LBPound

This is the second edition of the DVD Talk Top 100 DVDs poll, now including the impressive releases from late 2000. If you have not voted after December 1, 2000, please do so, even if it's just to post the same 10 as before.

Much thanks to darktrippers for coming up with this great idea! See his post below for info on how the list is tabulated.

Voters counted (103): Hetz, exm, ali, TonyDVD, JohnDill17, DaveBR1, fiver, B5Erik, hermit, Paveguy, Josh Martin, Kojack, dstrauss, JeTmAn, Robert, farahaqil, LBPound23, lesterlong, Fromundacheese, John H, Rascal, chisdwel, Pasolini, KitchenSink, Reese Feces, apeyard, spoon81, MidnightBomber, BartleyR7, amplified, agent mulder, dbrink, Todd Bangerter, Peat, Cereal-Killer, SAShepherd, darktrippers, 007bugs, Skrazem, Jason, apchrist, siberianluck, Autotelik, Space Samurai, MrVette99, adboy151, Gandalf, wrath, dglaser6, Phuzbox, nightliner, sabre, RDYoung, tezza, CaptDS9E, KungFuGrip, bluedevil, Dr. DVD, TexasGuy, gordon2, cwwallace, gcribbs, Jehan, HKnight, Al Infinitum, Bluewatr, rĉingoth, mjduda, wildcatkid, Heath Ewey, kino eye, Neitzl, HeatSeeker, Sinjin, arrghenshnorf, Silent_ Bob, Michael G, Monk506, Gonnosuke, crikey, ews3, Teri, Hamilton777, dvdnation, dom56, Dr. Dean, Anthony Soprano, Calistoga, Pudthai, SIUmark, Johnny Zhivago, bishop2knight, Masoo, William Ward, Cujo13, rabbit77, lodger_001, MaXYYYY, Jabx, MrGradenko, Sparrow, garmonbozia, caiman

The original Top 100 DVD Talk DVDs Census Thread: http://talk.dvdtalk.com/ubb/Forum3/HTML/016515.html

[Edited by LBPound23 on 03-16-01 at 06:41 PM]

LBPound

My top ten:

1) The Ultimate Toy Box
2) Ghostbusters
3) A Bug's Life CE
4) Ghostbusters II
5) Scrooged
6) Jurassic Park CE
7) Mrs. Doubtfire
8) Ferris Bueller's Day Off
9) Jaws CE
10) Apollo 13 CE

lesterlong

Top 10
1. Gladiator
2. X-Men
3. Fight Club
4. Face/Off
5. Clay Pigeons
6. Go
7. Boogie Nights CE
8. Terminator 2 UE
9. Toy Story Ultimate Box
10. Ghostbusters

Fromundacheese

1. 'Toy Story UTB'
2. 'X-Files Season 1'
3. 'X-Files Season 2'
4. 'Magnolia'
5. 'Fight Club'
6. 'Gladiator'
7. 'The Abyss'
8. 'Terminator 2' LE
9. 'Matrix' (had to put that in)
10. Winstar's 'Killer'

John H

1 T2 Ultimate Edition
2 Ultimate Toy Box
3 ThE MaTrIx
Gladiator(Tie)
4 Independence Day
5 A Bug's Life CE
6 Pink Floyd The Wall
7 Saving Private Ryan DTS
8 Aliens
9 Austin Powers
10Ghostbusters

[This message has been edited by John H (edited December 06, 2000).]

Rascal

1. North By Northwest
   
2. The Ultimate Toy Box
   
3. 39 Steps Criterion
   
4. Bug's Life, A CE
   
5. Abyss SE
   
6. Goldfinger
   
7. Vertigo
   
8. Lola Rennt
   
9. Boot, Das CE
   
10. Fantasia Anthology
    

chsidwel

1. Gladiator
2. Braveheart
3. Fight Club
4. T2 UE
5. Silence of the Lambs CC
6. Leon (international version)
7. Ultimate Toy box
8. Tarzan CE
9. MIB LE
10. Abyss SE

Pasolini

1 Fight Club
2 Toy Story Ultimate Box
3 Fantasia Anthology
4 Brazil CC
5 Boogie Nights
6 Grand Illusion CC
7 Bug's Life
8 Sound of Music
9 T2
10 12 Monkeys

I really REALLY wanted to put in Wizard of Oz Deluxe, Rushmore CC, Red Shoes CC, NxNW, and Dark City, but the list nazis only want 10 T2 and Abyss would be much higher if Cameron had bothered to do a commentary!

KitchenSink

Terminator 2 - UE
Silence of the Lambs - CC
Gladiator
Das Boot
Robocop - CC
Blues Brothers - CE
Apollo 13 - CE
Men In Black - LE
Goldfinger
Independence Day


------------------
"I do wish we could chat longer, but I'm having an old friend for dinner."

