DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Comic Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk-57/)
-   -   No Capes Allowed! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk/503119-no-capes-allowed.html)

bishop2knight 06-10-07 03:20 PM

No Capes Allowed!
 
I think it's time the non-super hero crowd had a chance to post comments on some of their favorite books. Don't get me wrong, I love Marvel and DC books as much as the next guy, and I fully respect the discussions that go on here, but I wanted a safe haven for discussions of another sort.

So, what non-hero books are you reading this month?

bishop2knight 06-10-07 03:26 PM

I guess I should start. I just finished <b>The Plain Janes</b> by Castellucci and Rugg. While I wouldn't say it's my favorite book this year, I did enjoy it, and I'm about as far removed from the book's core audience (younger females) as you can get. I found it refreshing to read a book that focuses a little more on relationships and everyday hardships instead of out-of-this-world antagonists.

One thing I was surprised to learn is that this is a totally self-contained story. I'm not sure where I got the idea, but I thought this Minx books were continuing stories. I suppose that could still be the case, but I almost forgot what it was like to sit and read a complete story. :up:

boredsilly 06-10-07 04:19 PM

I've heard so much good stuff about The Plain Janes that I'm going to give it a try.

Patman 06-10-07 04:35 PM

Anyone sort of frustrated by the latest arc in Optic Nerve? Sometimes I just want to bitchslap Ben.

JustinCleveland 06-10-07 05:35 PM

Just finished the Fell trade. Thought it was phenomenal.

Mok 06-10-07 06:18 PM

Can't wait for the next issue of The Walking Dead.

stingermck 06-10-07 06:33 PM

Umm can Y The Last Man count? Thats always good stuff

Just finished the last trade of Girls, and what a gigantic let down that was. Started strong, dragged out, then ended abruptly. I hate it when good comics crash :(

Patman 06-10-07 09:16 PM

I'm sort of glad Y the Last Man is winding down because it's still a decent read, but not as compelling as the first couple of years of issues.

madcougar 06-10-07 10:46 PM


Originally Posted by Patman
Anyone sort of frustrated by the latest arc in Optic Nerve? Sometimes I just want to bitchslap Ben.

One of my best friends is the freakin' mirror image of Ben personality wise. We are both Hispanic and I don't think he's ever been comfortable in his own skin either. I too wanted to slap the crap out of Ben, but I also was feeling a lot of sympathy as his plan left NY in the end. A person like that will never be happy until they learn to like themselves.

Chew 06-11-07 06:09 AM


Originally Posted by JustinCleveland
Just finished the Fell trade. Thought it was phenomenal.

Agreed. It's a great read.

Trevor 06-11-07 09:28 AM

I'm not a monthly reader, but I keep hearing good things about Fables. I know I'm a few years behind on this, but what is everyone's opinion on it? I used to love Willingham's Elementals.

bishop2knight 06-11-07 10:20 AM


Originally Posted by Patman
I'm sort of glad Y the Last Man is winding down because it's still a decent read, but not as compelling as the first couple of years of issues.

I stopped reading Y monthly about 8 months ago. I plan to read the entire series via tradepaperback once the last one hits. I love the cliffhangers Vaughan comes up with, but once that series hit about issue 30 or so, I felt it started reading better in one large chunk.

I heard the last issue will feature lots of nudity. Was that a joke I heard from one of the cons, or was that in all seriousness? Anyone know?

The Bus 06-11-07 10:51 AM

I couldn't imagine reading Y: The Last Man monthly. It's a bit like Lost, where not much happens in one issue but a lot can happen in two or three. Even reading one trade at a time isn't good enough. :lol:

I've read the first book of Fables and I enjoyed it, although not enough to buy the next books.

The other ones I enjoy are Ex Machina and The Losers.

DGibFen 06-11-07 10:54 AM


Originally Posted by Trevor
I'm not a monthly reader, but I keep hearing good things about Fables. I know I'm a few years behind on this, but what is everyone's opinion on it? I used to love Willingham's Elementals.

