DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-3/)
-   -   RATE MY DVD COLLECTION - wat yall think of it (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/380776-rate-my-dvd-collection-wat-yall-think.html)

lb999 08-18-04 10:40 PM

RATE MY DVD COLLECTION - wat yall think of it
 
8 mile
Behind Enemy Lines
Blow
Bringing Down the House
Cabin Fever
Colors
Drumline
Enough
Freddy Vs. Jason
Friday
Friday After Next
From Hell
Gone in 60 Seconds
GoodFellas
Gridlock'd
King of Comedy, The
Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The
Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The
Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, The
Minority Report
New Guy, The
New Jack City
Nothing to Lose
Others, The
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
Recruit, The
Reservoir Dogs
Road to Perdition
Rush Hour
Rush Hour 2
S.W.A.T.
Scary Movie
Scary Movie 2
Score, The
Se7en
Suicide Kings
Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
Traffic
Training Day
Undercover Brother
White Men Can't Jump
X2: X-Men United


wat yall think? any recomendations on movies i should pick up

steelpotato 08-18-04 10:47 PM

8 mile 6.5/10
Behind Enemy Lines 5/10
Blow 5.5/10
Bringing Down the House 3/10
Cabin Fever 5/10
Colors 6/10
Drumline 5.5/10
Enough 4/10
Freddy Vs. Jason 6.5/10
Friday 5.5/10
Friday After Next 7/10
From Hell 7/10
Gone in 60 Seconds 2/10
GoodFellas 10/10
Gridlock'd 5/10
King of Comedy, The 6/10
Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The 10/10
Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The 10/10
Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, The 10/10
Minority Report 7.5/10
New Guy, The 3.5/10
New Jack City 7.5/10
Nothing to Lose 5/10
Others, The 6/10
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl 9/10
Recruit, The 6/10
Reservoir Dogs 9.5/10
Road to Perdition 8/10
Rush Hour 5.5/10
Rush Hour 2 6/10
S.W.A.T. 6/10
Scary Movie 5/10
Scary Movie 2 4/10
Score, The 4/10
Se7en 9/10
Suicide Kings 5/10
Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines 6.5/10
Traffic 8.5/10
Training Day 5.5/10
Undercover Brother 6.5/10
White Men Can't Jump 5/10
X2: X-Men United 3/10

Suggestion = try getting some non-mainstream stuff. You don't seem to have much horror or international stuff so I'm not sure.

TomOpus 08-18-04 10:49 PM

Welcome to the forum! :wave:

There's already a thread going...HERE

But for your collection... sorry for being honest but it's pretty much what I would see at Blockbuster. It's a good start, though.

I'd broaden your horizons:

1) Check out more international movies.
2) Oh, and more horror. Can't have too much horror. :)

lb999 08-18-04 10:51 PM

wtf
 
your really underrating those movies man. you must really not be into mainstream movies.

the others 6/10?

training day 5.5?

white men cant jump 5?

King of Comedy, The 6/10?

Friday 5.5/10?

Score, The 4/10? its better than average

gridlock'd a 5/10?


come on man i know its your opinion but wat the hell kind of movies are you interested in.

MasterCXtreme 08-18-04 10:54 PM

Hooo boy, this'll get interesting...

lb999 08-18-04 10:54 PM

wat horror movies do you recommend. i get

i loved "the others"

from hell was kind of bla

and freddy vs jason and cabin fever were more funny than scary

TomOpus 08-18-04 10:55 PM

I'm not saying those are bad movies. In fact, I own several of them. :up:

You can click on one of my links in my sig to see what I like. My DVDAf collection is broken into folders for easier viewing.

Daytona24 08-18-04 10:55 PM

Dude, asking to have your collection rated is asking for trouble. First off you have less than 50 DVD's and your LOTR's arent even the 4 discs extended cuts (or so I figured from what you wrote). Some would say that you dont even have enough discs to show what type of movies you are really into. Many of the movies seem to be movies that you must really like and want to have in your collection (which is fine) But you are missing many DVD staples ( i.e. The Matrix, which like it or not you almost HAVE to have in your collection). Also TV on DVD is very popular these days yet you dont even have 1 season anywhere.

