DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk Archive (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive-54/)
-   -   STAR WARS packaging revealed... (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive/353964-star-wars-packaging-revealed.html)

chrisih8u 03-21-04 04:18 AM

I can hardly imagine walking into Bestbuy and seeing that box availabe to purchase. Seems to good to be true. September cant come soon enough.

wm lopez 03-21-04 06:00 AM

Now someone explain to why would anyone buy a full screen of this?
The full screen tapes have been out, the full screen has been played on t.v.
After all these years wouldn't someone want to see how the movie looked in it's original form?

rushmore223 03-21-04 01:50 PM

Beautiful Packaging!

At least they kept the artwork more in line with the original release art, not really a big fan of the Special Edition Montage art.

Any word on whether this set will include some sort of Episode 3 preview?

fumanstan 03-21-04 01:58 PM


Originally posted by wm lopez
Now someone explain to why would anyone buy a full screen of this?
The full screen tapes have been out, the full screen has been played on t.v.
After all these years wouldn't someone want to see how the movie looked in it's original form?

Isn't that the case with many full screen releases?

The Dude 03-21-04 02:15 PM


Originally posted by wm lopez
Now someone explain to why would anyone buy a full screen of this?
The full screen tapes have been out, the full screen has been played on t.v.
After all these years wouldn't someone want to see how the movie looked in it's original form?

As strange (and unnatural) as this sounds, there are some people (especially with smaller tv's) that don't like "them there" black bars on their movie. I know, I know, I don't get it either, but there you have it.

mikewendt 03-21-04 02:53 PM

great boxes can't wait

drjay 03-21-04 03:05 PM

I'm glad silver is WS, its purdier than the gold IMHO.

atari2600 03-21-04 03:09 PM

damn those are NICE.

Kant 03-21-04 03:51 PM

Look good! Can't wait!
Also this is what might change...taken from another forum...

Alright, some inside info I came across that, through some research, seems to be legit. One of the main reasons I see him as legit is because of this statement made 2 weeks ago about the packaging for the set, which wasn't revealed until last night:

"The DVD's themselves should be in slipcases similar to the prequel designs, with the roman numerals on the sides, but then the entire set could have a slipcover box that says "Star Wars Trilogy." Remove the slipcover and you have a matching set of DVDs."

Those who have seen the box art know this is 100% correct.

Anyway, his quotes of interest about the further OT changes. "I" refers to the "Insider" and "Some Guy" or "SG" refers to multiple people asking questions:

Insider: "Enjoy this [release]. There's going to be some cool surprises."

----------------

Some Guy: "I don't care if Greedo shoots first. But I just wish the scene looked better. If Lucas makes the scene look better then I don't care who shoots first."

I: "You'll get your wish."

SG: "But the thing I want to see the most, even more than fixing Greedo shooting first, is having Ian as Palpatine with new dialog in TESB."

I: "You'll also get your wish."

-----------------

SG: "Those 2 changes (= fixing ANH JAbba & ESB Palpatine) would be appreciated by a large group of fans, I think."

I: "Check and check."

SG: "what about the rumors of a Senate dissolving scene and a pre-explosion Alderaan scene being added to ANH?"

I: "Not to my knowledge."

SG: "Also, at one theater, there was a voice-over of "A long time ago..." as it appeared on the screen."

I: "I think your mind may be blending memories from listening to the Star Wars story album with watching the movie (which did have a narrator speak those lines). To my knowledge, there has never been a voiceover in the films. Maybe some dude was talking outloud to his illiterate kid in the front row!"

SG: "I'd rather they concentrate on fixing errors like lightsabers and bad FX like Jabba than messing with perfect scenes like the ESB Emperor."

I: "Lightsabers, check. Fixing Jabba, see above. Say buh-bye to monkey-woman Emperor. Ian is it. And the scene isn't perfect. It's just a scene. In this instance, continuity is more important and I'm sure the scene will retain the same creepy tone of the original you love. If it doesn't, I'm afraid you'll have to be content with your tapes and laserdiscs."

