DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk Archive (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive-54/)
-   -   Did ROTK win 11 Oscars.... or was it 12? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive/350282-did-rotk-win-11-oscars-12-a.html)

Easy 03-01-04 12:21 PM

Did ROTK win 11 Oscars.... or was it 12?
 
I just read this at HTF posted by Kevin_H:


RETURN OF THE KING did not win 11 Oscars, it won 12. 11 that you saw last night, plus a technical achievement Oscar for "their groundbreaking implementations of practical methods for rendering skin and other translucent materials using subsurface scattering techniques". (according to imdb, http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0504784/awards) If you count that one, and I see no reason why you wouldn't, it is an Oscar, then RETURN OF THE KING broke the BEN-HUR and TITANIC record.
Looks like 12 to me. Why is everyone saying 11?
Can someone explain?
What is your opinion... did LOTR ROTK actually beat out Titanic and Ben-Hur?

Flynn 03-01-04 12:36 PM

I would say yes then, it's the new champ.

chanster 03-01-04 12:50 PM

Titanic probably won some technical ones as well.

I believe companies, not films, win technical awards.

bballing 03-01-04 12:54 PM

That award is not an Oscar, it is a Technical Achievement Award, just like it says.


LOTR won 11 Oscars, not 12, technical achievement awards are a whole different thing.

marty888 03-01-04 12:56 PM


Originally posted by chanster


I believe companies, not films, win technical awards.

That's probably the case - whenever you see them being accepted, it's NOT by anyone from a specific movie.

bardevious 03-01-04 12:57 PM


Originally posted by bballing
That award is not an Oscar, it is a Technical Achievement Award, just like it says.


LOTR won 11 Oscars, not 12, technical achievement awards are a whole different thing.


Not completely true. My understanding was that 3 real true genuine Oscars were given out at the Science and Technical blowout bash. The rest were, as you say, technical achievement awards.

Did LOTR win one of those 3 Oscars is the question?

chanster 03-01-04 01:04 PM

A simple Google search will give you the answer:

http://www.oscars.org/scitech/2003/index.html


Two OscarŪ statuettes were among the 11 awards presented at the gala black tie dinner. Digidesign, a leading manufacturer of computer-based digital audio production systems, received an Oscar for the creation and development of the Pro ToolsŪ digital audio workstation. Bill Tondreau of Kuper Controls also received an Oscar for his significant advancements with robotic camera systems, which resulted in motion control becoming an integral part of the field of visual effects.

The Gordon E. Sawyer Award, also an Oscar statuette, was presented during the ceremony to Peter D. Parks for his lifetime of technological contributions to the industry.
Companies and/or individuals win these awards..not movies.

RoyalTea 03-01-04 01:06 PM


Two OscarŪ statuettes were among the 11 awards presented at the gala black tie dinner. Digidesign, a leading manufacturer of computer-based digital audio production systems, received an Oscar for the creation and development of the Pro ToolsŪ digital audio workstation. Bill Tondreau of Kuper Controls also received an Oscar for his significant advancements with robotic camera systems, which resulted in motion control becoming an integral part of the field of visual effects.

The Gordon E. Sawyer Award, also an Oscar statuette, was presented during the ceremony to Peter D. Parks for his lifetime of technological contributions to the industry.
http://www.oscars.org/scitech/2003/index.html

RoyalTea 03-01-04 01:06 PM

dammit chanster!!! always one step ahead of me.

maybe I could say great minds think alike.

chanster 03-01-04 01:09 PM

Well it is worth checking out because there are pics of Jennifer Garner!!

chanster 03-01-04 01:09 PM

http://www.oscars.org/scitech/2003/garner.jpg

Easy 03-01-04 01:31 PM

So and Academy Award is not necessarily an Oscar. Weird. I had no idea. Thanks for the info.

kliiez8 03-01-04 01:41 PM


Originally posted by chanster
Titanic probably won some technical ones as well.

I believe companies, not films, win technical awards.

You would make Jerry Reinsdorf proud :)

mookiemeister 03-01-04 03:16 PM


Originally posted by chanster
http://www.oscars.org/scitech/2003/garner.jpg
Jennifer is as pretty as ever. That's one good reason to watch the oscar. So we can see Jennifer's super-cute face.

Static Cling 03-01-04 04:23 PM

This has nothing to do with DVDs. And it looks like the question has been answered. Closing thread.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:23 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.