DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Comic Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk-57/)
-   -   Why Marvel Vs. DC? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk/621466-why-marvel-vs-dc.html)

Iron_Giant 10-13-14 05:14 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 12190932)
My first comic. A Treasury Edition, oversized comic which I got in 1976 when I was 5. Featured 2 Superman/Flash race stories, puzzles, Fortress of Solitude schematics, and more. Turned me into a Superman (and DCU) fan for life:

http://www.treasurycomics.com/images...rman_flash.gif

I still have it.

Christmas 1976 my cousin gave me this hardbound treasure:

http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb2...;s_Vol_1_1.jpg

This thick book featured Superman stories from every decade. I poured through it like it was Holy Writ. Mostly black and white, but with some color pages. Think of every possible Superman iteration of that time, from the Siegel/Shuster social crusader of the 30s to the grand goofy sci-fi of Mort Weisenger/Curt Swan and the Denny O'Neil 70s era. AMAZING STUFF.

My brother had the Batman version which was just as addictive as well.

Had most or all of the "Treasury Edition" over sized editions...LOVED THEM.
-Have many great memories reading those.

Still have the Superman vs Spider-Man and LoSH.

Love DC comics, never really collected Marvel.

Love both DC/Marvel movies now, feel like a kid again watching my fav characters on the big screen.

Solid Snake 10-13-14 05:54 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Why So Blu? (Post 12199302)
The Latina Ghost Rider bit was stupid but everything else is lolz.

an Hispanic Ghost Rider? She any good as a character?

I found a male one:
http://4.firepic.org/4/images/2014-0...f0rigr8pa8.png

See he ditched the cycle for a car. Guess that's neat. Kind of like his design there.

mrhan 10-13-14 10:37 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Iron_Giant (Post 12268519)
Had most or all of the "Treasury Edition" over sized editions...LOVED THEM.
-Have many great memories reading those.

Still have the Superman vs Spider-Man and LoSH.

Love DC comics, never really collected Marvel.

Love both DC/Marvel movies now, feel like a kid again watching my fav characters on the big screen.

I still have most of those, too. I remember years later some people use to rip off the outside covers and try to pass them off as originals; especially Action #1. It fooled some people because they were exact reproductions except they were much larger.

Trevor 10-14-14 07:33 AM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Iron_Giant (Post 12268519)
Had most or all of the "Treasury Edition" over sized editions...LOVED THEM.
-Have many great memories reading those.

Love both DC/Marvel movies now, feel like a kid again watching my fav characters on the big screen.

Yep, those treasuries were so great.

Originally Posted by mrhan (Post 12268890)
I still have most of those, too.

Sadly, I got rid of all of my Treasury Editions back when I was 15 or so and went thru a rare purge mode. I've re-bought several on ebay, and still pick them up occasionally when I see them in the $10 or less range.

davidh777 12-10-14 01:42 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 12190932)
Christmas 1976 my cousin gave me this hardbound treasure:

http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb2...;s_Vol_1_1.jpg

This thick book featured Superman stories from every decade. I poured through it like it was Holy Writ. Mostly black and white, but with some color pages. Think of every possible Superman iteration of that time, from the Siegel/Shuster social crusader of the 30s to the grand goofy sci-fi of Mort Weisenger/Curt Swan and the Denny O'Neil 70s era. AMAZING STUFF.

My brother had the Batman version which was just as addictive as well.

I borrowed both this and especially the Batman version from the library more times than I could ever count. A few years back I ran across the latter in a used book store and of course had to own it. Still awesome.

http://media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/73...08a4b4d2c2.jpg

(I wasn't really following this thread, but saw Hokeyboy's comment in passing and made a mental note to come back to it. Kudos to me for finding it!)

Hokeyboy 12-10-14 02:00 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by davidh777 (Post 12329939)
I borrowed both this and especially the Batman version from the library more times than I could ever count. A few years back I ran across the latter in a used book store and of course had to own it. Still awesome.

http://media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/73...08a4b4d2c2.jpg

(I wasn't really following this thread, but saw Hokeyboy's comment in passing and made a mental note to come back to it. Kudos to me for finding it!)