------------

SG: "Any word on how much the Jabba scene is improved?"

I: "No, other than that it is being done. I assume it will be the same exact scene in terms of length and cuts but with a new Jabba."

----------------

SG: "What about the disappearing and reappearing Tarzan yell?"

I: "That's been there in ever screening I've ever seen. It will probably be in the DVD too, but I wouldn't shed a tear if it was replaced with a more appropiate (and less groan inducing) Wookie yell."

----------------

SG: "Any info on the Rancor?"

I: "Cleaned up matte lines. Not a CG replacement. The contrast in the background plates are being adjusted and recomped in some shots to make them less flat and rear-projection-like.

To the best of my knowledge almost all of the changes are tweaks and fixes like this rather than whole new sequences."

----------------

I: "that extensive list that has was first reported on AICN is bogus. Most of the changes are subtle tweaks and fixes rather than wholesale changes. And my information is incomplete. I know a few things, but certainly not everything."

--------------



Well, that's it. Obviously nothing is 100%, but putting together both Bill Hunt's various statements and hints and this source's statements seems to make me believe this release will be one major step better than the '97 SEs, though fans of the unaltered OT are still going to be disappointed, obviously.

jough 03-21-04 04:07 PM

GREAT packaging. The more I hear about the changes (i.e. fixes) and now that I've seen the packaging, I'm getting more stoked about this release.

A good release about what'll be on the fourth disc should be forthcoming in a couple of months.

It's not surprising that they're releasing info about this a little bit at a time.

I mean, heck, Sept. is six months away!

TomOpus 03-21-04 06:31 PM

There's no way they can make everyone happy but I think many of us will be very happy with this release.

Once we see how great it looks and sounds, we'll be drolling and dancing bananas will spring forth :)

DVDho78DTS 03-21-04 07:18 PM

and these :hump:

whynotsmile 03-21-04 07:21 PM

i sorta liked the design of the 3 different unoffical ones that leaked a while ago a bit more, but i sure as shit aint complaning

TomOpus 03-21-04 07:46 PM


Originally posted by DVD-ho78(DTS)
and these :hump:
:lol: I forgot about "those"

talemyn 03-21-04 09:22 PM


Originally posted by DVD-ho78(DTS)
and these :hump:
Hey their your DVD's . . . you do what you want with them. ;)

JoeyOhhhh 03-21-04 09:26 PM


Originally posted by DVD-ho78(DTS)
and these :hump:
Yours fits in the hub :eek:

Dammit 03-21-04 10:09 PM

Another way to look at it:

Silver screen = movie theater

Movie theater = widescreen

Widescreen = silver

Works for me anyway. Gimme!

Shimmer35 03-21-04 10:13 PM

I have always liked silver over gold so I am glad the widescreen is silver. But I think the both look great. I can't wait to see the individual cases.

KodiakBear 03-21-04 11:20 PM

The box Art looks great!


The gold box Is to bright for my taste, So I'm glad the Widescreen Format will get the Platinum Box.

Fok 03-22-04 12:44 AM

Can't wait for this one, I think the fools screen should be in a brown box.

neocheddar02 03-22-04 02:08 AM

Oh man, that is some awesome packaging. Thanks for the info, I hadn't seen it yet.

Simpson Purist 03-22-04 06:51 AM

Words cannot describe how classy the packaging is. :up:

steebo777 03-22-04 07:18 AM

Very smooth and classy packaging.

PJsig08 03-22-04 07:16 PM

Nice boxes. Long overdue on DVD, hopefully they don't screw it up...but these days, that's wayyyyy to easy to do.

DavidH 03-22-04 07:34 PM

While Lucasfilm semi-screwed up the transfer of Phantom Menace, everything else they have released has been quite good; Clones and Indy probably look and sound as good as they could. I'm sure these releases will too.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:10 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.