I read all of the trades over two sessions at a bookstore. Very compelling stuff, but a little confusing at times as far as the rules go (as in, what happens to a Fable if he/she dies, etc.).

stingermck 06-11-07 10:56 AM

[QUOTE=The Bus]I couldn't imagine reading Y: The Last Man monthly. It's a bit like Lost, where not much happens in one issue but a lot can happen in two or three. Even reading one trade at a time isn't good enough. :lol:

Same here, lucky for me, a friend of mine gets the trades, so i read vols 1-6 at one time :)

Same with Girls, couldn't imagine it in singles

Chew 06-11-07 11:01 AM


Originally Posted by The Bus
I couldn't imagine reading Y: The Last Man monthly. It's a bit like Lost, where not much happens in one issue but a lot can happen in two or three. Even reading one trade at a time isn't good enough. :lol:

:shrug: I've been going monthly since the first or second trade.

Sessa17 06-13-07 04:50 PM

I just read GYAKUSHU the other day by the insanely talented Dan Hipp. Best work he has ever done, the art was phenomenal, his panel structure was just brilliant, it's really a visual treat. I am not a Manga fan at all, I can't stand the stuff, so don't let the fact that this is published by TokyoPop scare you. For under $10 it's a fantastic read, one of the best surprises of the year. I cannot wait for volume 2.

http://www.newsarama.com/tokyopop/Gy...USHU_COVER.jpg

JasonF 06-13-07 06:52 PM

I just found out that Ragmop got published in a collected edition earlier this year. Even better, Rob Walton added an ending. I ordered it and am eagerly awaiting its arrival in the mail.

Ragmop=awesome.

bishop2knight 06-14-07 10:15 AM


Originally Posted by Sessa17
I just read GYAKUSHU the other day by the insanely talented Dan Hipp. Best work he has ever done, the art was phenomenal, his panel structure was just brilliant, it's really a visual treat. I am not a Manga fan at all, I can't stand the stuff, so don't let the fact that this is published by TokyoPop scare you. For under $10 it's a fantastic read, one of the best surprises of the year. I cannot wait for volume 2.

http://www.newsarama.com/tokyopop/Gy...USHU_COVER.jpg

That covers looks sweet. When did that come out?

Supermallet 06-14-07 07:13 PM

Speaking of Y: The Last Man, a friend of mine let borrow trades 1-9. I heard 10 will be the last. Is this true?

dbm00 06-14-07 09:50 PM


Originally Posted by The Bus
I've read the first book of Fables and I enjoyed it, although not enough to buy the next books.

I was iffy on the first volume, liked 2 and 3, and loved volume 4. Haven't read past that yet, but can't wait.

My recent recommends are:

Abandoned by Ross Campbell (anything by Ross, really)

and

King City by Brandon Graham

Both are manga sized. Abandoned is about real people dealing with zombies (down point is that only vol 1 will ever come out, apparently), and King City is about a dude with an alien cat (I think it was alien; it was cool in any case). I think both have a similar vibe, and great art. I'll be reading these two many times.

DataZak 06-14-07 10:04 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
Speaking of Y: The Last Man, a friend of mine let borrow trades 1-9. I heard 10 will be the last. Is this true?

The series will end with issue 60 if I'm not mistaken so yeah, vol. 10 will be the last trade. Book 9 collects #49-#54 which means book 10 will collect #55-#60.

fujishig 06-15-07 12:21 AM

I'll try not to turn this into a manga thread, but some non-superhero like manga I've been reading lately are:

Death Note, by Tsugumi Ohba and Takeshi Obata. About a very intelligent highschool kid who finds the "Death Note," a notebook that kills anyone who's name you write down in it, and decides to become "Kira" (Killer). It's actually very, very wordy for a manga, but it's got great art and an interesting plot. I've gotten to the point where I've heard the series does a downturn, but it's still interesting to me.

