DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Comic Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk-57/)
-   -   Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk/504744-marvel-omnibuses-youd-like-see.html)

hiroic 05-29-09 05:16 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Don't mean to come off as threadcrapping, but I recently got my first omnibus: ASM vol 1, and I was somewhat disappointed. Although the idea of the omnibus sounds great, I think that it is just too large and cumbersome a format. Its a chore to read, and I believe its girth lead to it getting damaged during shipping.

All that being said, I probably would pony up for ASM vol 2. I'd just pay a little more at the LCS rather than Amazon.

Meatwad's Ghost 05-30-09 06:20 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by hiroic (Post 9472483)
Don't mean to come off as threadcrapping, but I recently got my first omnibus: ASM vol 1, and I was somewhat disappointed. Although the idea of the omnibus sounds great, I think that it is just too large and cumbersome a format. Its a chore to read, and I believe its girth lead to it getting damaged during shipping.

All that being said, I probably would pony up for ASM vol 2. I'd just pay a little more at the LCS rather than Amazon.

I understand the books are huge, Spider-Man and Secret Wars 2 I think are the two biggest. I read them at a desk, the only easy way to read them. If you're wanting smaller easier to read versions you can go with the Marvel Masterworks, they cost about $50 each and an omnibus collects about 3 of those so you save some $ by going with the Omnibuses.

With Amazon, I hardly ever order any graphic novels from them, it depends on which warehouse they ship from. I've had some come in great but then had one that was put in a huge box with 2 of those air pillows, like that would help. http://www.dcbservice.com/ is where I preorder my omnibuses, usually 50% off and shipping is about $6. I've gotten 3 from them only had one minor problem with one but I think it was more in the manufacturing.

slop101 05-30-09 07:41 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by Meatwad's Ghost (Post 9475231)
I read them at a desk, the only easy way to read them.

I recommend one of these:

http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/7915/lectern.jpg

hiroic 06-01-09 03:48 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by Meatwad's Ghost (Post 9475231)
I understand the books are huge, Spider-Man and Secret Wars 2 I think are the two biggest. I read them at a desk, the only easy way to read them. If you're wanting smaller easier to read versions you can go with the Marvel Masterworks, they cost about $50 each and an omnibus collects about 3 of those so you save some $ by going with the Omnibuses.

With Amazon, I hardly ever order any graphic novels from them, it depends on which warehouse they ship from. I've had some come in great but then had one that was put in a huge box with 2 of those air pillows, like that would help. (Can't copy the URL!!) is where I preorder my omnibuses, usually 50% off and shipping is about $6. I've gotten 3 from them only had one minor problem with one but I think it was more in the manufacturing.

Thanks for the link, I'll check that one out. With my ASM, Amazon simply double shrinkwrapped it to a piece of cardboard and into the box it went. There was nothing there to absorb the shock if it was dropped.

I have some Masterworks volumes that I got cheap, but you're right in that the HC's are not really economically feasible. Although given the new TPB format, I might go the Masterworks route with the FF. I do love the oversize pages and the inclusion of the letter columns in the omnibus though.

ivelostr2 06-03-09 08:23 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by ivelostr2 (Post 9206567)
TFAW has the captain america omnibus for 37.49 in the scratch & dent catagory. I quoted my report from the last S&D order i got from them, overall i am pleased with them. Just figured id give you heads up...

just to give you guys a heads up, things from another world has another cap america omni Nick and Dent for 37.49.


http://www.tfaw.com/Profile/Captain-...-Dent___326228

slop101 06-04-09 09:52 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Saw the new Brubaker Daredevil Omni at the LBC the other day. It's cover price was $75, which is kinda steep considering it was a much skinnier than the normal $75 Omnibus - I think under 20 issues or so. It's not available at amazon yet either.

majorjoe23 06-04-09 10:59 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
It's especially frustrating since the remainder of his run isn't going to be long enough for a good size second omnibus.

ytrez 06-05-09 08:51 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
I want a third Fantastic Four Omnibus, hopefully finishing off Kirby's run.

slop101 06-05-09 10:38 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Actually, the Bru-Devil Omni collects 23 issues. The reason it seems so skinny is that Marvel is now using much thinner paper in their Omnibuses. Compare an older one to a newer one and you'll immediately notice the difference.