So all in all, if you just started, if your happy with the collection GREAT, just keep going. But there are people on hear with close to a thousand or more DVD's, they have collections, and you'll know when you have a great DVD collection, because you wont have to ask.

lb999 08-18-04 10:57 PM


Originally posted by MasterCXtreme
Hooo boy, this'll get interesting...
yo man wat do you think of those movies man. dont you think the guy is being a little to harsh i mean half those movies aint that bad.

plus some movies im interested in getting are


deliverance
fight club
predator
scarface
godfather collection
t2

lb999 08-18-04 11:01 PM


Originally posted by Daytona24
Dude, asking to have your collection rated is asking for trouble. First off you have less than 50 DVD's and your LOTR's arent even the 4 discs extended cuts (or so I figured from what you wrote). Some would say that you dont even have enough discs to show what type of movies you are really into. Many of the movies seem to be movies that you must really like and want to have in your collection (which is fine) But you are missing many DVD staples ( i.e. The Matrix, which like it or not you almost HAVE to have in your collection). Also TV on DVD is very popular these days yet you dont even have 1 season anywhere.

So all in all, if you just started, if your happy with the collection GREAT, just keep going. But there are people on hear with close to a thousand or more DVD's, they have collections, and you'll know when you have a great DVD collection, because you wont have to ask.

heres some dvds i never posted

tupac - thug angel
deathrow uncut
tupac - thug immortal
chris rock bigger and blacker
beef

and buffy the vampire slayer seasons 1 - 5

man where can i buy cheap dvds is amazon good place

GMLSKIS 08-18-04 11:03 PM

Other than Lord of the Rings, Pirates and Terminator not my cup of tea so I don't care for it but to each their own.

Daytona24 08-18-04 11:03 PM

I am not sure why you quoted that guy?

Its not that your movies are bad its just that they dont constitute a "collection". The movies you mention you want to get, some of those like Fight Club and T2 have been in my collection for years!

Personally I dont know why everyone needs to have all this horror and international stuff in thier collections but to each his own.

Like I said in my last post, get what you like but NEVER ask to be rated!

asianxcore 08-18-04 11:15 PM


Originally posted by Daytona24
Dude, asking to have your collection rated is asking for trouble. First off you have less than 50 DVD's and your LOTR's arent even the 4 discs extended cuts (or so I figured from what you wrote). Some would say that you dont even have enough discs to show what type of movies you are really into. Many of the movies seem to be movies that you must really like and want to have in your collection (which is fine) But you are missing many DVD staples ( i.e. The Matrix, which like it or not you almost HAVE to have in your collection). Also TV on DVD is very popular these days yet you dont even have 1 season anywhere.

So all in all, if you just started, if your happy with the collection GREAT, just keep going. But there are people on hear with close to a thousand or more DVD's, they have collections, and you'll know when you have a great DVD collection, because you wont have to ask.

I agree. I just think that its your collection for a reason, well simply because it's yours. It's based on your personal tastes, your favorite movies or so on. Having people rate how good your tastes or personal preferences are , is just silly to me. Just buy whatever you feel like. Everyone on these boards has a different taste in movies and so on, and it makes us different/unique by having different collections and so on.

ok im done rambling.

steelpotato 08-18-04 11:36 PM

Yeah I'm into a lot of non-mainstream stuff
Here's a list of recommendations that could go on forever...
Battle Royale
Lone Wolf & Cub
Dead Man
Fando & Lis
Santa Sangre
Black Sunday
Fear & Loathing In Las Vegas
Visitor Q
Gozu
Happiness Of The Katakuris
Dead Or Alive
Fudoh
I Stand Alone
Irreversible
Deep Red aka Profondo Rosso
Suspiria
Phenomena
Zombie
The Beyond
Au Revoir Les Infants

PopcornTreeCt 08-18-04 11:37 PM

Welcome to DVD Talk, here are some guidelines:

1. Michael Bay movies suck, as do Adam Sandler, Rob Schneider, Halle Berry, and a few others I can't think of off hand.

2. foolscreen

3. Not all mainstream movies suck but you must own some non-mainstream ones to prove your street-cred.

4. Luca$, Di$ney

5. Lord of the Rings is the trilogy of worship here. The movies, the dvds, the man Peter Jackson are untouchable.

Follow those 5 guidelines and you will be fine.

steelpotato 08-18-04 11:38 PM

That list is nearly all horror mind you, with a few international titles thrown in, and as some of these are not available in Region 1 its becoming a bit more movie talk than DVDs themselves...

phr33k 08-18-04 11:49 PM

hi what about my collection http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...1&id=zidane349

i have a lot of mainstream crap but im a n00b at collecting dvds just started like 4 months ago, and the fact that im 16 and jobless doesnt help either :) what would you recommend? I really need to get some CC's Any recommenations? And what are some must see foreign films? Im into a lot of different kinds of movies. Also some good horror? no mainstream crap though :P

TomOpus 08-18-04 11:52 PM

Nice list, steelpotato :up:

steelpotato 08-18-04 11:59 PM

cheers tom :), I'm out out here for now.
zidane349, several of those movies I listed I would class as 'good non-mainstream horror'(although those who are into horror would recognise them instantly)
The Beyond
Zombie
Suspiria
Phenomena
Deep Red
Black Sunday
add Shura aka Demons but its incredibly difficult to find even on Region 2; I haven't tracked down a copy yet :(
also The Driller Killer, The Toolbox Murders and Maniac for some good psychos
and the first 2 films in the Hellraiser series, 3rd if you like them(although if you do, hold off on buying as Region 2 is getting a new special edition which may follow in Region 1)

Jackskeleton 08-19-04 12:05 AM

Why I think "Rate my dvd collection" suggestions are silly.

