Could you sell your collection?
#1
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Thread Starter
Could you sell your collection?
Legit question here. I was wondering, could you ever part with your collection? For some reasons everything but my collection is easy to sell and part with. Partly because its mainly worthless(the only money comic I own is Batman Adventures 12) but also partly because its hard not to still enjoy picking out a floppy and reading it again.
#3
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
I tried last summer but there were no offers that would even buy us dinner one night. I went to all of the Comic Book Shops in the area and no one was interested. They all claimed there was no market for old comic books.
In their defense, the people I talked to said they were having trouble selling the ones they have in stock. My collection spans from the late 70's to the early 90's. From everything they told me, there is already a glut of books from that era already, that's why there is little value from the ones I own.
After hitting all the shops trying to sell them, I just took them all back home. I'm not going to give them away for pennies on the dollar, so I will just keep them. They might not mean much to the average joe, but they are part of my life, from my early childhood to my mid 20's.
In their defense, the people I talked to said they were having trouble selling the ones they have in stock. My collection spans from the late 70's to the early 90's. From everything they told me, there is already a glut of books from that era already, that's why there is little value from the ones I own.
After hitting all the shops trying to sell them, I just took them all back home. I'm not going to give them away for pennies on the dollar, so I will just keep them. They might not mean much to the average joe, but they are part of my life, from my early childhood to my mid 20's.
#4
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
If your comics are in decent condition, you would probably get a lot more selling them on Ebay than you would from any local comic shop. The only downside is that you would have to pack them all up and ship them to the buyer.
#5
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Nonsense. Most collectors don't go to comic book shops to look for back issues anymore. They go on Ebay.
If your comics are in decent condition, you would probably get a lot more selling them on Ebay than you would from any local comic shop. The only downside is that you would have to pack them all up and ship them to the buyer.
If your comics are in decent condition, you would probably get a lot more selling them on Ebay than you would from any local comic shop. The only downside is that you would have to pack them all up and ship them to the buyer.
#6
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
The postage, ebay fees, etc is stuff you calculate into the prices you're willing to charge for your items. You can set the cost for shipping at any amount you want, though if you (over)charge too much you will probably drive potential buyers away. The time you spend selling on Ebay will likely be less than that of driving around to various comic shops looking for a buyer who will give you pennies on the dollar.
#7
Re: Could you sell your collection?
I have a box full of every single 1st issue Image comic released. Including all the limited series.
I don't know how much it's all worth but I could see myself parting with it in the future.
Value box: $10
I don't know how much it's all worth but I could see myself parting with it in the future.
Value box: $10
Last edited by Sonic; 03-31-18 at 06:19 PM.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Could you sell your collection?
If you have good stuff, you will make money. If you have shitty stuff, well then.
To answer OP. I could. It's just stuff. My collection has been big, small, amazing and shitty through out my life. Comes and goes.
#9
Re: Could you sell your collection?
No. The kids can do whatever they want with them when I'm gone. Besides, it's not really getting any bigger. I only buy a handful of BA/SA books every year.
#10
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Could I as in, could I part with them? Yes.
Could I as in, would I be able to find anyone who would take them? No.
Could I as in, would I be able to find anyone who would take them? No.
#11
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Could you sell your collection?
This is not a shot on you, but lately people are acting like ebay takes 175% fees
If you have good stuff, you will make money. If you have shitty stuff, well then.
To answer OP. I could. It's just stuff. My collection has been big, small, amazing and shitty through out my life. Comes and goes.
If you have good stuff, you will make money. If you have shitty stuff, well then.
To answer OP. I could. It's just stuff. My collection has been big, small, amazing and shitty through out my life. Comes and goes.
#12
DVD Talk Legend & 2021 TOTY Winner
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Yeah, you wanna buy it?
#13
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Could you sell your collection?
My collection just takes up space. I think the only titles I've looked at in fifteen years were Sandman, The Invisibles, Grant Morrison's Doom Patrol, and that's about all.
Maybe now would be a good time to unload Lucifer. Did the TV series give it a boost in popularity?
Maybe now would be a good time to unload Lucifer. Did the TV series give it a boost in popularity?
#15
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Parted with 95% of my collection years ago. I kept a few valuable and/or sentimental comics, but the rest were just taking up space. Easiest and best thing I ever did.
#16
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
I gradually gave away my collection over the years, mostly to younger relatives and various local friends.
.
This is including The Uncanny X-Men issues from 94 to around 150. (Though they were not in mint condition and were not fetching much on the collectors market in non-mint condition).
.
