For those with HDTVs - DVD with best Picture Quality?
#1
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
For those with HDTVs - DVD with best Picture Quality?
I just bought my 1st HDTV (Zenith C32V37) a week ago. After going through about 15 of my DVDs, IJ The Last Crusade came out to be my favorite as far as video quality goes for a live action movie.
Live Action:
1. IJ and the Last Crusade (Wow! Detail everywhere and the colors were almost to colorful)
2. The Fifth Element
Star Wars II (very good, but I thought it could have been better)
X-men 2 (I thought it was dark and had too much grain in shadow areas)
LOTR TTT (have not tried yet, but I will try later this week)
Animated:
1. Monster's Inc (about as clear as a DVD can get)
2. Toy Story (just as good as MI, but the hair on Sully's is what gave Monster's Inc #1 in the animated dept
Any other movies that someone has played on their HDTV that gave them the highest picture quality possible for a DVD playing on an HDTV?
Thanks
Live Action:
1. IJ and the Last Crusade (Wow! Detail everywhere and the colors were almost to colorful)
2. The Fifth Element
Star Wars II (very good, but I thought it could have been better)
X-men 2 (I thought it was dark and had too much grain in shadow areas)
LOTR TTT (have not tried yet, but I will try later this week)
Animated:
1. Monster's Inc (about as clear as a DVD can get)
2. Toy Story (just as good as MI, but the hair on Sully's is what gave Monster's Inc #1 in the animated dept
Any other movies that someone has played on their HDTV that gave them the highest picture quality possible for a DVD playing on an HDTV?
Thanks
#8
Member
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Corona CA
Posts: 61
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Rypro 525
some scene's of Se7en seem offily grainy to me.
some scene's of Se7en seem offily grainy to me.
#11
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally posted by TREX1993
In addition to the ones you listed, Finding Nemo looks fantastic
In addition to the ones you listed, Finding Nemo looks fantastic
#15
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by abintra
How much more resolution does HDTV's offer for DVD's compared to SDTV's?
How much more resolution does HDTV's offer for DVD's compared to SDTV's?
Regarding the red-Nemo issue BJacks mentioned, find out how to turn off red push and that will cease to be an issue.
All that said, I would have to say FOTR: SE.
Last edited by colossus; 01-27-04 at 10:45 AM.
#18
Suspended
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: You have moved into a dark place. It is pitch black. You are likely to be eaten by a grue.
Posts: 4,533
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Rypro 525
some scene's of Se7en seem offily grainy to me.
some scene's of Se7en seem offily grainy to me.
Some scenes in Se7en seem awfully grainy to me.
Don't forget Se7en used a bleach bypass process to make some of the silver remain on the negative, resulting in that gorgeous "stressed" effect. It's *supposed* to look like that, and it looks wonderful.
In addition to those mentioned, I'd recommend "Pearl Harbor: Vista Series," "Lawrence of Arabia: Superbit," and "Pirates of the Caribbean."
Congratulations on your new display!
#19
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally posted by DavidH
Colussus,
Can't you have the HDTV do the progressive part of it...not relying on the DVD player?
Colussus,
Can't you have the HDTV do the progressive part of it...not relying on the DVD player?
The decoding still needs to be done on the DVD player- and this is where you need to spend a lot of time researching which player to buy. The DVD-2900 is expensive, you can get a Panasonic with the same chipset for ~$600 less.
The difference in DVD player quality from SD4700 to DVD2900 was very obvious. Before I hooked up the DVD2900, I was watching AoTC and thought that it was time to do a manual convergence on my TV. After I hooked up the 2900, it didn't look like I needed to do it anymore. I did anyway and the picture was incredible.
How good? A while back HBO-HD was showing AoTC. I was viewing it on with a Sony SAT HD-300 receiver (in HD).
The anamorphic DVD looked better. Everybody in the room- my GF and her 11-year-old son included- agreed.
Last edited by colossus; 01-27-04 at 10:56 AM.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 432
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by BJacks
Unless you have a RPTV, in which case the bright reds (especially around the clown fish) may cause a problem for many sets.
Unless you have a RPTV, in which case the bright reds (especially around the clown fish) may cause a problem for many sets.
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 432
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by colossus
How good? A while back HBO-HD was showing AoTC. I was viewing it on with a Sony SAT HD-300 receiver (in HD).
The anamorphic DVD looked better. Everybody in the room- my GF and her 11-year-old son included- agreed.
How good? A while back HBO-HD was showing AoTC. I was viewing it on with a Sony SAT HD-300 receiver (in HD).
The anamorphic DVD looked better. Everybody in the room- my GF and her 11-year-old son included- agreed.
To answer the original poster's question. All of the Pixar stuff looks incredible but also, Ice Age is surprisingly good at times. They did a wonderful job with the lighting. For live action, Fifth Element Superbit is still my favorite.
#22
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
Originally posted by abintra
How much more resolution does HDTV's offer for DVD's compared to SDTV's?
How much more resolution does HDTV's offer for DVD's compared to SDTV's?
1. You can get a bigger screen and not loose resolution
2. You need to make sure you turn on progressive scan on the DVD player. It did not make as big of difference as I thought it would, but I can tell that details are a little sharper with it turned on. HDTV can turn the signal into progressive, but it is better to let the DVD player do the conversion.
3. Make sure DVD player has 3:2 Pulldown
4. Tell you DVD player you are using a 16:9 TV
-If you are using a 4:3 (which is the HDTV I have), then turn on the 16:9 mode.
5. Adjust all the contrast, brightness, color, tint...
-No HDTV comes out of the box ready to go, they all need to be adjusted
6. The HDTV will only be as good as the quality of the DVD you use:
-You will be gratiful for all the DVDs that have high video quality, HDTV will show you all the good and bad.
Overall HDTV does make a difference, and even more if you use the steps abvove.
#23
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 432
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Iron_Giant
2. You need to make sure you turn on progressive scan on the DVD player. It did not make as big of difference as I thought it would, but I can tell that details are a little sharper with it turned on. HDTV can turn the signal into progressive, but it is better to let the DVD player do the conversion.
2. You need to make sure you turn on progressive scan on the DVD player. It did not make as big of difference as I thought it would, but I can tell that details are a little sharper with it turned on. HDTV can turn the signal into progressive, but it is better to let the DVD player do the conversion.
#25
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Thread Starter
I watched "The Mask of Zorro" Superbit for the 1st time on HDTV and it really gave me a deeper appreciation for DVDs that have been created with much care given to the video quality.
This may become my favorite "Live Action" video/sound demo DVD. IJ and the Last Crusade also has great video quality, but TMoZ has the best sound and video combo I have viewed yet.
Thanks for all the suggestions
This may become my favorite "Live Action" video/sound demo DVD. IJ and the Last Crusade also has great video quality, but TMoZ has the best sound and video combo I have viewed yet.
Thanks for all the suggestions