DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Comic Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk-57/)
-   -   How Many CGC Comics Do You Own? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk/496699-how-many-cgc-comics-do-you-own.html)

Bronkster 03-30-07 11:18 AM

How Many CGC Comics Do You Own?
 
I have exactly one CGC comic.

Rogue588 03-30-07 11:19 AM

That's one more than I own.

Never understood the CGC process. I mean, I understand it, I just don't get why people would pay for something like that. :shrug:

Chew 03-30-07 11:29 AM

Zero.

Bronkster 03-30-07 11:39 AM


Originally Posted by Rogue588
That's one more than I own.

Never understood the CGC process. I mean, I understand it, I just don't get why people would pay for something like that. :shrug:

That's why I'm curious. For selling (or buying) on Ebay I can understand where it can be a good way to verify what you're buying/selling. But for owning? I don't like the slab. You can't enjoy the book.

Wildo1966 03-30-07 12:15 PM

I just got my first 2 of them..I bought Captain America #25 both versions graded 9.8 on Ebay fairly cheap. I am looking for a fast flip and make some money on the madness...

PalmerJoss 03-30-07 12:23 PM

None. I thought that I read that CGC is owned by Wizard magazine, so I have no interest whatsoever in giving them money. Also, I'm a comic book fan - not a collector. I like to read my comics, not bag them the second I get ahold of them and put them away forever.

Peep 03-30-07 12:31 PM

None.

The Bus 03-30-07 12:35 PM

Zero. Yet one more reason I prefer TPBs.

Wildo1966 03-30-07 12:37 PM


Originally Posted by PalmerJoss
None. I thought that I read that CGC is owned by Wizard magazine, so I have no interest whatsoever in giving them money. Also, I'm a comic book fan - not a collector. I like to read my comics, not bag them the second I get ahold of them and put them away forever.

They are definitely in bed together but CGC is not owned by Wizard...

bishop2knight 03-30-07 12:46 PM

I have about 10. I love 'em.

zombiezilla 03-30-07 01:08 PM

None. Wouldn't buy the service; comics are meant to be read. And if not (say, FF #1 in NM/M), an acid-free case would be sufficient. Grading by a third party is the bunk. Make up your own mind what it's worth to you.

D_N_G 03-30-07 01:24 PM

i have about 15 or so, most of which are duplicates of issues I have but love enough to want a perfect copy. And most of them are Valiants :)

reverie 03-30-07 02:09 PM

Zero, and unless I have something great I'd want to get rid of (unlikely), it'll porbably always be zero.

madcougar 03-30-07 03:16 PM

I collect books to read them, not for investment value. So having a book in a case I can't open doesn't make sense for me. Don't get me wrong, I have some books I've considered sending in because I think I might be able to sell them and make money off of them, but still the answer is zero.

Trevor 03-30-07 06:57 PM

None, I read my comics (or at least plan to someday).

scarredgod 03-30-07 08:53 PM

i have zero. i have seen comics damaged from being encapsulated, and i have seen comics freed from their case and resubmitted and receiving a higher grade. so i have no interest in them. besides its like having a super hot girlfriend but only being able to look at her and touch her thru plastic.

madcougar 03-31-07 12:31 AM


Originally Posted by scarredgod
besides its like having a super hot girlfriend but only being able to look at her and touch her thru plastic.

That wasn't supposed to arouse me was it?

movieguru 04-01-07 08:27 AM

I have around 80. All of mine are before 1975. most are from the 1960"s. 90% of those are 9.4 or better. I don't see any point in grading modern comics hat just came off the press; as mint 9.8 copies are readily available for them.

The ones I've had graded are for preservation and insurance purposes. Eventually when I sell them I will get more for them then I would if they were not graded.

TimeandTide 04-01-07 12:56 PM

Just one: Daredevil #185 graded 9.8 (NM).

wlj 04-01-07 08:25 PM


Originally Posted by PalmerJoss
Also, I'm a comic book fan - not a collector. I like to read my comics, not bag them the second I get ahold of them and put them away forever.


i agree...i am in it for the stories and artwork

Seeker 04-01-07 09:42 PM

I don't have any - but I'm about to sell almost 5000 comics, so wonder if I should CGC some of them... I mean, I have:

Adventure 247
Adventure 267
Batman 10 (ok - cmon - the 1940 version)
complete run of Sandman (including the "special" #8)
Green Lantern/Green Arrow Neal Adams run complete
X-Men 94-whenever and lots of earlier ones
a few 1940s All-Flash and Captain Marvel
first appearance of Howard the Duck
first appearance Wolverine
'Mazing Man 1-12 (ok, just had to throw that in)
and tons more

So - I think - if I'm selling this, should I pay to CGC them?????

ytrez 04-02-07 08:32 AM

Proud to say: ZERO

slop101 04-02-07 10:50 AM

I don't even know what a CGC comic is (and I've been buying comics for almost 30 years now), so, I guess I don't own any.

Trevor 04-03-07 10:20 AM

Seeker,
It might be worth your while, although I haven't researched it for awhile. But I remember that CGC slabbed books used to get significantly more on ebay. Do some ebay completed auction research and you should be able to find your answer.

Slop101,
wiki article on CGC

Seeker 06-02-07 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by Seeker
I don't have any - but I'm about to sell almost 5000 comics, so wonder if I should CGC some of them... I mean, I have:

Adventure 247
Adventure 267
Batman 10 (ok - cmon - the 1940 version)
complete run of Sandman (including the "special" #8)
Green Lantern/Green Arrow Neal Adams run complete
X-Men 94-whenever and lots of earlier ones
a few 1940s All-Flash and Captain Marvel
first appearance of Howard the Duck
first appearance Wolverine
'Mazing Man 1-12 (ok, just had to throw that in)
and tons more

So - I think - if I'm selling this, should I pay to CGC them?????

Thanks - I'm still trying to decide whether I should CGC these (and others) or just sell them. I mean - it is $30-$50 EACH to grade them! Wow.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:18 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.