This is including The Uncanny X-Men issues from 94 to around 150. (Though they were not in mint condition and were not fetching much on the collectors market in non-mint condition).
#17
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
For that matter, tons of "pristine mint" condition stuff published after the 1970s or so, also seems to be automatically in the shit category too. Especially stuff that was originally sold in the direct market (ie. sold directly to comic book shops frequently without any upc codes).
As to what can still fetch a pretty penny that is not in "pristine mint" condition, I have no idea.
#18
Re: Could you sell your collection?
The fees are a minor part of it, the biggest factor to me is the time. I’ve bought thousands of books on ebay, and at the prices I paid I can’t imagine the sellers made more than $20 an hour. I’ve sold on ebay. And even with mass posting, printing and shipping from home, the time sink is greater than most people think.
I always have between 600-700 unique items on Ebay and at least 3000+ total items on there. On an average day i'll have at least 10 items going to the post office. I will generally spend between an hour and an hour and a half a day going on Ebay and will profit $40-$75 for that time. The trip to the post office takes about 30-40 minutes round trip. That's fixed time weather I sell 1 or 100 items so the more I sell the more money I make during that time. I've got packaging time down to 3-4 minutes per item. I really need to add more items to my store but it's a passive activity for me right now.
#19
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Nearly complete runs of high-grade comics still do very well on eBay, even less popular titles. Go on eBay and check how people have packaged their collection into lots for easy sale.
What doesn't sell are random issues of 1980s and newer books. Most of this stuff is being collected now in omnibuses and other formats. Many dump their individual issues when they get the omnibus or hardcover.
What doesn't sell are random issues of 1980s and newer books. Most of this stuff is being collected now in omnibuses and other formats. Many dump their individual issues when they get the omnibus or hardcover.
#20
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Yes time is definetly the biggest factor. The fees you account for in prices you sell your items for. If you're selling only a few random lower valued items, you'll likely spend more time than it's worth having to pack up one or two items and make a trip to the post office to drop them off.
I always have between 600-700 unique items on Ebay and at least 3000+ total items on there. On an average day i'll have at least 10 items going to the post office. I will generally spend between an hour and an hour and a half a day going on Ebay and will profit $40-$75 for that time. The trip to the post office takes about 30-40 minutes round trip. That's fixed time weather I sell 1 or 100 items so the more I sell the more money I make during that time. I've got packaging time down to 3-4 minutes per item. I really need to add more items to my store but it's a passive activity for me right now.
I always have between 600-700 unique items on Ebay and at least 3000+ total items on there. On an average day i'll have at least 10 items going to the post office. I will generally spend between an hour and an hour and a half a day going on Ebay and will profit $40-$75 for that time. The trip to the post office takes about 30-40 minutes round trip. That's fixed time weather I sell 1 or 100 items so the more I sell the more money I make during that time. I've got packaging time down to 3-4 minutes per item. I really need to add more items to my store but it's a passive activity for me right now.
#21
Re: Could you sell your collection?
No.
I have two long boxes and quite a variety, in my opinion.
Flaming Carrot, Death Rattle, Caliber Presents, McFarlane/Michelinie Spider-man, early TMNT, Alan Moore Awesome! Comics, Twisted Tales, Rocketeer, etc.
Once in a blue moon I'll pick out an issue, and I remember when and where I was when I first read it.
The ads and the letter columns add to the time-machine-like nature.
I have two long boxes and quite a variety, in my opinion.
Flaming Carrot, Death Rattle, Caliber Presents, McFarlane/Michelinie Spider-man, early TMNT, Alan Moore Awesome! Comics, Twisted Tales, Rocketeer, etc.
Once in a blue moon I'll pick out an issue, and I remember when and where I was when I first read it.
The ads and the letter columns add to the time-machine-like nature.
#22
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Could you sell your collection?
Nonsense. There is still strong interest in old comic books, but most collectors don't go to comic book shops to look for back issues anymore. They go on Ebay.
If your comics are in decent condition, you would probably get a lot more selling them on Ebay than you would from any local comic shop. The only downside is that you would have to pack them all up and ship them to the buyer.
If your comics are in decent condition, you would probably get a lot more selling them on Ebay than you would from any local comic shop. The only downside is that you would have to pack them all up and ship them to the buyer.
#23
Re: Could you sell your collection?
I also want them to be scanned in immediately which the don't do for pick up. I can get them to scan them in for tracking at the post office even if they don't like doing it.
#24
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Could you sell your collection?
At some point there is a dividing line where all collectors markets shifted from 10% surviving in mint condition to 90+% surviving in mint condition. The culture changed from consuming to preserving.