Needle 06-14-05 02:40 PM


Originally Posted by jmj713
But isn't 1.33:1 the OAR for this miniseries? I would assume so, since it originally aired in what, '96-97.

Yes it was. Not sure how they are handling it. Carefully cropping it I suppose. But it always had the feel that it should have been a widescreen title. Even moreso now on a widescreen set.

marty888 06-14-05 02:41 PM


Originally Posted by jmj713
But isn't 1.33:1 the OAR for this miniseries? I would assume so, since it originally aired in what, '96-97.


I believe you are absolutely correct - the series was conceived, filmed and broadcast with a 1.33:1 aspect ratio.

Any one who doesn't already have this should place it high on their wish list - for me, it is still the best TV mini-series ever, but I'm not sure I need to double-dip on this.

Bill Needle 06-14-05 02:42 PM


Originally Posted by fitprod
HBO re-formated it a few years back when they lauched HBO-HD...

Also, if you plan on getting into HD-DVD, this is supposed to be an early release....

fitprod

Was there any comparison to explain how the presentation was affected? It makes me wonder since it was originally shot for full frame.

jmj713 06-14-05 02:48 PM

If it's cropped, I'll pass. The current set looks and sounds great anyway. PLus what other extras can they put on there? We'll see, but I very highly doubt I'll be upgrading.

marty888 06-14-05 03:27 PM


Originally Posted by jmj713
If it's cropped, I'll pass. The current set looks and sounds great anyway. PLus what other extras can they put on there? We'll see, but I very highly doubt I'll be upgrading.


My thoughts exactly. It will be fun to see how many of the "OAR purists" think this is a good thing.

JustInsane 06-14-05 03:46 PM

It was suppose to be shown in widescreen, but for some reason HBO ditched that idea when they first aired and put it on DVD.

Dazed 06-14-05 03:50 PM

I may have to pick this up, always wanted to see it but never got around to it.

jmj713 06-14-05 04:02 PM

I don't recall anything about From the Earth to the Moon ever being widescreen. I remember reading lots of articles in '97 or thereabout about the miniseries, I was very excited and couldn't wait to see it. I even remember hbo.com had a cool-lloking site about it. But I don't remember anything about it supposed to being widescreen. As I understand it was shot and broadcast in 1.33:1, and that's the OAR. We'll have to wait for comparison screenshots to confirm one way or the other.

Big Worms 06-14-05 04:30 PM

Might have to finally get this set when it comes out.

Filmmaker 06-14-05 04:37 PM

Hmm, I was curious about that...I guess I'll likely pass (though I'll wait for more confirmation/refutation regarding the original aspect ratio first) because I'm no more interested in letterboxing of 1.33:1 material than I am in pan-and-scanning of legitimate widescreen footage...

eau 06-14-05 04:41 PM

I am also curious as to what the OAR was. If they crop it for WS presentation, I'd give them a second thought before picking it up.

JustInsane 06-14-05 04:56 PM

All the shots I worked on, I was told to keep in mind that it was going to be cropped to widescreen and that the show had been shot open matte to also be cropped to widescreen.

Jason 06-14-05 05:02 PM

Great, I just bought this. At least it was used for a reasonable price ($44.99).

Great series. This and Band of Brothers show the true potential of the HBO series format.

Bill Needle 06-14-05 05:27 PM


Originally Posted by JustInsane
All the shots I worked on, I was told to keep in mind that it was going to be cropped to widescreen and that the show had been shot open matte to also be cropped to widescreen.

So it was shot for widescreen, but HBO left the matte off for the original broadcast. Does that about sum it up? Hmmm, what happens when the "theatrical" OAR does not equal director's intent? What to do! As I posted earlier, I'm letting my big, wide screen decide.

rdclark 06-14-05 06:06 PM

If I double-dip on this, it certainly won't be until the HD version is released and I hav a HD TV.

I'd be tempted at that point; this is a brilliant miniseries, one I've watched several times all the way through.

RichC

ctyankee 06-14-05 06:14 PM


Originally Posted by rdclark
If I double-dip on this, it certainly won't be until the HD version is released and I hav a HD TV.

I'd be tempted at that point; this is a brilliant miniseries, one I've watched several times all the way through.

RichC

Exactly. I've got better things to spend money on then to buy it again in the same format. Particularly with HBO's pricing.

Then again, I probably should have just picked it up at the library, terrific series though it may be.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:54 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.