Reese Feces

Braveheart
Chasing Amy CC
Shawshank Redemption
Toy story UTB
Fight Club
Magnolia
Gladiator
Life Is Beautiful
Halloween Ltd ed.
Good Will Hunting

------------------
"I Don't Do Humans"

apeyard

Boogie Nights (2 disc)
Rushmore CC
Fight Club
Ultimate Toy Box
T2 UE
Gladiator
Patriot
Braveheart
Sound of Music
Matrix

------------------
My DVD's

spoon81

1. Toy Story Ultimate Box
2. Fight Club
3. Fantasia Anthology
4. Gladiator
5. Pee-Wee's Big Adventure
6. Vertigo
7. Men In Black LE
8. The Wizard of Oz
9. Nightmare Before Christmas CE
10.Election

MidnightBomber

1. Brazil CC
2. Magnolia
3. American Beauty
4. Braveheart
5. Gattaca
6. The Third Man CC
7. Gladiator
8. Leon Integral Edition
9. Seven Samurai CC
10. Hard Boiled CC

------------------
"When looking at faults, use a mirror, not a telescope."
-Yazid Ibrahim

darktrippers

Thanks for injecting new blood into the thread, lb, and carrying it into the next wave of releases. I'll post a link to this updated version from my new thread The Ultimate Movie Club. Check it out by the way, new input is required.

Here are those rules and criteria you requested.

List your Top Ten favourite discs in your collection (taking into account the extras, as well as the movie itself), in order of preference. Mark draws if applicable. Points will be divided between them thus: 1st, 7 points/2nd, 6 points/3rd, 5 points/ 4th, 4 points/ 5th-10th 3 points each.

eg.
1st = 7 points
1st = 7 points
3rd = 5 points
4 = 4
4 = 4
6 = 3
7 = 3
8 = 3
9 = 3
10 = 3

IMPORTANT: If all Ten Films are equally placed, the order you write them will be taken into consideration.


Will post my updated Top Ten soon.

Cheers.
dt.


[This message has been edited by darktrippers (edited December 06, 2000).]

BartleyR7

1) Office Space
2) Toy Story UTB
3) Fantasia Anthology
4) A Bug's Life CE
5) U571
6) Fight Club
7) Face/Off
8) Titan AE
9) Terminator 2 UE
10) The Green Mile

------------------
"PC Load Letter?!?"

My DVD Collection

[This message has been edited by BartleyR7 (edited December 06, 2000).]

amplified

1. Magnolia
2. American Beauty
3. The Usual Suspects
4. Gladiator
5. Silence of the Lambs CC
6. The Game
7. The Sixth Sense
8. Groundhog Day
9. Ultimate Toy Box
10.Fight Club

agent mulder

1) Matrix
2) Magnolia
3) Green Mile
4) Saving Private Ryan
5) Frequency
6) Contact
7) Gladiator
8) Meet Joe Black
9) Gattaca
10) Postman

nevermind

Matrix
Toy Story UTB
Gladiator
The Abyss SE
Fight Club
Mallrats
Jurassic Park
Chasing Amy
X-Files Season 1
X-Files Season 2


And ready to bust into my top ten (when they get here):
Sopranos
Dogma SE
Almost Famous(God I loved this movie)




------------------
"Can I have a panda cone, dad?"
"What happened to the $68 I send your mother every month?"
"Weekday Dad wanted a DVD player."

TheBang

1. Terminator 2 UE
2. Toy Story: Ultimate Toy Box
3. Fight Club
4. Blade
5. Magnolia
6. Ghostbusters
7. Brazil Criterion
8. Fantasia Anthology
9. Mission Impossible 2
10. A Bug's Life: CE

Peat

1. The Abyss
2. The Matrix
3. Three Kings
4. Armageddon Criterion Collection
5. Life of Brian Criterion Collection
6. Gladiator
7. Boogie Nights : 2 disc set
8. Fantasia Anthology
9. 12 Monkeys
10. Jurassic Park

Josh Martin

1. Toy Story UTB
2. Brazil CC
3. Terminator 2 UE
4. Fantasia Anthology
5. Beastie Boys CC
6. Carnival of Souls CC
7. Fight Club
8. 12 Monkeys CE
9. Hard Boiled CC
10. A Bug's Life CE

LBPound

BUMPING UP FOR MORE PEOPLE TO VOTE!!! Anyone who hasn't yet voted (or not after December 1) VOTE!!!

I've updated the list, once more people vote I'll post it. This is a very close race, so the more people that vote, the better (and more representative of DVD Talk as a whole) this list will be.

Cereal-Killer

1- Fight Club
2- Mallrats
3- Hard Boiled: Criterion
4- Chasing Amy: Criterion
5- Brazil: Criterion
6- Toy Story: Ultimate Toy Box
7- A Bug's Life: Collector's Edition
8- The Alien Legacy
9- Dark City
10- T2: Ultimate Edition

------------------
I will not be pushed, filed, stamped, indexed, briefed, debriefed or numbered. My life is my own.

SAShepherd

1. Toy Story: Ultimate Toy Box
2. Brazil: Criterion
3. Run Lola Run
4. This is Spinal Tap (MGM version)
5. Rushmore: Criterion
6. The Limey
7. The Abyss SE
8. Fantasia Anthology
9. Stop Making Sense
10. Decalogue

darktrippers

1 Fight Club
2 Toy Story Ultimate Boxset
3 Taxi Driver
4 T2 UE
5 Matrix
6 Go
7 Gladiator
8 The Player
9 Spinal Tap
10 Vertigo

[This message has been edited by darktrippers (edited December 07, 2000).]