DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Reviews and Recommendations (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations-8/)
-   -   Essential John Wayne DVD's (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations/574460-essential-john-wayne-dvds.html)

smurr05 05-29-10 04:01 PM

Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Believe it or not I've never picked up a John Wayne disc until I recently got Stagecoach-Criterion Collection. I know True Grit is one of the biggies but can you guys reccomend any other top Wayne discs one should have for essential viewing...thanks:)

jmu878 05-29-10 04:15 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
My Top 3:

Rio Bravo
Man Who Shot Liberty Vance
The Searchers

Fist of Doom 05-29-10 04:18 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 

Originally Posted by jmu878 (Post 10185042)
My Top 3:

Rio Bravo
Man Who Shot Liberty Vance
The Searchers

:up:

Fielding Mellish 05-29-10 04:24 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 

Originally Posted by jmu878 (Post 10185042)
My Top 3:

Rio Bravo
Man Who Shot Liberty Vance
The Searchers

:up::up:

Ginwen 05-29-10 04:40 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
My Top 3

Red River
The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
The Searchers

mdnitoil 05-29-10 04:55 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
If I were to venture outside the established top 3, I wouldn't waste much time before getting to The Quiet Man.

NoirFan 05-29-10 05:21 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Not a classic by any means, but I've always enjoyed El Dorado, James Caan's regrettable 'Chinaman' routine aside. Among those not mentioned so far, Donovan's Reef, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon and Long Voyage Home are worth checking out.

Paul Mavis 05-29-10 06:29 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Some of his later stuff is seriously underrated:

Mark Rydell's The Cowboys has one of his best performances:

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/28213...e-edition-the/

And he's amazing in Don Siegel's The Shootist. And you're right about True Grit; it's essential:

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/28173...ition/?___rd=1



Those are must-haves for the Duke.

arminius 05-29-10 06:42 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Sands of Iwo Jima, a very good WWII movie.

obscurelabel 05-29-10 09:17 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 

Originally Posted by mdnitoil (Post 10185082)
If I were to venture outside the established top 3, I wouldn't waste much time before getting to The Quiet Man.

Great movie, lousy picture quality on the Republic DVD.

Hondo is lean and mean.

I've always liked McLintock! even though there's a lot of silliness in it -- I think it's the best (only?) comic role I've seen of his (I don't care for Donovan's Reef at all).

I love the chemistry he has with Patricia Neal in In Harm's Way but don't care for the rest of the movie. I don't really have an excuse for not yet watching Operation Pacific where he also costarred with Neal, as it's sitting beside me unopened as I type.

Trevor 05-30-10 07:41 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Good ideas for DVDTalk's upcoming Historical (War/Western/etc) Challenge!

wakwak007 05-30-10 10:10 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
My favorite has to be: Big Jake

Rex Power Colt-Robot Man 05-30-10 08:16 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Chisum! John Chisuuuum!

Boba Fett 05-31-10 10:19 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
That one that doesn't star a giant buffoon.

wendersfan 06-01-10 05:48 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 

Originally Posted by jmu878 (Post 10185042)
My Top 3:

Rio Bravo
Man Who Shot Liberty Vance
The Searchers

The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance isn't ideal if you're looking for a lot of John Wayne, since he takes a back seat to James Stewart in that one. I would recommend She Wore a Yellow Ribbon instead. Bear in mind I love both movies.

Joseph B 06-01-10 08:32 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Another vote here for "The Searchers" and "The Cowboys" ...

TANK 06-01-10 09:58 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
some others to watch-

Allegheny Uprising

Fort Apache

The Fighting Kentuckian

Albert71292 06-01-10 10:11 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
For his first role in a major film, I'd recommend "The Big Trail" (1930), also it was one of the first "widescreen" movies.

NoirFan 06-01-10 09:51 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
Did John Wayne ever not play a cowboy or a soldier?

wendersfan 06-01-10 10:34 PM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 

Originally Posted by NoirFan (Post 10189485)
Did John Wayne ever not play a cowboy or a soldier?

Branigan and McQ are two late-career movies where he played a cop or detective. Then of course there's The Quiet Man.

dispatcherdean 06-02-10 01:21 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
The Conqueror...but make sure your really drunk first, then it's a riot!!!!

creekdipper 06-02-10 02:26 AM

Re: Essential John Wayne DVD's
 
(1) The Searchers
(2) Red River
(3) The Quiet Man (needs a good Criterion-type remastering, though)

All three are both superb movies and fine acting from Duke in his prime. Growing up with Wayne's later films in the sixties & early seventies (War Wagon, Undefeated, Rio Lobo, The Alamo, Green Berets), I never realized that he could actually act until getting to see his earlier films...especially when directed by a firm hand that Wayne respected (John Ford, Howard Hawks, etc.).

Hard to keep it to just three. I would also think that the following are "essential" Wayne, even if they don't make the top three:

The "Cavalry Trilogy": Fort Apache, Rio Grande, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon.
Rio Bravo.
Man Who Shot Liberty Valance.
Hondo.
McClintock.
Sands of Iwo Jima.
The Shootist (great final performance by Duke).

So many others...They Were Expendable & some of the other WWII films...even minor westerns such as "Dakota" or "Big Jake" are lots of fun.

True Grit is an 'essential' performance by Wayne, but IMHO, Glen Campbell almost single-handedly ruins the movie. Hard to fathom casting a novice pop singer as a lead character trying to hold his own against the likes of Wayne, Robert Duvall, Dennis Hopper, Strother Martin, and a host of character actors. Campbell's stiff, awkward attempt is enough to make anyone "Grit" his teeth trying to get past him. Also, the movie actually skimps a little on some of the book's most exciting scenes (the snake pit, for instance). It'll be interesting to see what the Coen Brothers do with the remake starring Jeff Bridges, Matt Damon, and (I think) Josh Brolin.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:46 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.