DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/book-talk-18/)
-   -   carl barks and will eisner (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/book-talk/448721-carl-barks-will-eisner.html)

bloopbleep 12-13-05 08:44 PM

carl barks and will eisner
 
I always wanted to try thier work,any suggestions as were to begin? I heard its best to start the Spirit archives in the teens and not in the beginning and I have no clue were to begin with Barks.

ytrez 12-14-05 07:54 AM

I'd suggest hunting down some of Barks Uncle Scrooge collections.

Early Spirt is very golden age and the art & stories are much more primitive than Eisner's later work, though I certainly read it fondly. If you're okay with non-hero, humanistic type stories, I'd recommend A Contract with God or To the Heart of the Storm.

boredsilly 12-14-05 09:37 AM

Yeah, I honestly have a hard time reading golder age superhero stuff, but Eisner's tales of New York are great. Any of those should knock your socks off, but A Contract With God is the place to start.

cultshock 12-14-05 11:59 AM

I don't know if there is really any wrong place to start with Barks. Perhaps with some of his Walt Disney Comics & Stories 10 pagers, before moving on to his longer full length Donald Duck and Uncle Scrooge stories?

I started reading Eisner back before his graphic novels were published, so I pretty well had to start with the early Spirit stories. But maybe nowadays "A Contract with God" would be a good place to start.

MBoyd 12-14-05 02:12 PM

The Life And Times Of Scrooge McDuck has been getting a lot of buzz this past year.

JasonF 12-14-05 03:29 PM

I'll definitely second the recommendation for Life & Times of Scrooge McDuck, but it's not by Barks -- it's by Don Rosa.

cultshock 12-14-05 11:11 PM

I haven't read that. How does it compare to Barks?

boredsilly 12-15-05 02:57 AM


Originally Posted by cultshock
I haven't read that. How does it compare to Barks?

I can't speak for Barks, but the book turned this some what fan of Ducktales into a full blown Scrooge-aholic. I think it's possibly the best comic (superhero or otherwise) comic I've read all year. Plus Rosa is very true to the spirit of Barks, working in a lot of facts about Scrooge Barks hinted at in his comics.

JasonF 12-15-05 04:25 PM


Originally Posted by cultshock
I haven't read that. How does it compare to Barks?

The drawing style is a little more detailed and a little closer to the modern cartoons (well, the 80s cartoons, anyway -- when was the last time a Disney Duck appeared in new animation?) In terms of writing, it's so close to Barks that Rosa must be channelling his spirit.

bloopbleep 12-27-05 06:19 PM

hello I got Walt Disney Presents Uncle Scrooge: Back to the Klondike (Gladstone Comic Album Series No. 4) .The Life and Times of Scrooge McDuck (Paperback), A Contract with God : And Other Tenement Stories (Paperback)
and the newly released
The Best of the Spirit (DC comics) (Paperback) by Will Eisner ,thank you all for the recommendations, I now look forward to my first exposure to Barks,Eisner and Rosa.I will check back in a few weeks and let you know what I thought of them.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:40 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.