MBoyd 06-06-09 02:28 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Just placed and my order at DCBS. Noticed there is a Brubaker Criminal Omnibus that I missed in the solicits. Never read it. Any good? Wonder if it will look like the normal Marvel line.

majorjoe23 06-06-09 05:11 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Criminal is awesome. The Icon line that Criminal is a part of doesn't share any design qualities with Marvel books, so my guess is the Omnibus won't either.

John_Shil 06-09-09 10:25 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
The CRIMINAL omnibus hasn't been solicited yet. It'll be in this month's solicitations. Brubaker confirmed this on BleedingCool.com. I figure this'll cover #1-10, 1-7, which seems sparse for an omnibus. Shame we probably won't get any of the backmatter, but I understand the initiative to get people to pick up the singles.

ivelostr2 06-12-09 09:19 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 9485212)
Saw the new Brubaker Daredevil Omni at the LBC the other day. It's cover price was $75, which is kinda steep considering it was a much skinnier than the normal $75 Omnibus - I think under 20 issues or so. It's not available at amazon yet either.

amazon delayed mine again to June 29th, both this one and the inferno one have beem delayed atleast 2 times. I guess we will see if the inferno one comes next week...

I wonder why the mutant massacre HC isn't being called an Omnibus, it collects all of the titles that were crossed over i think. maybe it isnt big enough?

http://www.tfaw.com/Profile/X-Men-Mu...re-HC___348076

John_Shil 06-12-09 10:24 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
I don't think INFERNO and MUTANT MASSACRE are technically Omnibus; neither were solicited that way. Inferno is the size of one of the smaller omnibus, Daredevil, Iron Fist, etc. Mutant Massacre, however, is only as big as one of the oversized hardcovers they've been releasing for certain series: New Avengers, Punisher MAX, Annihilation, etc.

ivelostr2 06-12-09 10:31 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by John_Shil (Post 9501340)
I don't think INFERNO and MUTANT MASSACRE are technically Omnibus; neither were solicited that way. Inferno is the size of one of the smaller omnibus, Daredevil, Iron Fist, etc. Mutant Massacre, however, is only as big as one of the oversized hardcovers they've been releasing for certain series: New Avengers, Punisher MAX, Annihilation, etc.

yeah, neither of them are an omnibus' and i thought the explanation for Inferno not being one was because it didn't include all the side stories, but the mutant massacre one does, so I was wondering..not that it really matters, I just hope all the X-men stories from my child hood get reprinted in the oversized books...

ivelostr2 06-15-09 01:22 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Secret Wars II showed up in my quick picks today on Amazon for $59.84...wow, i never realized that is 1184 pages! I knew it was bigger than the other one, but i didn't realize it was that big...

fujishig 06-15-09 02:36 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by ivelostr2 (Post 9505946)
Secret Wars II showed up in my quick picks today on Amazon for $59.84...wow, i never realized that is 1184 pages! I knew it was bigger than the other one, but i didn't realize it was that big...

But it sucked five times as much as Secret Wars 1. That is a lot of pages, though,did they include all of the tie ins? Because I thought the miniseries was shorter than the first Secret Wars.

ivelostr2 06-15-09 02:58 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by fujishig (Post 9506107)
But it sucked five times as much as Secret Wars 1. That is a lot of pages, though,did they include all of the tie ins? Because I thought the miniseries was shorter than the first Secret Wars.

i think it was only 8-9 issues, but yeah, it includes every side issue, like when the beyonder wrestled the thing and took Dazzler on a date...

ytrez 06-16-09 07:53 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by ivelostr2 (Post 9506152)
i think it was only 8-9 issues, but yeah, it includes every side issue, like when the beyonder wrestled the thing and took Dazzler on a date...

I seem to remember Spider-Man teaching Beyonder how to use a toilet. What a terrible series.

