Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
#5
Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 234
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
So the discs are in sleeves and Creature From the Black Lagoon is defective according to reviews? I think I'll still have to pass.
#6
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
#10
Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
AFAIK the only difference between the US and the UK set, content wise, is that the UK set is missing one of the commentary tracks on Dracula.
#11
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
What is the defect for Creature? My UK version played great. I didn't notice anything.
#12
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
It was vastly overpriced to begin with and I am not sure there is a huge potential market for this set. Most people only want one or two of the movies in it, beyond the hardcore collectors. I expect it to continue dropping in price, both in the US and the UK.
#16
DVD Talk Special Edition
#17
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
Who said I was bragging? Just stating a fact relative to the post about STAR WARS being somehow more worthy of purchase than this set. Not everyone has the same tastes or buying priorities.
#18
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 2,080
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
I generally mock people who get all OCD over packaging but most foreign logos are hideous and take up a lot more real estate on the cover compared to the relatively-tasteful MPAA ratings.
I'd say that missing commentary is more of a factor on this release. Once they drop actual content I'll generally draw the line. A lot of the older titles in the Bond 50 box set had their original mono tracks dropped to make room for additional foreign language tracks (which is probably what happened here with the Dracula disc) and that's definitely a dealbreaker.
The instant gratification of fast Amazon Prime shipping is yet another factor for me.
I'd say that missing commentary is more of a factor on this release. Once they drop actual content I'll generally draw the line. A lot of the older titles in the Bond 50 box set had their original mono tracks dropped to make room for additional foreign language tracks (which is probably what happened here with the Dracula disc) and that's definitely a dealbreaker.
The instant gratification of fast Amazon Prime shipping is yet another factor for me.
#19
Member
Join Date: Nov 2011
Posts: 129
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
Tough one for me. I'll likely go for the UK set while it's still on special, though that missing commentary track is what's kept me from pulling the trigger so far. Even being the completest that I am though, it's hard to justify an additional $40 for one commentary track.
#20
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
I still say the fact that Frankenstein vs Wolfman is not part of this is a huge reason why it doesn't really feel complete.
#21
Senior Member
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
I remember one of the commentary tracks on either Frankenstein or Dracula (or perhaps it was both of them) was extraordinarly dry and mostly stating the obvious ("In this static shot, the actor playing Reinfield will enter the scene on the left, move toward the center. The next shot is an establishing shot...."). If that's the sort of commentary that was dropped, more power to them! --Peter
#22
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
The point was there is much more demand for Star Wars than this and the Universal Monster set has much more potential for price drops and sales than something that is (almost) UNIVERSALly loved.
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
The lack of Star Wars love in this thread is very upsetting to me. I shall not return to this thread...
#24
Member
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 237
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
Aside from the dropped commentary on Dracula and the additional languages/subs, are there any other differences between the UK and US sets? I've did some searching but couldn't find any AV comparisons.
#25
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Amazon DOTW 1/13 - 1/19: Universal Classic Monsters Collection $79.99
I generally mock people who get all OCD over packaging but most foreign logos are hideous and take up a lot more real estate on the cover compared to the relatively-tasteful MPAA ratings.
I'd say that missing commentary is more of a factor on this release. Once they drop actual content I'll generally draw the line. A lot of the older titles in the Bond 50 box set had their original mono tracks dropped to make room for additional foreign language tracks (which is probably what happened here with the Dracula disc) and that's definitely a dealbreaker.
The instant gratification of fast Amazon Prime shipping is yet another factor for me.
I'd say that missing commentary is more of a factor on this release. Once they drop actual content I'll generally draw the line. A lot of the older titles in the Bond 50 box set had their original mono tracks dropped to make room for additional foreign language tracks (which is probably what happened here with the Dracula disc) and that's definitely a dealbreaker.
The instant gratification of fast Amazon Prime shipping is yet another factor for me.
Tough one for me. I'll likely go for the UK set while it's still on special, though that missing commentary track is what's kept me from pulling the trigger so far. Even being the completest that I am though, it's hard to justify an additional $40 for one commentary track.