DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Gladiator Extended Edition - (now rumored to be 8/23, 3 discs) Complete Details! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/418159-gladiator-extended-edition-now-rumored-8-23-3-discs-complete-details.html)

catracho 04-12-05 09:14 AM

Now you have an confirmation ;)

rexinnih 04-12-05 09:24 AM

C'mon, let it have DTS!

fumanstan 04-12-05 09:41 AM


Originally Posted by The Bus
Who's going to sit through a three and a half hour documentary? Man...

I'm sure some people had no problems going through the entire LOTR:EE bonus discs in one sitting :p

animatedude 04-12-05 09:52 AM

what about the price guys?

dick_grayson 04-12-05 09:53 AM

"do you like Gladiator movies, Timmy?"

grim_tales 04-12-05 10:10 AM


Originally Posted by fumanstan
I'm sure some people had no problems going through the entire LOTR:EE bonus discs in one sitting :p

I didnt :p They were great :D (FOTR/TTT).
(Well not quite 1 sitting but almost) ;)

Snowmaker 04-12-05 10:20 AM


Originally Posted by QuiGonJosh
The Theatrical version of Gladiator was 155min. No where near 3 hours, so this version will be 172min. Still, not three hours. If the T2 UE can offer three versions of a 155min. movie and DDEX and DTSES tracks, and a commentary. I think they can squeez Gladiator on there with DTS and a commentary.

OK, so just over 2 1/2 hours. I was guessing. :p

cajun_junky 04-12-05 10:27 AM

I will also be double dipping on this. The rewatchability of this movie is great!! Let's keep our fingers crossed for DTS and a reasonable price.

ShagMan 04-12-05 10:52 AM

exxxxxcelllent, Smithers!

Can't wait for this one!

grim_tales 04-12-05 11:14 AM

If the original theatrical version is included via branching the only reason to duble dip would be DTS (if its not there) or the extras on the old release no? (Which are admittedly very good). My favourite was probably the one looking at the real Gladiatorial Games. :)

digitalfreaknyc 04-12-05 11:16 AM

Are all the extras from the first version on this one?

QuiGonJosh 04-12-05 11:18 AM

Yeah, if it does not include the previous commentary, then it looks like the original 2-Disc would be worth keeping for that and the 'Real' Gladiator Documentary.

I'll probably wait to read a review and see if this version is better, because frankly, I think the Theatrical Version was pretty damn tight in terms of pacing and perhaps a longer version would throw that off. More than likely, unless that documentary is out of this world and the extended version an improvement or at least as good, I'll stick with the Signature Collection set.

Spiderbite 04-12-05 11:25 AM


Originally Posted by QuiGonJosh
I'll probably wait to read a review and see if this version is better, because frankly, I think the Theatrical Version was pretty damn tight in terms of pacing and perhaps a longer version would throw that off. More than likely, unless that documentary is out of this world and the extended version an improvement or at least as good, I'll stick with the Signature Collection set.

I will do the same. I actually thought the original version could have used a 15 minute or so trim so a longer version could be really clunky. Anyone know what the 17 minutes consists of?

Giles 04-12-05 11:32 AM


Originally Posted by brianluvdvd
Anyone know what the 17 minutes consists of?

the deleted scenes from the first edition disc.. :lol:

darkhawk 04-12-05 11:43 AM

is the deleted scenes from the 3rd disk the same as the added 17 minutes of extended version?

Mike Lowrey 04-12-05 11:43 AM


Originally Posted by grim_tales
If the extended version is done via branching I will get it but not if its' not. Nothing worse on a film like that than having a naff marker pop up every time you want to see an extended scene.
Maybe it just means marked as in indicated in the menu? LOTR EE's does this, in the menu chapter selection it tells you which scenes are new/extended.

No, no. The extended footage marker will likely be done the way they were done on the Alien Quadrilogy set. ie. They were selectable within the menu to pop on whenever extended footage was shown. When I watched my set, I watched Alien 3 and Alien Resurrection with that on.

Mike Lowrey 04-12-05 11:47 AM

Anyway, I love it when I'm vindicated for a previously rejected entry for a DVDAficionado listing. :p (I submitted an entry for a Gladiator Special Edition back in February and was rejected.)

digitalfreaknyc 04-12-05 12:17 PM

Does anyone have a scan of the ad? Any cover art available?

Mike Lowrey 04-12-05 12:22 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
the deleted scenes from the first edition disc.. :lol:

Most probably, but at least a few of those scenes were cut due to the level of violence in them, (ie. ratings worries, I'd imagine.) There was extended footage of the Germanic barbarian battle at the beginning, some short cuts of violence in the gladiatorial battles. Others had totally unused scenes that were of character development type stuff. There was also some extension to the escape scene that was cut due to some torture scene or something that's easily been surpassed by almost anything in the Passion of the Christ movie.

Giles 04-12-05 12:24 PM


Originally Posted by Mike Lowrey
Most probably, but at least a few of those scenes were cut due to the level of violence in them, (ie. ratings worries, I'd imagine.) There was extended footage of the Germanic barbarian battle at the beginning, some short cuts of violence in the gladiatorial battles. Others had totally unused scenes that were of character development type stuff. There was also some extension to the escape scene that was cut due to some torture scene or something that's easily been surpassed by almost anything in the Passion of the Christ movie.

so has this new 'expanded' more violent version been submitted to the MPAA? will it be "unrated"?

digitalfreaknyc 04-12-05 12:30 PM

Being "unrated" is no longer the bad thing that it used to be for a movie. Now, they tout it on every cover they can as the UNRATED EDITION!

Mike Lowrey 04-12-05 12:33 PM


Originally Posted by Giles
so has this new 'expanded' more violent version been submitted to the MPAA? will it be "unrated"?

Well, most probably it will be unrated as the theatrical cut was rated 'R' was it not?

Mike Lowrey 04-12-05 12:34 PM


Originally Posted by digitalfreaknyc
Being "unrated" is no longer the bad thing that it used to be for a movie. Now, they tout it on every cover they can as the UNRATED EDITION!

Yeah, like the Blade Trinity: Unrated Edition. :D

mikeporter 04-12-05 01:15 PM

Awesome news. I own the 2D and will DD for the EE. :thumbsup:

TylerDurden_73 04-12-05 01:51 PM

I will probably dd, here's hopin for a dts track.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:06 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.