Stop buying DVD because of the new format?
#126
Member
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am puzzled by all the Joe Six Pack references...it seems like the general feeling here is that if u can't really appreciate or afford expensive A/V systems then you are branded an idiot or backwoods Walmart shopping mouth breather and guilty of "holding back" formats or upgraded technology. Maybe these J6P people that are talked about have other interests or responsibilities that prevent them from even thinking about HDTV or HD DVD in the near future...
#128
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: The Pacific Northwest
Posts: 3,422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by abintra
I'd go further and say that most anything that has the negative in top form or can be restored to it will see the improvement. Just because something is in black and white doesn't discount the extra fine detail, depth, and clarity that can be seen with a greater resolution.
Granted the film stock and other technological advances have improved to allow one to get the most out of 35mm film now in comparison to 50+ years ago but I wouldn't go as far to say one will not be able to experience an immediate improvement from something like Casablanca, Citizen Kane or even The Man Who Wasn't There. I'm sure there is someone reading that has seen a restored 35mm screening of Kane or Casablanca that can yield concrete comparisons that that print offers a good deal more than the DVD not just in screen size.
Granted the film stock and other technological advances have improved to allow one to get the most out of 35mm film now in comparison to 50+ years ago but I wouldn't go as far to say one will not be able to experience an immediate improvement from something like Casablanca, Citizen Kane or even The Man Who Wasn't There. I'm sure there is someone reading that has seen a restored 35mm screening of Kane or Casablanca that can yield concrete comparisons that that print offers a good deal more than the DVD not just in screen size.
#129
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 432
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
You'd be amazed what viewing extremely old film can be like in high definition. I've seen old WWII specials (using some of the crappiest film ever) in HD that I was just mesmerized by. The footage was grainy as hell, lots of scratches and blemishes but there were no digital artifacts. Completely free of the blurriness caused by upsampling a low res image on a large HDTV. It was like you were looking at the film stock itself. Very impressive.
#130
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Resurrecting an old but interesting thread I found while doing a search.
One thing a lot of people aren't taking into account - upconversion technology. I think with that number of DVDs people own these days. a big selling point will be how much better the new HD-DVD players can make your current DVDs look. Samsung has some models out now that upconvert 480P to 720P, but my understanding is that the results are good but not overwhelming. If they make strides in this area, 48Op could end up looking almost as good as 1080i - but when 1080P becomes feasible, it will put everything else to shame (at least until they start the next generation 4,000 line format LOL).
One thing a lot of people aren't taking into account - upconversion technology. I think with that number of DVDs people own these days. a big selling point will be how much better the new HD-DVD players can make your current DVDs look. Samsung has some models out now that upconvert 480P to 720P, but my understanding is that the results are good but not overwhelming. If they make strides in this area, 48Op could end up looking almost as good as 1080i - but when 1080P becomes feasible, it will put everything else to shame (at least until they start the next generation 4,000 line format LOL).
#131
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 4,389
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by NCYankee
Resurrecting an old but interesting thread I found while doing a search.
One thing a lot of people aren't taking into account - upconversion technology. I think with that number of DVDs people own these days. a big selling point will be how much better the new HD-DVD players can make your current DVDs look. Samsung has some models out now that upconvert 480P to 720P, but my understanding is that the results are good but not overwhelming. If they make strides in this area, 48Op could end up looking almost as good as 1080i - but when 1080P becomes feasible, it will put everything else to shame (at least until they start the next generation 4,000 line format LOL).
One thing a lot of people aren't taking into account - upconversion technology. I think with that number of DVDs people own these days. a big selling point will be how much better the new HD-DVD players can make your current DVDs look. Samsung has some models out now that upconvert 480P to 720P, but my understanding is that the results are good but not overwhelming. If they make strides in this area, 48Op could end up looking almost as good as 1080i - but when 1080P becomes feasible, it will put everything else to shame (at least until they start the next generation 4,000 line format LOL).
#133
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2003
Location: Birmingham, AL
Posts: 530
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for bumping this NCYankee. It is an interesting thread. I greatly expanded my DVD collection when the used DVD market gained traction. I now pretty much follow a self imposed rule that I will not pay more than $15.99 for any movie. The only exceptions I've made to that rule are for sets like the LoTR EE's, which I paid $19.99 for used, or for TV box sets, which I also pick up used. Lately, I've been able to lower my average single DVD purchase threshhold lower because many places offer buy one get one free deals, etc, and by using Columbia House.
The bottom line is that I have grown very accustomed to not paying a premium for the movies I want, and I'm not interested in paying more than I do now, no matter what the format. So, my upgrade strategy is simple - I will wait until there is one definitive format (and if that means sitting out the HD-DVD and Blu-Ray war for the format that succeeds them so be it) and when that one format establishes itself, I will then wait until the titles I want are available at $15.99 or under due to loss leader sales, the development of a used market, or great CH deals. Then, whenever practical, I will trade in my DVD's towards the new purchases. I say practical, because, as we all know, it is a big assumption to think that the next format release of a flick currently on DVD will carry over all of the commentaries or extras that were on the original (or subsequent) DVD issues.
Also, I get OTA HD channels and while they do look great, I still marvel at the incredible DVD picture quality I get running my DVD's through a TheaterTek HTPC setup via DVI to my Sammy DLP. The difference between the two is not so extreme that I am champing at the bit to throw cash at HD-DVD or Blu-Ray.
