Highdef, were you able to determine whether the "Session 9" transfer is from the digital master?

I also noticed a little "smearing" (for lack of a better word) in the image, both at home and in the theater. It's subtle and occurs particularly during pans across backgrounds. It's like a slightly grainy stutter effect, not quite as fluid as film. It's definitely not my equipment (prog-scan Toshiba 6200, Mits. 65" Diamond). Other than minor video flaws like that, this image is extraordinarily filmlike.

Again, as I've mentioned earlier, I do not see this "smearing" effect that has been mentioned within this forum. Something must be be creating this within your setup, as I have no other explanation for it. As for the "Smearing" effect in the theatre,
that is attributed to a poor HD to film transfer. SESSION 9 was not mastered at the Sony HD center in CA. I am working on my own feature in HD for theatres and will be utilizing this facility for transfer to film.

You'll have to trust me on this: It's not the setup. It's a very subtle characteristic of this digital-video presentation. I wouldn't even call it a flaw, just a very slightly different look.

That being said, were you able to confirm whether whether the "Session 9" transfer is from the digital master?

According to USA, SESSION 9 was transferred from its HD originated master. Still, I have no explanation for the "smearing"
effect being mentioned on this DVD presentation. I'm looking at the transfer as I write this and I just don't see the "smearing." Every aspect of this transfer is first-rate. I'd even go so far as to say that it's the best looking DVD in my collection.

Believe me when I say this, as an HD filmmaker, I am extremely critical of the form. I do not argue the fact that you are experiencing some sort of digital flaw. I just can't explain it.

Very interesting. I wonder why USA didn't make a bigger deal of that. It's really a beautiful transfer.

Anyway, as soon as I can, I'll watch the film again and try to come up with a couple of time marks for you to take a look at. I'll post here when I do.

I look forward to that posting. As for USA not making such a big deal about the HD transfer, SESSION 9 was not exactly a box office smash. Don't get me wrong, I really loved the film, but corporate America places far too much value on box-office earnings rather than overall quality. Timing is everything in this business and SESSION 9 wasn't released at the right time. Let's face it, DONNIE DARKO didn't get the theatre play that it deserved either.

Also, USA is not exactly known for releasing great SE's. However, this DVD release truly raises the bar of excellence that others
will have to follow. Keep up the good work, USA.

Re: Grade Wanted: Session 9
 

Piece of crap. Well, in that a really, really, really, really, bad movie is a D- (like you Manos the Hands of Fate or something like that) I'd put this very low average. c- or so.

I think I am getting this one. Thanks guys.

To all that watched SESSION 9,

Now how many of you guys can agreee that for the 1st 45 minutes this movies was very boring and did not know what the heck was going on?

2nd... now how many of you loved it when it told you what was going on?

3rd... How many of you flipped out when the director finally got you out of your confused mind that was the plot of the movie.??

now I will say its a good suspense movie.. but I would not consider it HORROR. No way man!!
Its worth a DvD rental and the copy it on VHS. but for 20 bucks... i can put it to better use somewhere else!!
But I totalyu like how the director did the closeing on this movie so you would not be confused at the END. Woosh!!!

After reading this thread, I am so looking forward to seeing this one. Thanks.

Ummm.... Why?

If this is going to happen, we'll have to stop calling them "filmmakers". They'll be videomakers. I find that quite depressing.

Well once again I see you're curious on my opinions. I have only posted to two topics in this part of the forum and you have questioned me both times.

The video medium, whether the final result is good or bad, has advanced the art. All technology does this. It has allowed more people to experiment in the art of making movies.

It's advance into digital and the mainstream for better or worse will allow people to make and distribute their own film.

So while it may seem a little depressing; I don't think film will ever totally disappear. I'm sure it was depressing to some that films were being put in video form on Laser Discs and DVD. Compromises...hmmm.

Hey, Trencher, I couldn't agree with you more. Josh Z, would you consider what George Lucas is doing regarding "ATTACK OF THE CLONES," as depressing? LUCASFILM is raising the bar for HD
filmmaking and in the process is opening doors that were once closed. Remember that we've only tipped the iceberg with this technology. D.L.P. projection in theatres will only get better, therefore transferring HD originated product to film for theatrical exhibition will be a thing of the past. Of course digital theatres are only evolving as we speak so its mainstream establishment will take some time. If you've seen a film presented in D.L.P. you know just what I'm talking about. Even Lucas will have to transfer his "ATTACK OF THE CLONES" to film for theatrical release. However, if you live close enought to a D.L.P. cinema, rush out in May and see this film digitally.

Digital Filmmakers will only grow in numbers as the technology
for both production and post-production becomes more accessible. SESSION 9 is an excellent example of how HD originated product transfers wonderfully to DVD. It's also important to remember that this production DID NOT use the same modified Sony F-900 series HD cameras and Panavision lenses that Lucas did. In May the truth will be revealed... Digital is here to stay and will only get better over time.

As a Digital Filmmaker myself, I embrace the future with open arms and renewed spirit.

8 out of 10 I was totally engrossed with the story and the movie! I really thought they did a great job with it and a bunch of nice extra's also. BTW I also thought it "looked" fantastic for how they filmed it.

8 out of 10 movie
 

An excellent suspense/thriller. No teeny bopper crap movie. A must see.

A worthy rental but not a "must see" by any means. My copy has already been traded.....