On Cent Ted Tate Mica ;)

I have distinct memories of a Wonder Woman hardcover that my sister received, but since I was 5 and this was 38 years ago, I could be entirely full of beans.

Still have both the Superman and Batman books (bought off eBay 15 years ago) and they remain great reads. I always loved the decade "preview pages" for the 50s, 60s, and 70s. The Batman ones were ESPECIALLY creepy; each issue seemed to be showcasing Robin's imminent death.

Hokeyboy 12-10-14 02:04 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 
http://comicsastonish.files.wordpres.../batman246.jpg

Hokeyboy 12-10-14 02:11 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 
Or perhaps even:

(Spoilered for size)

davidh777 12-10-14 02:12 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 12329964)
On Cent Ted Tate Mica ;)

:lol:


Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 12329964)
I have distinct memories of a Wonder Woman hardcover that my sister received, but since I was 5 and this was 38 years ago, I could be entirely full of beans.

Still have both the Superman and Batman books (bought off eBay 15 years ago) and they remain great reads. I always loved the decade "preview pages" for the 50s, 60s, and 70s. The Batman ones were ESPECIALLY creepy; each issue seemed to be showcasing Robin's imminent death.

No, I thought I remembered a Wonder Woman version as well, though a quick search didn't turn up anything. I found a Shazam! version once but wasn't enough of a fan to pay the high price, and I already have the Showcase and some others.

Damn you, nostalgia! I just ordered the Superman one for 12 bucks shipped. :)

mrhan 12-10-14 03:02 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 
There was a WW hardcover. It had WW face on it; yellow and blue with stars. It was thinner than the Batman and Superman books. I never owned it but remember flipping through it.

EDIT: Here it is.

http://www.wonderwomancollectors.com/books-2l.jpg

http://www.wonderwomancollectors.com/home.html

fumanstan 12-10-14 03:37 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 
So... how many ways can a Robin die?

davidh777 12-10-14 03:41 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 
http://media-cache-ec0.pinimg.com/73...f6b17be5e9.jpg

PhantomStranger 12-10-14 03:46 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by davidh777 (Post 12329976)
No, I thought I remembered a Wonder Woman version as well, though a quick search didn't turn up anything. I found a Shazam! version once but wasn't enough of a fan to pay the high price, and I already have the Showcase and some others.

Damn you, nostalgia! I just ordered the Superman one for 12 bucks shipped. :)

The Shazam Treasury is awesome.

mrhan 12-10-14 04:55 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 
I prefer this one over the original cover of Batman #232.

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources...batcover43.jpg

Shannon Nutt 12-10-14 04:56 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by davidh777 (Post 12329939)
I borrowed both this and especially the Batman version from the library more times than I could ever count. A few years back I ran across the latter in a used book store and of course had to own it. Still awesome.

http://media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/73...08a4b4d2c2.jpg

(I wasn't really following this thread, but saw Hokeyboy's comment in passing and made a mental note to come back to it. Kudos to me for finding it!)


I had this book when I was a kid. Of course, my Mom got rid of it when I moved out. Thanks, Mom! :(

davidh777 12-10-14 06:00 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by PhantomStranger (Post 12330085)
The Shazam Treasury is awesome.

Damnit


Originally Posted by mrhan (Post 12330024)
There was a WW hardcover. It had WW face on it; yellow and blue with stars. It was thinner than the Batman and Superman books. I never owned it but remember flipping through it.

EDIT: Here it is.

http://www.wonderwomancollectors.com/books-2l.jpg

http://www.wonderwomancollectors.com/home.html

Yep, that looks right. :up:

Josh-da-man 12-10-14 07:41 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by Hokeyboy (Post 12329969)

Autoerotic asphyxiation?

PhantomStranger 12-10-14 10:55 PM

Re: Why Marvel Vs. DC?
 

Originally Posted by mrhan (Post 12330178)
I prefer this one over the original cover of Batman #232.

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources...batcover43.jpg

Man, that would make one awesome poster or framed art.:thumbsup: Batman needs his blue cape back.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:50 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.