DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   Arrested Development Censored! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/391013-arrested-development-censored.html)

Samuel 10-16-04 11:42 AM

Arrested Development Censored!
 
I got my season 1 set of Arrested Development on Thursday and watched the first disc yesterday and it's excellent.

The extended pilot episode is uncensored, (the swearing is not bleeped) but all the other epsiodes are bleeped which to me is a disappointment, especially in the episode in which Buster gets expressive with his feeling about is mother Lucille.

Still the set is really nice , lots of deleted scenes and commentary but having it censored is a major letdown, it was one of the things I was looking foward to getting on the DVDs.

joshualane 10-16-04 12:25 PM

It's not like the cover-art says "UNCENSORED COLLECTION", so why would you assume it would be?

Yakuza Bengoshi 10-16-04 12:29 PM

I think the bleeping is purposeful for humorous effect, not censorship, thus is was kept in for the DVD release.

Rizor 10-16-04 12:32 PM

Did the shows air with bleeping?

flashburn 10-16-04 12:35 PM

Ofcourse.


It wouldn't be "uncensored", just like that is the way Reno 911 was released.

calhoun07 10-16-04 12:52 PM

I also think the bleeps are in the episodes for humor purposes. Like Sealab 2021 season one had an episode uncensored as a bonus feature, and you actually find out they weren't saying anything that couldn't have been broadcast, but they put the bleeps in because it was funnier that way.

It doesn't bother me at all. I am glad to have this show on DVD, and if this stops some people from getting it, shame on them.

PopcornTreeCt 10-16-04 01:21 PM

So its not really censored its shown exactly the way it was originally aired.

Gizmo 10-16-04 02:40 PM

Just like with South Park, the BLEEPS are actually funnier then hearing shit every 3 minutes.

clckworang 10-16-04 04:27 PM

I can't imagine the scenes when Buster cusses about his mom being funnier without the beeps. To be honest, I'm not sure he could have said anything that made any sense with that many beeps in a row. Well, he would have to work at it at least.

Jackskeleton 10-16-04 07:33 PM

THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH CENSORSHIP!!! GAHHHH!!*

The studio that produced this show decided to put bleeps in the show. Guess what, if an outside source, say the U.S. Government, jumped in and put those bleeps in there. That would be censorship. As it stands now, it's a creative control choice that is done against no one's will.

NOT CENSORSHIP!

GoVegan 10-16-04 08:25 PM


Originally posted by Jackskeleton
THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH CENSORSHIP!!! GAHHHH!!*

The studio that produced this show decided to put bleeps in the show. Guess what, if an outside source, say the U.S. Government, jumped in and put those bleeps in there. That would be censorship. As it stands now, it's a creative control choice that is done against no one's will.

NOT CENSORSHIP!

Quit infringing on my first amendment rights, jerk.

Groucho 10-16-04 08:39 PM

The censorship issue has everybody so worked up that nobody's made the obligatory "Bragging Thread" comment.

Jaime_Weinman 10-17-04 01:27 PM


I can't imagine the scenes when Buster cusses about his mom being funnier without the beeps. To be honest, I'm not sure he could have said anything that made any sense with that many beeps in a row. Well, he would have to work at it at least.
Yeah, the joke there is based on the fact that all those words will be bleeped. Without the bleeping, there's no joke.

Since all the swearing on the show was done with the advance knowledge that it would be bleeped out, I wouldn't see the point of un-bleeping it; that would be contrary to the way the show was intended to air. Honestly I don't even see the point of taking out the bleeps for the "director's cut" pilot, but as long as the originally-broadcast version is also there, it doesn't matter much.

Jericho 10-17-04 01:55 PM


Originally posted by Rizor
Did the shows air with bleeping?
Fuck No

ThatGuamGuy 10-18-04 09:43 AM


Originally posted by flashburn
It wouldn't be "uncensored", just like that is the way Reno 911 was released.
I'm not sure why you brought it up or what you're trying to say, but one big difference between the two shows was that episodes of 'Reno' aired and then were censored in subsequent airings (at least twice, to my knowledge).

The Antipodean 10-18-04 02:49 PM

They also took out the hardcore nudity which I clearly recall seeing on Fox.

Abob Teff 10-18-04 02:55 PM

Probably the same liberal pinko commy bastards who censored out the name of Uma Thurman's character in Kill Bill . . .


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:17 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.