DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   HD-DVD's not to work cith current HD displays!? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/417438-hd-dvds-not-work-cith-current-hd-displays.html)

brhow 04-06-05 02:01 PM

HD-DVD's not to work cith current HD displays!?
 
according to this article, hd-dvd will not work with current hd displays when the new format is is introduced. and that is just the tip of the iceberg for what they have planned. can this be real? can this be legal?

http://www.dvdfile.com/news/viewpoin...005/04_01.html

bboisvert 04-06-05 02:14 PM

Check the date. April Fools.

DVD Josh 04-06-05 02:27 PM

Well it was posted on April's Fools Day, and the piracy section seems so ridiculous that I have to believe this is bunk.

But as for "legality", of course it is. You will always need specialized players to view specialized contact (e.g., DVD players for DVDs). The only thing the FCC would have control over is broadcast signals.

brhow 04-06-05 02:44 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Well it was posted on April's Fools Day, and the piracy section seems so ridiculous that I have to believe this is bunk.

But as for "legality", of course it is. You will always need specialized players to view specialized contact (e.g., DVD players for DVDs). The only thing the FCC would have control over is broadcast signals.

well, perhaps it was an april fools gag, and perhaps i fell for it.

but, as far as legality, there was alot more going on in there than neeeding a "specialized player to view specialized content". read on.....

Easy 04-06-05 03:06 PM


Originally Posted by brhow
well, perhaps it was an april fools gag, and perhaps i fell for it.
....

The details may have been a bit off but there is a large base of early adopters whose equipment have only component inputs (no DVI or HDMI). Hollywood has lobbied long and hard to have Hidef DVD digital only, shutting out those with component only sets. So while the details of this "funny" article may not be completely accurate there is a large grain of truth to be found there.

hondo21 04-06-05 03:30 PM

The last sentence of the article:

... And if the paranoia I've described in this article were true, I'd have to find a new hobby.
Yes, it is over the top, but a not-too far-fetched extension of some of the actual plans and ideas being floated. Read some of the "real" articles linked at the bottom of this one. The lack of analog component outputs with full HD resolution is a very real prospect, and a depressing one.

DVD Josh 04-06-05 04:06 PM


Originally Posted by brhow
well, perhaps it was an april fools gag, and perhaps i fell for it.

but, as far as legality, there was alot more going on in there than neeeding a "specialized player to view specialized content". read on.....

Yes, there was more going on, however, your post directed nothing towards it. I responded to YOUR post, not the article.

Read on.

paulringodaman 04-06-05 04:42 PM

I believe it wholeheartedly...first update dvds, then tv.....great

DavidH 04-06-05 06:54 PM


When these serialized high definition discs are sold, retailers and web vendors will be required to provide purchase information based on credit card transactions to the MPAA for its database on a weekly basis. Brick and mortar shops will also be required to install networked cameras directed toward cash register positions to capture images of purchasers during sales of high definition discs. The shutter will be triggered either by the bar code scanner or manually by the salesperson if the customer turns away during the scan. That also creates a record for cash transactions. Retailers who do not comply with these anti-piracy measures will not receive product.

Wasn't THIS enough to give it away?

brhow 04-07-05 12:36 PM


Originally Posted by DVD Josh
Yes, there was more going on, however, your post directed nothing towards it. I responded to YOUR post, not the article.

Read on.

actually, my post did reference the other things going on in the article. that is what "that is jut the tip of the iceberg" meant, that there was alot more going on. and my legality questions had to do with the other stuff going on, not the incompatibility of the new players with older display devices.

read on....

Josh Z 04-07-05 07:24 PM

The article was, obviously, an April Fools joke. However, the shutting-out of viewers whose "HD-ready" TVs don't have HDCP-compliant DVI or HDMI inputs is very much real. Anyone who purchased an HDTV in the past with only analog component inputs will not be able to view Blu-Ray or HD-DVD discs in full high-definition.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:15 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.