1. Everyone has different taste. Aslong as your own dvd collection reflects titles that you enjoy I have no say on what I would rate it cause it's your taste.. not mine.

2. Half of them turn out to be bragging threads. And when it comes down to it a lot of other people have a ton more dvds and buy more a month then you may have in your collection.

3. Does it matter what I think? will you actually go out and rent/buy something because I may think you may like it? I somewhat doubt it.


In saying that I will rate your collection. Looks like a lot of blockbuster titles indeed. Nothing sticks out as something that the average joe will watch. I doubt I would ever watch half of those movies more then once. Some of them I don't even want to watch that many times.

I would suggest picking up the EE's of LOTR if those aren't it on your list. It seems like you have a mainstream sort of taste.

I can only suggest buying more fox titles. Simply because everyone needs fox titles and I need a bigger paycheck.

TomOpus 08-19-04 12:07 AM


Originally posted by zidane349
hi what about my collection http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...1&id=zidane349

i have a lot of mainstream crap but im a n00b at collecting dvds just started like 4 months ago, and the fact that im 16 and jobless doesnt help either :) what would you recommend? I really need to get some CC's Any recommenations? And what are some must see foreign films? Im into a lot of different kinds of movies. Also some good horror? no mainstream crap though :P

First thing I'd do is replace your copies of Fight Club and Se7en with the 2-disc sets. :)

For horror, it might be tough because of your age. Try Night of the Living Dead Millennium Edition. Try the new release of Fulchi's Zombie.

For Criterions, try Man Bites Dog, The Vanishing and Rushmore

TomOpus 08-19-04 12:09 AM


Originally posted by Jackskeleton
I can only suggest buying more fox titles. Simply because everyone needs fox titles and I need a bigger paycheck.
:D

El-Kabong 08-19-04 01:29 AM

Re: RATE MY DVD COLLECTION - wat yall think of it
 
8 mile
Sucks

Behind Enemy Lines
Sucks

Blow
Sucks

Bringing Down the House
Sucks

Cabin Fever
WAY Sucks

Freddy Vs. Jason
Doesnt Suck

Friday
Sucks

Friday After Next
Sucks

From Hell
Sucks

Gone in 60 Seconds
WAY Sucks

GoodFellas
Doesnt Suck

Gridlock'd
Sucks

King of Comedy, The
Sucks

Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring, The
WAY Sucks

Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King, The
WAY Sucks

Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers, The
WAY Sucks

Minority Report
Doesnt Suck

New Guy, The
Sucks

New Jack City
Sucks

Nothing to Lose
Sucks

Others, The
Sucks

Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
Doesnt Suck

Recruit, The
Sucks

Reservoir Dogs
Doesnt Suck

Road to Perdition
Sucks

Rush Hour
Doesnt Suck

Rush Hour 2
Doesnt Suck

S.W.A.T.
EXTREMLY Sucks

Scary Movie
Sucks

Scary Movie 2
Sucks

Score, The
Sucks

Se7en
Sucks

Suicide Kings
Sucks

Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
Doesnt Suck

Traffic
Sucks

Training Day
Sucks

Undercover Brother
Doesnt Suck

White Men Can't Jump
Sucks

X2: X-Men United
WAY Sucks

any recomendations on movies i should pick up

Well, at least you dont have the Matrix. Thats a point in your favor. But you need to stay away from mainstream stuff - in short, get some movies that dont suck. You need more international films and old classics.

vivarey 08-19-04 02:08 AM

Re: Re: RATE MY DVD COLLECTION - wat yall think of it
 

Originally posted by El-Kabong
But you need to stay away from mainstream stuff - in short, get some movies that dont suck. You need more international films and old classics.
Yes, you obviously don't have much taste. I mean, actually owning mainstream movies on DVD? Don't you know, this hobby isn't about owning what you like... it's about owning the best films according to other people - mostly the pretentious, holier-than-thou type - who you don't know and definitely should not care about. Dude, just sell your collection and DVD player now. It's over.

DVD Polizei 08-19-04 02:15 AM

lb999,

I think you should definitely get Deliverance.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:34 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.