DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   DVD Reviews and Recommendations (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations-8/)
-   -   new BTTF review (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-reviews-recommendations/258743-new-bttf-review.html)

dbmottle 12-19-02 10:44 PM

new BTTF review
 
BTTF Review

DreamWeaver88 12-25-02 12:05 PM

It sucks that they had to screw up the widescreen in parts 2 and 3. Here are a couple of pics I took of part 3 on my computer. The first is a P&S VCD of part 3, the second is the same scene from the WS DVD.

Pretty sad.

http://mywebpages.comcast.net/dreamw...pics/bttf1.jpg

http://mywebpages.comcast.net/dreamw...pics/bttf2.jpg

Konstantine 12-25-02 06:18 PM

Wow i never noticed it to be that bad. I dont really care tho0ugh the movies are awesome.

Geoff H 12-26-02 01:47 PM

Uhh... isn't that just a matter of the open-matte on the P&S version?

I'm not sure if I see much of a real problem here...
(I actually think the framing on the widescreen image looks better, which makes sense of course, because that's how the director would've intended it to look).

DreamWeaver88 12-26-02 03:57 PM


Originally posted by Geoff H
Uhh... isn't that just a matter of the open-matte on the P&S version?

I'm not sure if I see much of a real problem here...
(I actually think the framing on the widescreen image looks better, which makes sense of course, because that's how the director would've intended it to look).

Actually, the director would have intended you to see what you see in the P&S version, plus more on each side, not zoomed in and cropped.

DW

method 01-02-03 02:23 PM

it was an error with the widescreen transfer. the manufacturer knows and they're currently asking retailers not to replace them until the new presses are released. Apparently it only happened with the first batch.

Another question....does this DVD have DTS sound?

GuessWho 01-02-03 02:55 PM


Originally posted by method
Another question....does this DVD have DTS sound?
No,

method 01-03-03 02:56 PM

much obliged. :)

pd071 01-04-03 12:43 PM

i still think the transfer looks good. and unless you are a real die hard BTTF fan you really don't notice it much. As long as you have seen the movies, in my opinion, it all still makes sense and looks good.

hogfat 01-07-03 02:19 PM


Originally posted by DreamWeaver88
Actually, the director would have intended you to see what you see in the P&S version, plus more on each side, not zoomed in and cropped.

evidence, please? as far as i can tell, the "framing issues" are just that -- issues with framing. in short, the movies were incorrectly matted. i'd hate to imagine how terribly open some shots would look if what you say is true.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:36 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.