|
I will probably pick it up since i dont have the other dvd but
am I the only one that thought this movie was Overrated? its a good movie but I thought Troy was more entertaning as historical movies go. people seem to easy on Russel Crowe. since Master & commander was nominated for best picture but it was another boring movie. very accuate but nothing really happens in the movie |
Originally Posted by maingon
I will probably pick it up since i dont have the other dvd but
am I the only one that thought this movie was Overrated? its a good movie but I thought Troy was more entertaning as historical movies go. people seem to easy on Russel Crowe. since Master & commander was nominated for best picture but it was another boring movie. very accuate but nothing really happens in the movie |
I have the current 2 disc SE and the transfer is great as is the audio. I've had the disc for two years now and have yet to watch the special features so unless this new version has a stellar extended cut then I won't buy.
|
Originally Posted by maingon
I will probably pick it up since i dont have the other dvd but
am I the only one that thought this movie was Overrated? its a good movie but I thought Troy was more entertaning as historical movies go. people seem to easy on Russel Crowe. since Master & commander was nominated for best picture but it was another boring movie. very accuate but nothing really happens in the movie |
I like Gladiator. I think its a very well done movie, though looking back I would have given Best Picture to Traffic to that year. As for Master & Commander that movie I absolutely love and should have won Best Picture if not for those silly hobbits. Russell Crowe knows how to pick projects pretty damn well.
|
if it only had the new features i wouldnt care but hearing of a possible extended edition will cause me to double dip on this one!
|
Since I've only seen the Signature Series that I own once, and I'm not likely to ever watch it again, I doubt I'll double dip on this one.
Stew |
Well, I have the two disc special edition from when it first came out. It's got great sound, picture quality is good enough for me, and yeah, unless the packaging is sick, I won't be picking this movie up again. I thought it got pretty darn good treatment the first time around.
|
They said they were making a sequal, so all it may be is previews of the upcoming movie sequal. You guys know like they did to the AMERICAN PIE movies.
|
I decided awhile ago that I won't rebuy any titles I have until blue ray comes out. This is no exception. I can't think of anything else they could add to make me want to rebuy a special special edition.
|
I watched Gladiator for the first time on my new set-up (Panasonic XP30 and ISF'd Sony KP-57WS520) and was a bit disappointed with the video quality...more so than before. It sort of had a digital, compressed look to it. I'm not saying it's a bad transfer, but something about it I didn't like. I wonder if there's a chance for a new transfer with this next version.
|
id buy this movie again for an extended cut
|
Thatll be the only way ill double dip on this one, only its an exteneded cut. And i dont mean like a few mins of camera shots or non-important dialogue either, its gotta be some good concrete stuff. The 2-Dsic version i have now is pretty damn good!
|
I liked Gladiator and thought it was very entertaining, a much better film than Troy too :) I have the 2 disc w/DTS since I bought my first DVD Player in 2001.
Unless this "SE" is Extended w/DTS or something I won't Double Dip :) |
Gladiator Special Extended Edition(3 discs set): June 7, 2005
Sorry, but I cant reveal the source. |
Maybe it'll be something along the lines of what he did with Legend, theatrical and director's cut in one package.
|
Originally Posted by catracho
Gladiator Special Extended Edition(3 discs set): June 7, 2005
Sorry, but I cant reveal the source. |
If it's an extended cut...maybe...otherwise I'm perfectly content with the terrific 2-Disc set.
|
Originally Posted by The_Infidel
Maybe it'll be something along the lines of what he did with Legend, theatrical and director's cut in one package.
|
Originally Posted by scott1598
yes, but "Legend" DC was horrible!!!
|
Digital Bits say NO DTS
We've checked with our sources and learned that, because this title is still in production, this list isn't entirely correct (although the final release should be very close to this). For one thing, the 3 hour and 20 minute Strength and Honor: Creating the World of Gladiator documentary takes up virtually the entire second disc in the set. The other "extras" you see listed under this on Disc Two are actually the titles of chapters of the documentary, some of which have changed since this list was issued. We've learned that a couple of the special features listed were from an early disc proposal and are not part of this set, while you should also expect a few additional special features not yet revealed. Finally, we've learned that there will be no DTS track, owing to the disc space demands of including two versions of the film on a single DVD disc via seamless branching, while still keeping the presentation quality high (an unfortunate but understandable sacrifice that will nevertheless likely be a sticking point with some fans). We'll update you as things become more finalized on this release. Look for an announcement from DreamWorks and Universal on this title sometime in the next few months, along with final disc specs and the official release date. |
That's GOOD news. DTS is already on the first version. This I'm getting only for the extras.
|
If it's a 448 Kbps DD 5.1 EX soundtrack they put on there and they make sure it's mixed well, it won't bother me. But if they downgrade to the lower bitrate because of a lack of disk space, the entire film will be ruined by lacklustre audio. This is a film where the sound is just as important as the image.
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:49 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.