What is the best version of each of the Halloween movies?
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
What is the best version of each of the Halloween movies?
I guess the latest Halloween movies are obvious, but what about most of the earlier ones? So far I've concluded that the 2-disc Limited Edition is the best for the first one, but what about the rest?
Thanks!
Thanks!
#3
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Is the 2-disc limited edition the one with both the theatrical version and the one with extra scenes filmed later by Carpenter for the TV version? I don't believe that one is available anymore, but both of these DVDs can still be purchased separately. That's what I did, so I could own both versions. It didn't cost anymore than the original retail price of the limited edition.
#4
DVD Talk Special Edition
My favorite version is the Divimax 2 disc version...havent really watch the extras yet, but as far as audio/video quality is concerned, that version really impressed me the most.
As far as the sequels go, i had the Goodtimes release of the second one, then bought the Universal version, and i thought the Universal version was better.....unfortunately no extras though.
As far as the sequels go, i had the Goodtimes release of the second one, then bought the Universal version, and i thought the Universal version was better.....unfortunately no extras though.
#5
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: The Pacific Northwest
Posts: 3,422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Currently, these are the best available versions for each of the Halloween films on region 1 DVD:
Halloween - 2003 Anchor Bay DiviMax 25th Anniversary Edition (+ 2001 Extended Edition for "TV" cut)
Halloween II - 2001 Universal version
Halloween III - 2003 Universal version
Halloween 4 - 2001 Anchor Bay version (Limited Edition tin is the same DVD)
Halloween 5 - 2000 Anchor Bay version (Limited Edition tin is the same DVD)
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers - 2000 Dimension version (unfortunately non-anamorphic, and non-Producer's cut)
Halloween: H20 - 1999 Dimension version (unfortunately non-anamorphic)
Halloween: Resurrection - 2002 Buena Vista version
Halloween - 2003 Anchor Bay DiviMax 25th Anniversary Edition (+ 2001 Extended Edition for "TV" cut)
Halloween II - 2001 Universal version
Halloween III - 2003 Universal version
Halloween 4 - 2001 Anchor Bay version (Limited Edition tin is the same DVD)
Halloween 5 - 2000 Anchor Bay version (Limited Edition tin is the same DVD)
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers - 2000 Dimension version (unfortunately non-anamorphic, and non-Producer's cut)
Halloween: H20 - 1999 Dimension version (unfortunately non-anamorphic)
Halloween: Resurrection - 2002 Buena Vista version
Last edited by joliom; 03-30-04 at 10:49 AM.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
even though the H25 Divimax disc has a shitload of extras, I still prefer the 99' THX release of Halloween.
also I wish universal didn't put such a shit DVD together for Halloween 2. 22 bucks for a barebones DVD is dumb.
also I wish universal didn't put such a shit DVD together for Halloween 2. 22 bucks for a barebones DVD is dumb.
#9
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,701
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is the 2-disc limited edition the one with both the theatrical version and the one with extra scenes filmed later by Carpenter for the TV version? I don't believe that one is available anymore, but both of these DVDs can still be purchased separately.
However, I agree with you that they're the ones to get (although the extras make the Divimax version worth buying, the color's way off).
#12
DVD Talk Limited Edition
FYI. Rumor has it Anchor Bay is currently working on Special Divimax Editions of H4 and H5. Some materials for each film have been recently obtained by them for use.
I can say no more.
on topic,
Halloween THX + Extended = Halloween 2 disc L.E.
Halloween 2 Universal
Halloween III Universal
I can say no more.
on topic,
Halloween THX + Extended = Halloween 2 disc L.E.
Halloween 2 Universal
Halloween III Universal
#13
DVD Talk Legend
I would LOVE to get a SE of H4 (and even H5). Kudos to Anchor Bay if they are actually doing this.
If only they could get the rights to the other films, especially H2 and H6. Both of those are screaming for SEs and alternate cuts.
If only they could get the rights to the other films, especially H2 and H6. Both of those are screaming for SEs and alternate cuts.
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Thanks for the feedback.
I recently won the LE of the first film on eBay for $18, so I think that's a great buy.
I was going to wait and hold out for a possible box set one day, but I doubt we'll see that anytime soon, if ever. So I'm just going to create my own collection of the series now.
