DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/book-talk-18/)
-   -   Worst Stephen King Book? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/book-talk/362496-worst-stephen-king-book.html)

cheapskate 06-29-04 01:31 PM

I voted "From a Buick 8" - which I finished last night.

Reads like one of Grandpa's stories - rambling, easily side-tracked. Oh, and nothing actually happens! Terrible ending - I was hoping for a reward for a hard slog through the first two thirds and was dissapointed. Finished it just so I could give it away - plus I couldn't afford to spare the bookmark. ;)

I would not have picked this up if it hadn't been the only possible choice in a tiny bookstore in Canada while on vacation last week. Even though I cut my teeth (ow) on King books growing up, I have to admit his later ones just aren't as snappy - and I've moved on (or downwards) to authors like Little, Laymon, etc...

Other King books I didn't finish were:

Dreamcatcher: I'm surprised to hear so many people didn't like it. I had heard nothing but good things about it from friends, but still it sits on my bedside table with a dusty bookmark sitting approximately halfway through. I stopped reading around the time of the alien "body rides" ESP whatever it was mumbo jumbo shit. Started off great - but couldn't take it after
Spoiler:
they killed the BEAV!


Insomnia: So it's not just me? Bookmark sitting about 30 pages from the end. Looks like I got further than most! :D

(PS - can't believe the lack of love for the Tommyknockers! I ploughed through that, and actually cried at the end - yes, like a GIRL. Of course, I was 12 years old at the time, so I'll reserve judgement! :D)

Is Gerald's Game really as bad as you all say? I love it when authors and film makers set something in the SAME PLACE for long periods of time - (but only if it's done well, obviously)

Tscott 06-29-04 02:12 PM


Originally posted by ceeece
Tscott, I highly recommend finishing Black House. I really liked it.
I'm sticking with it (after taking a break to read Orwell's 1984 and two Lemony Snicket books I borrowed from a nephew) and it's getting better now that I'm past all the long introductory stuff. I'm also in the middle of Everything's Eventual and plan to switch off books for a break if Black House gets the better of me again.

tommyp007 06-29-04 06:54 PM

For fear of being stoned, Gerald's Game is one of my favorite books! (ducks) I voted for Tommyknockers.

cultshock 06-29-04 10:58 PM

I had to go with Tommyknockers. The basic concept was a good idea, but man, is that book bloated.

I'm also a big fan of the Dark Tower books. Some of his best stuff. I'm halfway through Song of Susannah now.

Black House starts out very awkwardly for me, hell I almost gave up on it. But if you can get through the first 50 pages or so, it turns out being a great story. Not as good as The Talisman, but a must read for Dark Tower fans.

conscience 06-30-04 12:21 AM

Gerald's Game most definitely. It actually started off really good, but after the first 20 pages, blah...

MoviePage 07-01-04 02:14 AM

I liked Gerald's Game. It's been a while, but I still remember the woman handcuffed to the bed and waking up in the night to see a strange man standing in the corner (I can't remember the specifics - I think he was a murderer or something - but I remember it being very creepy).

Rose Madder is the worst for me. I read Insomnia when it first came out and didn't understand most of it, probably because I hadn't read any of the Dark Tower books at the time. I need to re-read that one.

Reading Dreamcatcher now (well, not technically reading it - listening to the unabridged audio version. From what I've heard, it's not worth the time to actually read, so I'm listening to it while commuting, etc.).

Dimension X 07-01-04 10:42 AM


Originally posted by MoviePage
I liked Gerald's Game. It's been a while, but I still remember the woman handcuffed to the bed and waking up in the night to see a strange man standing in the corner (I can't remember the specifics - I think he was a murderer or something - but I remember it being very creepy).
As I remember, the bit with the murderer in the room was in a short postscript at the end of the book, and was almost like a separate short story. It was the only part of that book I liked.

Trevor 07-03-04 12:16 AM

I have read very few King books, but quite enjoyed Gerald's Game.

And the first person I asked, who has read a lot of King, has it as one of her favorites also.

DeltaSigChi4 07-04-04 11:06 AM

All of them

NEUMANN 07-04-04 01:55 PM

I have read about 15 King books and the only one i thought was bad is insomnia it was real boring and hard to get through,all the others i have liked(although i have not read all of them on this poll, i see that the tommyknockers are leading this poll,i actually liked that book

Samuel 07-04-04 06:39 PM


Originally posted by DeltaSigChi4
All of them
Wow, you're pretty devoted. Stephen King's my favorite author and there are still 4 books from his bibliography that I've yet to read.

xmiyux 07-06-04 08:45 AM

Gerald's Game was so horrible i stopped reading King entirely. And while í'd like to check out the Dark Tower series, every time i go to pick it up the cover of Gerald's Game floats into my head and i have to put it down. Horrible.

Shap 07-09-04 12:31 PM

I can't believe how many votes Tommyknockers is getting for his worst book. I loved that story! I also liked Gerald's Game.

