DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Things learnt from commentaries. (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/394740-things-learnt-commentaries.html)

Hokeyboy 11-08-04 08:37 PM

"Akira Kurosawa's shit didn't stank."

Courtesy of Michael Jeck in the "Seven Samurai" commentary track

Still the best commentary track ever recorded, though...

nemein 11-08-04 11:22 PM

I just learned tonight that Shatner's father died while they were filming the "horta" eps... strangly enough I learned this in a Stargate SG1 commentary (when Peter DeLuise was talking about having to work around Anderson's father dying while filming a particular eps).

Dazed 11-09-04 12:15 AM

Having Richard Donner point out Christopher Reeves Grope in Superman.

aam1 11-09-04 04:21 AM


Originally posted by illennium
And the period goes before the end quote.
Are you sure? Surely the 'Full Stop' belongs to the sentence, not the word.

taronga 11-09-04 10:00 AM

Grammar rules differ from place to place. In Europe the period (or "full stop" as they call it) goes outside the quotation marks. In the US it goes inside them. The latter method looks neater but doesn't make much sense.

If you found this all just fascinating I'd recommend picking up a copy of Eats, Shoots and Leaves. You'll never look at an apostrophe the same way again.

Groucho 11-09-04 10:12 AM

If there's a sentence inside the quotes, I put the puncuation there:

I was at Wal*Mart the other day, browsing their DVD rack. A fellow comes up to me and asks "Hey dude, what's the difference between Widescreen and Fullscreen?"

But if it's just a word or phrase, I put the puncuation outside:

I was at Wal*Mart the other day, browsing their "DVD rack".

Walter Neff 11-09-04 11:18 AM


Originally posted by Groucho
If there's a sentence inside the quotes, I put the puncuation there:

I was at Wal*Mart the other day, browsing their DVD rack. A fellow comes up to me and asks "Hey dude, what's the difference between Widescreen and Fullscreen?"

But if it's just a word or phrase, I put the puncuation outside:

I was at Wal*Mart the other day, browsing their "DVD rack".

Then you're following British grammar rules, not American.

Either way, though, there's no need for quotes around the phrase "DVD rack" in your sentence.

teddydogg 11-09-04 11:28 AM

Shouldn't this be moved to the book forum?.

dick_grayson 11-09-04 11:34 AM


Originally posted by teddydogg
Shouldn't this be moved to the book forum?.

Yeah, no kidding. It's an Internet forum. Spelling/grammar shouldn't be of much concern. Let it go!!!

FantasticVSDoom 11-09-04 11:35 AM


Originally posted by Walter Neff
Then you're following British grammar rules, not American.

Interesting, because that was how they taught us in elementary school...Of course this was in Florida as well, so there you go.

Groucho 11-09-04 11:38 AM


Originally posted by Walter Neff
Either way, though, there's no need for quotes around the phrase "DVD rack" in your sentence.
The point of doing that was to mock Wal*Mart's DVD rack, to show that's it's one in name only.

The Exister 11-09-04 11:40 AM

Seems like theirs a lot of need to explain jokes around here!

Husker 11-09-04 11:54 AM

My favorite commentary has to be Bruce Campbell in Evil Dead pointing out "Now see the monster in this scene hanging upside down? ...See that stuff running out of his ear? That's not a special effect! It's sweat running out of the mask earhole!!!"

There are so many nuggets of trivia like this in the Evil Dead series of DVDs it makes viewing them a real joy.

aukevin 11-09-04 11:56 AM


Originally posted by Mondo Kane
Tom Cruise played an extra that got killed in Young Guns.
that's pretty cool. do you remember what scene?

Cygnet74 11-09-04 01:50 PM


Originally posted by PopcornTreeCt
Warner Bros. still has part of the Casablanca set in storage.
its actually on display right now in los angeles at the grove at 3rd and fairfax courtesy of TCM. they have the front doors to rick's cafe, the letters of transit, victor and ilsa's passports, and sam's piano and bench.

Cygnet74 11-09-04 01:52 PM


Originally posted by aukevin
that's pretty cool. do you remember what scene?
its during the final shootout at the house. he has a huge mustache and hat but he is recognizable if you know to look for him.

Josh Z 11-09-04 06:51 PM

I learned that Siskel & Ebert can go f**k themselves if they don't like Terry Gilliam's movie (Brazil- Criterion Collection).

Burnt Alive 11-10-04 12:06 AM

The events in the Return Of The Living Dead actually did happen.

Walter Neff 11-10-04 01:28 PM


Originally posted by Groucho
The point of doing that was to mock Wal*Mart's DVD rack, to show that's it's one in name only.
I missed the joke, I guess, because I never shop at Wal-Mart. Actually, there aren't even any Wal-Marts close to where I live, thankfully.

Also, I'm stupid.

Pasolini 11-10-04 05:10 PM


Originally posted by Shannon Nutt
That director Roger Kumble's favorite line in <i>Cruel Intentions</i> is when Sarah Michelle Gellar says "You Can Put It Anywhere" :)
And I learned from the same commentary that one can only have 1 1/2 "butt thrusts" in a sex scene to receive an MPAA rating of "R". More butt thrusts than that and its NC-17. The thrusts in question were Ryan Phillippe's, if I remember correctly.

On the topic of Butt Thrusts, I believe the same topic on number of allowable thrusts was brought up in the American Pie commentary during the pie-humping scene.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:04 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.