I recently won the LE of the first film on eBay for $18, so I think that's a great buy.
I was going to wait and hold out for a possible box set one day, but I doubt we'll see that anytime soon, if ever. So I'm just going to create my own collection of the series now.
#16
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Brent, that is a good buy! The LE of Halloween has the same transfer for the theatrical cut that the '99 THX release of Halloween does. They both look fantastic and have the right color.
#17
Member
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 51
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
i just bought Halloween 6 from KoreanDVDs.com.
http://www.koreandvds.com/dvddetail.html?id=7342
This is the only one I know thats anamorphic, and region free to boot. The transfer is out of date, I guess similar to AB 4 & 5.
There is Halloween H20 from Japan, about $30, thats anamorphic, 5.1 and NTSC. Unfortunatly its region code 2, so you just need a hacked player. No PAL to NTSC conversions.
I only stick wish Asian imports that are NTSC. Its easy to get around the region coding, without the confusion of video conversion. You can go mad trying to figure out how to convert PAL and make it look good. Im trying not to put down PAL though. I plan to buy a projector next year with PAL in mind. Its cheaper to shop anywhere than Japan for DVD's, so Korea is a good place for your money.
Speaking of Korea, they are going to get ID4 in DTS.
http://www.koreandvds.com/dvddetail.html?id=7342
This is the only one I know thats anamorphic, and region free to boot. The transfer is out of date, I guess similar to AB 4 & 5.
There is Halloween H20 from Japan, about $30, thats anamorphic, 5.1 and NTSC. Unfortunatly its region code 2, so you just need a hacked player. No PAL to NTSC conversions.
I only stick wish Asian imports that are NTSC. Its easy to get around the region coding, without the confusion of video conversion. You can go mad trying to figure out how to convert PAL and make it look good. Im trying not to put down PAL though. I plan to buy a projector next year with PAL in mind. Its cheaper to shop anywhere than Japan for DVD's, so Korea is a good place for your money.
Speaking of Korea, they are going to get ID4 in DTS.
#18
Originally posted by theDVDfreak
i just bought Halloween 6 from KoreanDVDs.com.
http://www.koreandvds.com/dvddetail.html?id=7342
This is the only one I know thats anamorphic, and region free to boot. The transfer is out of date, I guess similar to AB 4 & 5.
There is Halloween H20 from Japan, about $30, thats anamorphic, 5.1 and NTSC. Unfortunatly its region code 2, so you just need a hacked player. No PAL to NTSC conversions.
I only stick wish Asian imports that are NTSC. Its easy to get around the region coding, without the confusion of video conversion. You can go mad trying to figure out how to convert PAL and make it look good. Im trying not to put down PAL though. I plan to buy a projector next year with PAL in mind. Its cheaper to shop anywhere than Japan for DVD's, so Korea is a good place for your money.
Speaking of Korea, they are going to get ID4 in DTS.
i just bought Halloween 6 from KoreanDVDs.com.
http://www.koreandvds.com/dvddetail.html?id=7342
This is the only one I know thats anamorphic, and region free to boot. The transfer is out of date, I guess similar to AB 4 & 5.
There is Halloween H20 from Japan, about $30, thats anamorphic, 5.1 and NTSC. Unfortunatly its region code 2, so you just need a hacked player. No PAL to NTSC conversions.
I only stick wish Asian imports that are NTSC. Its easy to get around the region coding, without the confusion of video conversion. You can go mad trying to figure out how to convert PAL and make it look good. Im trying not to put down PAL though. I plan to buy a projector next year with PAL in mind. Its cheaper to shop anywhere than Japan for DVD's, so Korea is a good place for your money.
Speaking of Korea, they are going to get ID4 in DTS.
#19
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 3,220
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here it is:
The TV version sucks...dont waste your time...
Simply get the 1999 Halloween DVD and the 25th Anniversary Divimax...the 99 DVD has the better transfer and approved colors and the Divimax has the excellent extras...
The TV version sucks...dont waste your time...
Simply get the 1999 Halloween DVD and the 25th Anniversary Divimax...the 99 DVD has the better transfer and approved colors and the Divimax has the excellent extras...