Also drawn by Obata is Hikaru No Go, written by Yumi Hotta. It's about, well, the Japanese board game of Go, which would seem to be an odd title to bring to the states, but it's entertaining.

Lastly, as a totally guilty pleasure, I've been enjoying Ma Wing Shing's Blood Sword, basically a martial arts comic.

JasonF 06-16-07 12:21 AM

My copy of Ragmop arrived today. Hooray! I can't wait to read it. Ragmop is awesome!

http://www.paneltopanel.net/ezimagec...88-400x500.jpg

It's Looney Tunes meets Noam Chomsky meets Jack Kirby meets Dr. Suess meets X-Files meets Illuminati meets Walt Kelly. It's super awesome fun.

Buy it! Read it! Love it!

davidh777 06-16-07 01:12 AM

Would they ever do an Absolute Y The Last Man?

bishop2knight 06-16-07 08:10 AM


Originally Posted by davidh777
Would they ever do an Absolute Y The Last Man?

I've gotta believe that after the series is done, they at the very least produce hardcover collections. It's a great series, and I'm sure fans would eat up an Absolute version. And if the TV series or movie takes off, then that's even more reason.

JasonF 06-16-07 12:26 PM


Originally Posted by davidh777
Would they ever do an Absolute Y The Last Man?

Maybe eventually, but I have to think that if they add a second title to the line of Vertigo Absolutes, it will be Preacher. I'd probably also expect to see Transmetropolitan and maybe Swamp Thing get Absolute treatment before Y.

Sessa17 06-17-07 11:33 AM

I just got finished reading Death By Chocolate: Reduxe & enjoyed the hell out of it, I can't recommend it enough. If anyone hasn't run out & picked up GYAKUSHU, based on my recommendation, then make it a priority to seek this book out instead (or preferably w/ Gyakushu). Here is a brief synopsis. . .

"Agent Swete - an unlikely hero comprised of organic chocolate and a member of the FBI's Food Crimes Division - and his sharp-tongued partner, Anderson, investigate a series of bizarre, food-inspired crimes. Along they way they encounter a variety of characters including an extraterrestrial canine named Geoffrey, writer Ernest Hemingway, an organized crime lord intent upon finding the life-enabling 'eternity pasta,' and an eerie, all-devouring trio known as The Metabolators. The collection includes the Xeric-grant awarded origin tale of Agent Swete from 1996, as well as a never-before published DBC tale and an essay by Yurkovich on the creation of the series. Every page of the collection has been reworked by Yurkovich, making Redux the definitive edition of these stories!"

http://images.tfaw.com/covers_tfaw/4...apr074010f.jpg

bishop2knight 06-26-07 09:32 PM

I'm finally working my way through THE WALKING DEAD via the hardcovers. Loved the first 6 issues. Tony Moore is fucking amazing. Too bad he stopped doing the art. Is it because he had too many other books to draw?

dbm00 06-27-07 07:16 PM


Originally Posted by bishop2knight
I'm finally working my way through THE WALKING DEAD via the hardcovers. Loved the first 6 issues. Tony Moore is fucking amazing. Too bad he stopped doing the art. Is it because he had too many other books to draw?


From http://www.comicgate.de/content/view/279/52/1/1/

CG: After the first arc you left the title and Charlie Adlard took up the pen. Why that? And did you and Charlie ever talk about how to draw the title in order to retain a certain visual style?

TM: There were a lot of reasons I left. Most of which I don’t feel confortable going into here, but the amount of time it took me to pencil, ink, and greytone the book each month was causing me to slip on the schedule, especially when you toss in that I was doing the covers as well, and did a 48 page issue of BRIT, also with Kirkman, concurrently with The Walking Dead. In the end, though, I knew I had to leave or I would run myself into the ground.

bishop2knight 06-27-07 07:34 PM

Well, say what you will about TWD, but the art took a hit after Moore left. Don't get me wrong, I think Aldred is a fine artist, and this book fits his style pretty damn well, but those first six issues were bloody fantastic.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:21 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.