DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   "I didn't change them, I finished them." (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/384967-i-didnt-change-them-i-finished-them.html)

Mike Lowrey 09-11-04 07:07 PM

"I didn't change them, I finished them."
 
Just saw a FOX Report "G Block" story on the Star Wars DVDs. It had ol' George Lucas at some "celebrity event" whether it be an unveiling event or what, I don't know, but he said, "I was never happy with the original [theatrical] versions...only got about 25% of what I wanted....and now I was allowed to finish them...and I'm much happier now and can stand up and watch them." He also said that the [story] between the prequals and the original trilogies hasn't changed. It was always meant to be like that.


So as we all wait for Ep. III, all these "changes" or shall George say, "finishing touches", may actually make sense after we see Ep. III.

DVD Josh 09-11-04 07:10 PM

I know I saw a Star Wars thread around here somewhere... :D

Mike Lowrey 09-11-04 07:16 PM


Originally posted by DVD Josh
I know I saw a Star Wars thread around here somewhere... :D
;) I know, but hey, I thought it made for a pretty good thread title. :D

PopcornTreeCt 09-11-04 07:32 PM

Well, I'm just happy that Lucas is the only director out there that is totally nuts.

DVD Josh 09-11-04 07:54 PM


Originally posted by PopcornTreeCt
Well, I'm just happy that Lucas is the only director out there that is totally nuts.
If you keep it up, I'll shoot you with my Walkie-Talkie :D

Daniel L 09-11-04 07:58 PM

Argh. Enough. I'm not reading another SW thread until the 21st.

Feathers McGraw 09-11-04 08:17 PM

It's a terrible attitude, because it's a work of art, not a building. You finish buildings. A work of art can never be finished, there's always something you could change.

Best simply to never go down that road.

Seeker 09-11-04 08:25 PM

hmmm - let me apply just a little more paint. I'm not quite satisfied with Mona's smile...

mjlukich 09-11-04 08:36 PM


Originally posted by Seeker
hmmm - let me apply just a little more paint. I'm not quite satisfied with Mona's smile...
<BG> Exactly. And, you know, she's starting to look a little DATED, so let's give her a makeover. Lose the frock, and show a little skin baby. How about a few tats...maybe a barbed wire arm band and a couple of chinese characters???

Mike Lowrey 09-11-04 08:48 PM


Originally posted by mjlukich
<BG> Exactly. And, you know, she's starting to look a little DATED, so let's give her a makeover. Lose the frock, and show a little skin baby. How about a few tats...maybe a barbed wire arm band and a couple of chinese characters???
Hey, why not, aren't metro-sexuals "in" these days?

DonnachaOne 09-11-04 09:05 PM


Originally posted by DVD Josh
If you keep it up, I'll shoot you with my Walkie-Talkie :D
Well played!

Jackskeleton 09-11-04 09:40 PM

Thank goodnes, I thought we wouldn't meet the quota of star wars threads for the weekend.

Altimus Prime 09-11-04 10:56 PM

No, Robert Wise "finished" Star Trek The Motion Picture by completing the unfinished effects shots. Everything that is in the director's edition DVD looks like it belongs there.

Lucas went back and made stupid, pointless, worthless changes to his movies that stand out like sore thumbs.

There's a big difference. Wise did it right with TMP. Lucas did it wrong.

[Gump] And that's all I've got to say about that. [/Gump]

nodeerforamonth 09-12-04 12:29 AM

yawn

Fincher Fan 09-12-04 12:42 AM

I highly doubt those changes he made has added the "75%" of the movie he couldn't do the first time around.

Rubix 09-12-04 01:37 AM

so how does adding luke's scream in '97 and then removing it in '04 fit into finishing it.

i guess he always had a yearning to remove a mistake he made that he never got to add in the first place, huh?

Thunderball 09-12-04 05:42 AM

I am standing by my conviction to not purchase these.

I proudly own the LaserDisc to DVD bootlegs, yes with the audio problem on ESB, and I do'nt care.

I'd rather own them then own the schlock that's about to come out.

Static Cling 09-12-04 05:58 AM

NOT ANOTHER STAR WARS THREAD AGHHGHGHGHGHGHHGG


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:51 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.