DVD Talk review of 'Frank Miller's Sin City'
 

I read Aaron Beierle's DVD review of Frank Miller's Sin City at http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=17141 and...

Yes Aaron! I wanted to see a high rating. Great review and I can understand why it didn't get Collector's because there are no extras.

And as the reviews keep coming in...all of them are WoW! IGN gave it 10/10 for movie and video. 9/10 for sound and we know the extras story.

Has a DVD got the Collector's based soley on the movie?

Hanzo the Razor got Collector's Edition despite no rating in the extras department....

angels in america didnt' have any extras either and it got a "collectors series as well.

I placed Der Untergang in the Collector's series (my one and only pick so far to get the nomination) based predominantly on the quality of the movie. I am a realist and understand that the film is not likely to get the lavish treatment the German distribs Constantin Film AG did for the German/Swiss market. But all things considered this is indeed a phenomenal film, unlike anything I have seen in the last 20 years, and I happen to have seen quite a few. With other words, I went against my principles (in terms of extras) and gave it the highest ranking.

Here's the review:
http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/read.php?ID=17098

Pro-B

No sound.

I picked up Sin City yesterday and I have no sound from the movie -- although the menu (stereo) has music. When I start the movie, my A/V controller frashes "no data."

Am I the only one with this problem? The package says DTS, and my system wants AC-3, but I have never had trouble with any format of DVD before.

My Sin City dvd sounded GREAT. One of the best sounding discs all year. No problems at all.