DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk Archive (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive-54/)
-   -   What Commentaries Should I Watch? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive/337377-what-commentaries-should-i-watch.html)

blazincaucazn 12-24-03 09:27 AM

What Commentaries Should I Watch?
 
Well, I've actually never sat down and watched the commentary for any DVD That I own. Mostly because I barely have time just to watch the movie, but with Christmas break here I have some extra time on my hands and was wondering if anyone could recommend which commentaries I should watch. You can see my collection in my signature, thanks.

RobCA 12-24-03 09:46 AM

I looked through your collection on DVDAf (nice collection, by the way!) and while I'm sure you've got some great commentaries in there, and there are some that I've been meaning to listen to myself, the only ones I've actually listened to personally are the ones on Family Guy, which I'd highly recommend. There are two on each disc; I found all of them to be extremely informative and entertaining. Oh, and I also listened to the one on Liar Liar, but I thought that one was just okay.

Rob

milo bloom 12-24-03 09:48 AM

12 Monkeys
Lord of the Rings EE
Any of the Kevin Smiths
X2 is pretty good, don't have the X 1.5 but probably good

vegasbaby 12-24-03 10:21 AM

I personally havent Watched any commentary.

I have listened to a few, though. ;)

Terry Gilliam's commentaries are always great (12 Monkeys, etc.).

nemein 12-24-03 10:25 AM

12 Monkeys
Apollo 13
Donnie Darko (was just ok but if you like the movie it may be interesting)
X-Men

If you subscribe to Netflix it's probably worth it to get the SE versions of Black Hawk Down and LotR and listen to those as well.

marty888 12-24-03 10:33 AM

Both <b>Fight Club</b> and <b>Seven</b> have multiple commentary tracks that are excellent.

<b>Phone Booth</b> has a fine Joel Schumacher commentary.

And check out <b>Jerry Maguire</b> where you can watch the participants as the commentary unfolds - unusual and fun.

PalmerJoss 12-24-03 10:37 AM

Almost Famous
Boogie Nights
Fight Club--the Cast Commentary
Any of your Kevin Smith movies

Movie_Man 12-24-03 10:52 AM


Originally posted by nemein

If you subscribe to Netflix it's probably worth it to get the SE versions of Black Hawk Down and LotR and listen to those as well.

FYI: Netflix does not carry these SE titles.

basketb 12-24-03 10:56 AM

Almost Famous is definitively worth your time.
So is Natural Born Killers.
If you want to kill some time, I'd say listen to all commentaries of Fight Club.

celluloidwisdom 12-24-03 11:18 AM

Texas Chainsaw Massacre.

El-Kabong 12-24-03 12:14 PM

Ah, that's easy -

Back to the Future. Bob Z is a intresting commentator, and it's a question/answer format instead of him just talking. And it doesnt go for the entire movie, so they're easy to sit through.

The Family Guy commentaries are funny as hell because sometimes the cast members start ripping on each other in character.

Gov'ner Ah-nold is a laugh riot on any commentary he's done, including Total Recall. Not quite as good as his Conan commentary, but still a great listen.

fryinpan1 12-24-03 12:41 PM

I suggest:
Fight Club
Jackass
Ocean's Eleven
Old School
Snatch

MovieMaster11 12-24-03 12:48 PM

Rules of Attraction with the Carrot top commentary track is hilarious i highly reccomend it

Janitor 12-24-03 02:41 PM

"Cannibal, the Musical" - Best commentary ever.

shawagg 12-24-03 04:51 PM

You want to know what commentaries are the worst? The 9th Gate and the Simpson's. God awful! The Simpson's spend all there time laughing and never saying anything-- like the Chasing Amy one but without any enjoyment. And the 9th Gate was 90mins of a guy smoking. Oh and Frankenmiller was a disapointment for me as well.

The best one I've found are any ones that Rodger Ebert does. These guy really knows his stuff and you get a real sense that he loves movies. I didn't like him reviews much and I liked him even less, but after the first time I heard one of his comantaries I took it all back.

bunkie42 12-24-03 11:59 PM

Good Will Hunting I thought was good, but that might be just because it's my favorite!

SlangNRocks 12-25-03 02:52 AM

I know I'll flamed for even mentioning it, but I like the commentaries by Michael Bay on the Rock, Armageddon, and Bad Boys. Ben affleck on the Armageddon commentary is funny.

Phuzbox 12-25-03 09:09 AM

Mallrats

CephalicCarnage 12-25-03 06:43 PM

This Is Spinal Tap has one of the best commentaries I have ever heard. Aside from it being a very funny movie with very memorable characters, the commentary is done by the 3 main actors, in character!

It makes for hilariously refreshing take on commentaries, and is just as, if not more funny than the original movie.

TCG 12-26-03 04:40 AM

any Kevin Smith
Fight Club all
Se7en
LOTR all
The Mummy (Fraser)
any Schwarzennegger
Something About Mary
any Ebert
any Jim Cameron
any Coppola
any William Friedkin
Apollo 13 both
The French Connection both
Black Hawk Down all
any Oliver Stone

Caliking 12-26-03 05:14 AM

Usual Suspects started it all for me :)

Drexl 12-26-03 06:07 PM


Originally posted by vegasbaby
I personally havent Watched any commentary.

I have listened to a few, though. ;)

Well, there are a few you can watch:

Ghostbusters
The Goonies
Mallrats
Glory SE

sade 12-26-03 06:12 PM


Originally posted by CephalicCarnage
This Is Spinal Tap has one of the best commentaries I have ever heard. Aside from it being a very funny movie with very memorable characters, the commentary is done by the 3 main actors, in character!

It makes for hilariously refreshing take on commentaries, and is just as, if not more funny than the original movie.

I cannot agree more, it's like watching another 'Spinal Tap' movie :)

Sade

PS: Is your nickname refering to the grindcore band from relapse ?

CephalicCarnage 12-26-03 06:30 PM


Originally posted by sade
PS: Is your nickname refering to the grindcore band from relapse ?
Why yes it is, Im a big fan.
And your nickname?
Is it refering to this Sade?
http://www.sondexter.com/sadeworld/images/sade11-s.jpg

and Edit: to stay on topic, I second "Cannibal! The Musical"

NaturalMystic79 12-26-03 06:40 PM

Texas Chainsaw Massacre (Tobin Hopper & Gunner Hansen)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:21 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.