I voted 'From a Buick 8' as I never really got into it. The Dark Tower series is the best, especially books 2-4. I think it's starting to lose some steam now, he seems to be stretching things out too much.

auto 07-09-04 05:56 PM

I've also read his entire catalog.

Worst book: From A Buick 8

It's the only thing I've read by King that makes me think he might actually be ready to retire. :(

DeltaSigChi4 07-14-04 02:20 PM


Originally posted by Samuel
Wow, you're pretty devoted. Stephen King's my favorite author and there are still 4 books from his bibliography that I've yet to read.
You better get on that then, Sammy.

cultshock 07-14-04 08:34 PM


I've also read his entire catalog.

Worst book: From A Buick 8
I've read everything too (I've been reading King for over 20 years now), and actually I rather liked From a Buick 8. I dunno, for me, it has a bit of the old spark that has been missing from a lot of his more recent stuff (except the Dark Tower books, which are always great IMO).

RicP 07-14-04 08:39 PM


Originally posted by DeltaSigChi4
You better get on that then, Sammy.
Well aren't you just the merry imbecile.

Tommyknockers got my vote. It was written during his binge days, when he was not really writing his best stuff.

I liked GG because it was such a departure for him stylistically, though I wouldn't rate it near his best.

The Dark Tower series is the pinnacle of his career though, as is proved out with each successive novel. Volume VII should be a hell of a ride to the finish.

I think I'll have to stop and actually let it sink in that I'll finally have all 7 DT volumes ( in Grant 1st Edition hardcovers). I bought the first 2 at a book dealer back in '85 or so and have been getting the rest directly from Grant ever since. It'll be hard to finally admit that it's all over.

Geofferson 07-15-04 09:54 AM


Originally posted by RicP
I think I'll have to stop and actually let it sink in that I'll finally have all 7 DT volumes ( in Grant 1st Edition hardcovers). I bought the first 2 at a book dealer back in '85 or so and have been getting the rest directly from Grant ever since. It'll be hard to finally admit that it's all over.
I know. It'll be a sad, sad day when I finish DT VII.

Bandoman 07-15-04 12:30 PM

"Cujo" was the only SK book I hated.

WillieTheShakes 07-15-04 03:00 PM


Originally posted by atreyue
And if you're looking for reasons to appreciate the Stand, consider the current trend of writing books with multiple main character perspectives. I don't want to go out on a limb, but it's very possible that SK started it (for better or worse) with this book.
Good thing you didn't go out on a limb -- King was far from the first writer to use multiple viewpoints.

wmansir 07-20-04 11:09 PM

I've read a lot of King, but I couldn't vote in the poll because the only books I have read on the list are the Dark Tower series and Tommyknockers and I enjoyed them both. I've read all the classic King stuff, but with the exception of the DT series I haven't been keeping up. Based on the selection of books for this poll I don't think I have missed much.

Filmmaker 07-26-04 06:37 PM

ROSE MADDER by a country mile...frankly, I'm astonished GERALD'S GAME ranks so much worse on this list (word to the wise, I've not yet tackled DREAMCATCHER, but the movie was definitely grade-Z tripe--I had hoped the book would offer a vast improvement, but this poll seems to imply otherwise...a shame...). It's kind of ironic--I've always considered GERALD'S GAME, DOLORES CLAIBORNE and ROSE MADDER to make up an unofficial "battered women trilogy", and have always found DOLORES CLAIBORNE to be one of King's finest hours, GERALD'S GAME to be enjoyable, but rather average, and ROSE MADDER to be the single most excrutiatingly difficult King read to be suffered through (though even at his lowest point of story-creating talent, his command of the language makes for its own compelling, hard-to-put-the-book down element). Even though I might be hard-pressed to find anyone who will agree with me, I rank the pseudonymously penned THINNER a close 2nd...BAG OF BONES would likely be 3rd...that one read like the mind of V.C. Andrews filtered through the voice of King...not so fortuitous of a mix...

twikoff 07-26-04 08:42 PM

Ive read ALOT Of SK books.. and of the ones Ive read so far.. Gerald's game is the only one I didnt bother finishing

although.. there are a couple on that list I havent read yet.. so I guess they could be worse
bag of bones (although I have this one now, so Ill give it a shot).. and from a buick 8

http://www.twikoff.com/dvdtalk/dasTwik.gif

Rainet 04-02-06 06:45 PM

Another vote for Gerald's Game. It was so bad, it scared me. I was in high school at the time and i read all his books up that point. I loved just about all his books even (Tommyknockers). So when i got to Gerald's Game i was in sudden shock. Just amazed of the drop compared to his earlier work. Remember most of the past 15 years (up and down in quality) etc hasn't happened yet.

Fok 04-03-06 02:12 PM

I find his old stuff to be great, not quite sure what's happened to him now though

brainee 04-03-06 02:25 PM

I went with "Dreamcatcher" though "Gerald's Game" is a very worthy worst choice too. I guess I give GG some bonus points for at least trying something different. I think King's output has suffered since he became a mega-star in that no editors probably have the stones to tell him to change anything. You'd think an editor, if confronted with something like DC from a lesser-known writer, would have the initial response: "Shit weasels?!? Haha, that's a good one. Now where's the real book?"