MBoyd 06-18-09 02:06 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

DAREDEVIL BY BRIAN MICHAEL BENDIS & ALEX MALEEV OMNIBUS VOL. 2 HC
Written by BRIAN MICHAEL BENDIS
Penciled by ALEX MALEEV, MICHAEL GOLDEN, GREG HORN, P. CRAIG RUSSEL, PHIL HESTER, CHRIS BACHALO, JAE LEE, DAVID FINCH, FRANK QUITELY, ROB HAYNES & MICHAEL LARK
Cover by ALEX MALEEV
During a character-defining run, Brian Michael Bendis crafted a pulp-fiction narrative that exploited the Man Without Fear’s rich tapestry of characters and psychodrama, and resolved them in an incredibly nuanced, modern approach. Earning an Eisner Award for Best Continuing Series, Bendis and artist Alex Maleev restored Daredevil to a luster worthy of the all-time greats. In this volume, Bendis and Maleev’s run comes to a blistering conclusion with a Daredevil/Black Widow team-up that takes an interesting turn; untold tales of Hell’s Kitchen past and present; and the return of Wilson Fisk, the Kingpin of Crime! Collecting DAREDEVIL #61-81, DAREDEVIL: NINJA #1-3 and WHAT IF KAREN PAGE HAD LIVED?
656 PGS./Rated T+ ...$99.99
ISBN: 978-0-7851-3813-6
DAREDEVIL BY BRIAN MICHAEL BENDIS & ALEX MALEEV OMNIBUS VOL. 1 HC STILL AVAILABLE!
$99.99 (ISBN: 978-0-7851-3112-0)
I am sure you guys saw this one already. Yes I am going to complain about getting another DD Omni so soon. Actually that's it. That one line complaint. No wild rant.

We moved to Austin Monday. Damn those Omnis and Absolutes were heavy. I put them in plastic locking tubs. Was a real workout.

slop101 06-18-09 10:01 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by MBoyd (Post 9510590)
I am sure you guys saw this one already. Yes I am going to complain about getting another DD Omni so soon.

I'll add to that complaint and say it was also dumb to release it after Brubaker's DD Omni, since this 2nd volume of Bendis' DD takes place just before Bru's run. Not to mention, getting all these Daredevils and Bendis' 2nd run, and still no sign of Uncanny volume 2.

Mhepburn20 06-18-09 10:26 AM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 

Originally Posted by slop101 (Post 9510940)
I'll add to that complaint and say it was also dumb to release it after Brubaker's DD Omni, since this 2nd volume of Bendis' DD takes place just before Bru's run. Not to mention, getting all these Daredevils and Bendis' 2nd run, and still no sign of Uncanny volume 2.

Agree on all counts. This brings us to nearly SIX Daredevil omniboo (counting the companion and Elektra) and we don't have uncanny volume 2. I want my paul smith issues in omnibus form now!!

sinned 06-18-09 12:11 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
It's expensive too..... 24 issues for $100

Spiderbite 07-13-09 09:22 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Tales of Wonder is having a $50 Omnibus sale but I believe it is only good for another couple of days. You get free shipping on orders over $99.

http://talesofwonder.com/category-ex.../cn/Marvel+HCs

Sorry I'm late but I just thought about posting it. I picked up Spider-man, Wolverine, and the Secret Wars sets. I have all of FF, Hulk, Iron Man, and X-men stuff on Gitcorp's dvd-rom releases but couldn't help myself and caved for the Spider-man set.

Seems to be pretty good prices even though it appears Secret Wars' MSRP is way overpriced from what I have read.

fujishig 09-08-09 04:43 PM

Re: Marvel Omnibuses you'd like to see
 
Read and enjoyed Bendis and Brubaker's first DD omnis. First time I've ever read the material at all.

Also been going through the Captain Britain one. I actually have both of the previous tpbs (the one from the 80s and the more recent one), and in all honesty, the early, serialized issues that weren't collected anywhere else weren't all that great. Moore even admits in his intro (which was written like 7 years ago) that he hadn't revisited this stuff at all since he wrote it. Still, I love Alan Davis, and I really hope that we get an Excalibur collection to go along with this one someday.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:13 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.