jfrost

I have done "Best of" polls for the first two quarters of 2004... so why not try a Best of 1st half 2004 poll?

There will be no write in votes this time around, since all choices are the top vote getters from the quarterly polls.

***REMEMBER - this poll is for the best DVD (i.e. audio quality, video quality, Special Features, etc.), NOT best movie released on DVD... although I guess the film quality does matter to some extent.

Here are the results for the Q1 vote:

1) Panic Room (SE) - 41 votes
2) Schindler's List - 22 votes
3) Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Platinum) - 21 votes
4) Lost in Translation - 12 votes
5) Futurama - Vol. 3 - 11 votes
6) The Rules of the Game (Criterion) - 10 votes
7) The Commitments (CE) - 8 votes
8T) Curb Your Enthusiasm - Season One - 7 votes
8T) Dawn of the Dead (Divimax) - 7 votes
10) Chappelle Show: Complete First Season - 4 votes

Here are the results for the Q2 vote:

1) The Simpsons - The Complete Fourth Season - 34 votes
2) The Good the Bad and the Ugly (Special Edition) - 29 votes
3) Lord of the Rings - The Return of the King (2-disc) - 25 votes
4) Monster Legacy Collection - 20 votes
5) Freaks & Geeks – 13 votes
6) Kill Bill Vol. 1 – 8 votes
7T) Bubba Ho-Tep – 7 votes
7T) Mystic River (Special 3-Disc Edition) - 7 votes
9T) Master and Commander CE – 5 votes
9T) The Leopard CC – 5 votes

MasterCXtreme

I like how Freaks & Geeks recieved 13 votes for Q2, but wasn't even an option on the poll. Thanks for including it jfrost, it'll get the votes.

jfrost

Bump

PopcornTreeCt

I vote again for Master & Commander Collector's Edition and again its not listed as an option. When the lackluster Lost In Translation is an option.

InnocentBlood

i voted for the Monster Legacy set as everything, IMO, about it is great - the films themselves, the packaging and the extras

Novasonic

Okay, anybody that votes Lost In Translation should be shot in the head, repeatedly!!!!!!

Tony Dvdfan

Another vote for the Monster Legacy Collection.

Quake1028

1.Freaks and Geeks LE
2.Monster Legacy Collection
3.The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly SE

jfrost

I agree... Master & Commander should have been an option. But since it did not receive many votes during the quarterly poll... it did not receive any love this time around.

OldBoy

instead of bumping an obvious dupe thread why not just count the # of votes for your 2 polls and see which has the most...that will give you your answer and not liter the board...just a thought.

ianholm

Freaks and Geeks by far with the Yearbook Edition even farther.

Quake1028

More people have had a chance to buy/watch some of the earlier releases, and their opinions could have changed significantly. If anything, those smileys in every post of yours do more to "liter" the board than anything.

LBCrazyFool

Freaks and Geeks Yearbook for me.

natevines

Panic Room.
The movie is mediocre, but it is easily the most comprehensive DVD of all the choices.
If only they'd give this kind of treatment to better films...

Sessa17

I seem to be alone, but I stick with my same choice as I did for Q1.


The best DVD release of the first half of 2004 is BY FAR the Kill Bill: Uncut Box Set.

Mountain Biker

Freaks and Geeks LE Yearbook, BY FAR

EskimoJoe

I don't own any of these titles. I feel lonesome.