The Bus 04-03-06 02:30 PM

I was really into reading his stuff when I was 12... a few years later none of the stuff was very interesting to me.

I could never finish The Dark Tower and Desperation was pretty bad too.

My favorite? I'd say The Dark Half.

darkessenz 04-03-06 10:36 PM

Geralds game/rose madder-Only started both, but didn't like either one enough to continue.

Also, bag of bones I could not get into. I need to read insomnia.

Man did I love IT, Eyes of the Dragon, 1-4 DT (haven't gotten to the last 3), The Stand, Bachman Books, ALL of the short stories (practically).

King rocks...its too bad I didn't have the steam to plow through some of the more recent stuff. I am in a different stage of reading, kinda trying to read some more classical and acclaimed stuff.

I will finish DT though...probably the coolest synergy ever. I wish he wrote more fantasy, and it really makes sense that DT is quite compelling when you consider the strongest points of his other novels. DT is like diving into the entire mystique that submerges the everyday occurences in other novels...

Pwman 04-04-06 02:56 AM


Originally Posted by Filmmaker
ROSE MADDER by a country mile...frankly, I'm astonished GERALD'S GAME ranks so much worse on this list (word to the wise, I've not yet tackled DREAMCATCHER, but the movie was definitely grade-Z tripe--I had hoped the book would offer a vast improvement, but this poll seems to imply otherwise...a shame...). It's kind of ironic--I've always considered GERALD'S GAME, DOLORES CLAIBORNE and ROSE MADDER to make up an unofficial "battered women trilogy", and have always found DOLORES CLAIBORNE to be one of King's finest hours, GERALD'S GAME to be enjoyable, but rather average, and ROSE MADDER to be the single most excrutiatingly difficult King read to be suffered through (though even at his lowest point of story-creating talent, his command of the language makes for its own compelling, hard-to-put-the-book down element). Even though I might be hard-pressed to find anyone who will agree with me, I rank the pseudonymously penned THINNER a close 2nd...BAG OF BONES would likely be 3rd...that one read like the mind of V.C. Andrews filtered through the voice of King...not so fortuitous of a mix...


You could add Insomnia to your battered womans list. The victim actually turns lesbian from the abuse. I asked some lesbians I know if that was something that happened in real life and they just laughed. I've read almost all of Kings books. Met him twice, once in the hotel Boulderado where Misery takes place and the other in Estes Park while he was filming The Shining TV miniseries. I did get to converse with him for a while but I never got around to telling him how much I hated Geralds Game or that domestic violence is not a leading cause of homosexuality.

Filmmaker 04-04-06 08:17 AM

I don't think it caused her to become homosexual...some people have bisexual tendencies--that's all I read into INSOMNIA's instance. I also don't include INSOMNIA in the "battered women" trilogy since the character referenced, while key to the plot, is not a main character.

Buttmunker 04-04-06 03:45 PM

I'm convinced that, since his wife Tabitha is also a writer, that the bad Stephen King books are really written by her!

MovieExchange 04-04-06 10:30 PM


Originally Posted by Buttmunker
I'm convinced that, since his wife Tabitha is also a writer, that the bad Stephen King books are really written by her!

After what filmmaker dubbed "the battered women trilogy," that was a major rumor. I wouldn't be surprised if it was true.

modfather 04-05-06 09:35 AM

Does anyone know if SK has a particular "least favorite"? I doubt he would hold a press conference to announce such a thing, but just wondering if he'd ever mentioned it...

Michael Corvin 04-06-06 07:42 AM


Originally Posted by MovieExchange
After what filmmaker dubbed "the battered women trilogy," that was a major rumor. I wouldn't be surprised if it was true.

I remember that. It's always that or that he had college writers writing for him around that time as well. About that time he was churning them out like Patterson does.

Dogg 04-07-06 11:37 AM

I've read all of his books, one of my favorite authors. Tommyknockers was my least favorite...it just seemed to drag on and on and on.

Tommy Ceez 04-11-06 11:19 PM

I just started reading this thread and was confused by all the posts on page 1 Talking about the Dark Tower being his crowning achievement, then I saw the post that talked about Song of Suzanah coming out SOON, looked at the dates and said ....ahhhhhh!

jmj713 04-12-06 02:03 PM

I loved Insomnia and Rose Madder.

starry 04-12-06 02:26 PM

Well, I haven't read Dreamcatcher but saw the movie which sucked big time. My choice of the books I read would be Insomnia. It just seemed to go on and on. A massive edit would have improved that book tremendously. Same with the Stand though that is my favourite of his books.

twa2 04-12-06 03:31 PM

Definitely The Dark Half. Although Dreamcatcher was pretty bad, too.

Palpadious 04-16-06 05:25 PM

The Tommyknockers was chore to get through, but I remeber The Regulators being pretty awful, although I did like Depseration


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:01 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.