The bottom line is that I have grown very accustomed to not paying a premium for the movies I want, and I'm not interested in paying more than I do now, no matter what the format. So, my upgrade strategy is simple - I will wait until there is one definitive format (and if that means sitting out the HD-DVD and Blu-Ray war for the format that succeeds them so be it) and when that one format establishes itself, I will then wait until the titles I want are available at $15.99 or under due to loss leader sales, the development of a used market, or great CH deals. Then, whenever practical, I will trade in my DVD's towards the new purchases. I say practical, because, as we all know, it is a big assumption to think that the next format release of a flick currently on DVD will carry over all of the commentaries or extras that were on the original (or subsequent) DVD issues.
Also, I get OTA HD channels and while they do look great, I still marvel at the incredible DVD picture quality I get running my DVD's through a TheaterTek HTPC setup via DVI to my Sammy DLP. The difference between the two is not so extreme that I am champing at the bit to throw cash at HD-DVD or Blu-Ray.
#134
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Easton, PA
Posts: 1,075
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Kris81
weren't they saying that BY LAW *EVERY* tv made by 2006 should be HD TV ready?
#135
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by NCYankee
Resurrecting an old but interesting thread I found while doing a search.
One thing a lot of people aren't taking into account - upconversion technology. I think with that number of DVDs people own these days. a big selling point will be how much better the new HD-DVD players can make your current DVDs look. Samsung has some models out now that upconvert 480P to 720P, but my understanding is that the results are good but not overwhelming. If they make strides in this area, 48Op could end up looking almost as good as 1080i - but when 1080P becomes feasible, it will put everything else to shame (at least until they start the next generation 4,000 line format LOL).
One thing a lot of people aren't taking into account - upconversion technology. I think with that number of DVDs people own these days. a big selling point will be how much better the new HD-DVD players can make your current DVDs look. Samsung has some models out now that upconvert 480P to 720P, but my understanding is that the results are good but not overwhelming. If they make strides in this area, 48Op could end up looking almost as good as 1080i - but when 1080P becomes feasible, it will put everything else to shame (at least until they start the next generation 4,000 line format LOL).
Most dvd players that upconvert SD have numerous problems. Handshake issues with various displays, macroblocking, white/black crush problems, green push, colorspace problems ....
Upconversion is a great way to improve dvd images but many problems still exist with it. I don't think the first generation HD players will be able to fix all these problems with playing standard dvds at a higher resolution than 480P.
#136
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
I may be wrong here,but dont these DVDs already exist?
I have a few that say they were shot in HD.Like Godsmack - Live (2001) by Image Entertainment/ComingHomeProductions.
Does FILMING in HD not mean it is 'pressed' onto DVD?Because that video I mension above is spectacular on my HDTV!Best 'visual' DVD I have.And since I watch HD,it looks very 'HD' to me.
I have a few that say they were shot in HD.Like Godsmack - Live (2001) by Image Entertainment/ComingHomeProductions.
Does FILMING in HD not mean it is 'pressed' onto DVD?Because that video I mension above is spectacular on my HDTV!Best 'visual' DVD I have.And since I watch HD,it looks very 'HD' to me.
#137
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A DVD can be mastered from a HD source - this produces a better quality image, but it is still only at 480 lines of resolution.
The only HD DVD I am aware of is the HD version of Terminator 2 on the extreme version - it can only be played on Windows media player 9. Unfortunately, this requires you to install PC Freindly / Interactual player, which I refuse to do - it crashed my hard drive when I first got my current computer, resulting in a reformat. Thus, I haven't yet had the pleasure of watching this in HD on my computer.
The only HD DVD I am aware of is the HD version of Terminator 2 on the extreme version - it can only be played on Windows media player 9. Unfortunately, this requires you to install PC Freindly / Interactual player, which I refuse to do - it crashed my hard drive when I first got my current computer, resulting in a reformat. Thus, I haven't yet had the pleasure of watching this in HD on my computer.
#138
Banned
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Los Angeles
Posts: 89
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
why hold off buying now when blu-ray, HDVD comes out that shit will be hella expensive for the players.. toshiba showed one at CES2005 and it say it would retail at $1000 when it comes out. Im guessing that's how much dvd players were when they first came out? Maybe the time to hold off on buying dvd's is in 3 or 4 years when the HDVD/bluray players are at LEAST 2-3 hundred dollars?
#139
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: The Archives, Indiana
Posts: 1,758
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
To me the key to HD-DVD sales will be getting the prices down, and quickly, in order for the average buyer to make the transition. Tell J6P he's going to have to pay $500-1000 for a player and he's going to close his ears immediately. Hell, tell ME that and I'm gonna do the same, call me J6P as well. I've been around long enough to have done my share of jumping on new technologies at their onset.....and it's usually a case of basic usage for high cost....then that technology starts working out its' bugs and lowering it's price to own. Maybe that won't be the case with HD hardware, but I'm betting that to some degree it will be- the first $1000 units being dinosaurs a few years later. The smart money says to just watch the prices fall on the HD hardware, then get onboard. When I DO get onboard I can see me buying select titles I already own on DVD in the HD format, and buying HD discs released from that point on (pretty much) exclusively. The manufacturers would do well to make the transition as painless as possible for the consumer by getting their business quickly with a low cost player and HD discs being priced in the same range as what SD DVDs cost today. I don't think that will be the case for the first year, but DVD has already shown that this is the way to cause the new format to boom.