DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk Archive (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive-54/)
-   -   Saving Private Ryan Collector's Set in May! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive/349461-saving-private-ryan-collectors-set-may.html)

djones6746 02-26-04 05:05 AM


Originally posted by PapaWheelie
Hm... so the initial "SPECIAL LIMITED EDITION" release was only "special" and "limited" up until this collector's set is released. :rolleyes:
No doubt....I am really getting tired of this nonsense. Any way possible to capitalize on a movie....they will do it!!! Not sure I really need this edition...especially with so much to buy over the next few months. Maybe I will pick this up used in the future when the price is right.

QuiGonJosh 02-26-04 05:43 AM

All over this one!

Rypro 525 02-27-04 01:30 PM

YES
http://www.thedigitalbits.com/articl...ryanboxdvd.jpg
Morning, folks! We've got more details for you on the extras to look for on Universal's forthcoming Saving Private Ryan: D-Day 60th Anniversary Commemorative Edition, which we mentioned yesterday. The 2-disc set will boast 5 featurettes (including A Look Inside with the Filmmakers, Looking Into the Past: The Research, the Vision and the Screenplay, The Making of a Platoon, Boot Camp for the Cast and Re-Creating D-Day: Omaha Beach). Additional features are TBA.

None of these are on the current editions of the film, so i might double dip on this one

LBCrazyFool 02-27-04 01:34 PM

:thumbsup: Nice!! Guess I will be double dipping on this one... Thanks for the additional information.

DavidH 02-27-04 05:54 PM

Is this a new transfer?

Rypro 525 02-27-04 06:41 PM


Originally posted by DavidH
Is this a new transfer?
i highly doubt it. Why would it need it. the grain and weak colors were all intended by Spielberg.

RyoHazuki 02-27-04 06:42 PM

Ugh. With new features I will be forced to triple dip.

DavidH 02-27-04 06:46 PM


i highly doubt it. Why would it need it. the grain and weak colors were all intended by Spielberg.
I agree. But, just curious. I know there was some edge enhancement in it.

NaturalMystic79 02-27-04 08:26 PM

As much as SPR is a great movie, I will stick with my current DTS release. Plus I'm enjoying Band of Brothers too much right now to think about SPR.

Simpson Purist 02-27-04 08:29 PM

The more I think about it, the less I feel about buying the new version. I just have a feeling the featurettes are gonna have that "slapped on" approach that plagued the Minority Report and Catch Me If You Can DVDs.

Tony Dvdfan 02-27-04 10:58 PM

I am going to double dip on this one...i love watching featurettes, especially for war movies. This is assuming there is no quality difference from the earlier release.

jough 02-28-04 01:50 AM

The transfer on the original disc was great for 1999, but not so good by today's standards.

I might double-dip for a new transfer. Otherwise, I can't see buying this one again.

tacomantt 02-28-04 05:29 AM

Hope these two deleted scenes show up:

http://home.rochester.rr.com/tantalo/spr_del1.jpg



http://home.rochester.rr.com/tantalo/spr_del2.jpg

digitalfreaknyc 02-28-04 07:34 AM

ummmm....yah.

those sure do look....umm....riveting.

tacomantt 02-28-04 08:56 AM


Originally posted by digitalfreaknyc
ummmm....yah.

those sure do look....umm....riveting.

I don't know if you ar being sarcastic or sincere however these two photos DO NOT show up in the DVD or theatrical cuts.

If your complaining about the quality or content of the deleted scenes I posted then I suggest you step back and think about why you are bashing unseen footage.

So yes if my eyes have not seen them they are riviting.

bdrules 03-29-04 01:13 PM

Hmmm...looks like there is going to be separate DTS and DD release again. Amazon has taken DTS out of the details, and over at DVD Town they have menu screens of the discs. Notice the audio options screen.

DD Version

DTS Version

REL77 03-29-04 01:19 PM

Well, i am not suprised they are doing this again. I think everyone will be getting the DTS track as long as its as good as the last versions... I just hope the dont hold anything back this time with extras if you get the DTS

Kal-El 03-29-04 01:21 PM

I may just have to double dip on this one...

DavidH 03-29-04 01:25 PM

No new transfer = No sale

Dammit 03-29-04 01:30 PM

Anybody else find it mildy amusing how everytime HD-DVD comes up most people chime in saying they won't upgrade but then tons of people will double or even triple dip for something like this? :)

Just an observation.

talemyn 03-29-04 02:09 PM

Still trying to figure out if this will have the old special features as well as the new ones . . . :hscratch:

Josh Z 03-29-04 02:12 PM


Originally posted by tacomantt
I don't know if you ar being sarcastic or sincere however these two photos DO NOT show up in the DVD or theatrical cuts.

If your complaining about the quality or content of the deleted scenes I posted then I suggest you step back and think about why you are bashing unseen footage.

Do we know for a fact that those are actually from deleted scenes, and aren't just publicity photos taken during production where the actors were asked to pose?

Simpson Purist 03-29-04 02:54 PM


Originally posted by talemyn
Still trying to figure out if this will have the old special features as well as the new ones . . . :hscratch:
Judging by these menu shots, these seem to be all new extra features.

Also it seems that there will be separate DTS and Dolby Digital versions. I'm getting the impression that there won't be any substantial improvments in terms of video/audio quality (unless Dreamworks suddenly saw the light and is doing full bitrate DTS).

jough 03-29-04 02:59 PM

Yes, the DTS version will also have a DD 5.1 track (as is mandatory) in English, whereas the DD version will have a French 5.1 DD track as well.

The extras will be all new and will not contain the two features found on the previous DD release.

As I have the Dolby version of the first disc (it was one of the discs I bought with the player back when I got my first DVD player) I'll probably get the DTS version.

This is one worth double-dipping on.

And I know what you mean - once HD-DVD players are cheap I can't imagine anyone won't upgrade, especially if they release fairly bare-bones DVD releases and HD-DVD releases simultaneously.

Who else hopes that they won't change the packaging for HD-DVD? I love the keepcase (although I suppose they could be "shorter" since there's a lot of wasted space on the inside).

Kahz 03-29-04 03:07 PM

Back when Amazon still showed the features for their DVDs, the listing for the box set (with the two extra WW2 DVDs) claimed the SPR disc with the set had an "exclusive DTS track."

I'm assuming that the new DTS version will only be available in the set and the Dolby 5.1 will be the only new standalone version.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:31 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.