DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Talk Archive (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive-54/)
-   -   Shrek single disc edition Full Screen only... (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk-archive/317926-shrek-single-disc-edition-full-screen-only.html)

Duality 09-15-03 12:32 PM

Shrek single disc edition Full Screen only...
 
I visited Targ*t last weekend and saw the new single disc Shrek, which is Full Screen only! I immediately searched the children's video section for the original two disc Widescreen copy and found it!

I've been procrastinating with regard to this title; now I own it. What's up? Is the studio discontinuing the Widescreen inclusive two disc set? I hope not.

DonnachaOne 09-15-03 12:54 PM

http://www.dvdtalk.com/forum/showthr...ek+single+disc

Duality 09-15-03 01:28 PM

Thanks for the link...
 
However, I believe it is important to emphasize the fact that this disc is Full Screen! The previous post simply starts as a release announcement.

DonnachaOne 09-15-03 02:10 PM

From the other thread:


Originally posted by RobCA
It's a single disc version. According to DVDPlanet, it's fullscreen.

Rob

I think it's pretty much common knowledge by now anyway. Your post's still appreciated though.

Duality 09-15-03 02:21 PM

Sometimes I'm the last to know. :(
 
Thank you for being polite.

Rogue588 09-15-03 03:16 PM

[resurrecting the 'ol Katzenburg v. Disney drama]

hmm...yet Disney has recently been attempting to eduate the commonfolk about the differences 'tween w i d e s c r e e n and fool frame..

and putting out some damn good DVDs too..

wonder if this'll be incorporated into Shrek II..

[/resurrecting the 'ol Katzenburg v. Disney drama]

PixyJunket 09-15-03 03:34 PM

What do you miss in the full screen Shrek? A fart?

Drexl 09-15-03 03:51 PM

Another bad thing is that the DTS soundtrack and the worthwhile extras in the set like the commentary were on the disc with the widescreen version -disc 2. (I'm assuming this is just a repackaging of the first disc.)

Duality 09-16-03 11:05 AM

You're probably right.
 
Dreamworks used to be so dependable with extras and OAR.

Duality 09-17-03 10:10 AM

One more thing...
 
Does anyone know if a Dreamworks representative (or any other rep for that matter) frequents these boards regularly?

actyper 09-17-03 11:14 AM

Discontinue the 2disc. Better news for me. If you don't have the old version already, than this new version is perfect for you.

DonnachaOne 09-17-03 11:27 AM

Dreamworks hasn't discontued the 2-Disc - it, like the Gladiator and Minority Report packages, are still available in 1-disc or 2-disc versions. A lot of retailers simply choose to stock the cheaper single-discers.

Drexl 09-17-03 11:38 AM

I wonder if this wasn't just a mistake.

All of the other one-disc versions of Dreamworks' and other studios' two-disc titles repackaged the first disc out of the two. Maybe whoever made the decision to do that for all of the titles they were reissuing as one-disc versions didn't realize that Shrek was unlike the others in that it had a different transfer on each disc, instead of only extras on the second disc. If they did realize that, maybe they just assumed the first disc had the widescreen version which it should have had anyway.

Duality 09-17-03 01:24 PM

Re: One more thing...
 

Originally posted by Duality
Does anyone know if a Dreamworks representative (or any other rep for that matter) frequents these boards regularly?
Hello People!:) Martin Blythe frequents DVD Talk. Anyone else?

DonnachaOne 09-17-03 01:28 PM


Originally posted by Drexl
I wonder if this wasn't just a mistake.

All of the other one-disc versions of Dreamworks' and other studios' two-disc titles repackaged the first disc out of the two. Maybe whoever made the decision to do that for all of the titles they were reissuing as one-disc versions didn't realize that Shrek was unlike the others in that it had a different transfer on each disc, instead of only extras on the second disc. If they did realize that, maybe they just assumed the first disc had the widescreen version which it should have had anyway.

Nah. Minority Report goes so far as to drop the dts. And I'm sure they had to get rid of those things that say "more features on disc2".


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:42 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.