I agree. With the exception of the Thrawn trilogy and the X-wing series of novels, the post-ROTJ EU is pretty bad. The prequel-era novels were much better though. I especially like the Bane and Plagueis novels because they fill in a lot of backstory to the prequels.

Its pretty funny how the original movie trilogy was good and the EU was crap, but the opposite is true with the prequels in that the movie trilogy was crap and the EU was good.

Same here. If the characters only ever duel one time, why is there a need to specify the movie? That makes no sense.

for instance
Vader vs luke - Technically there were 3 battles. ESB in the swamp (yeah some weird force halucination - doesn't really count) ESB in bespin and ROTJ in the final battle. luckily everyone specified which one.

Bake your noodle over Obi Wan vs Vader.
I will expand when the question comes up and I am sure some of you will challenge.

I guess there's a clear answer but it took me a bit to think about it.

That would be a case for providing the movie instead of the participants.

Movie and Lightsaber Fights have a many:many relationship. You have to be specific.

I'm just hoping most people got their answers from Caravan of Courage and not The Battle For Endor.

Here's hoping these answers are all the same

I would argue that Obi Wan versus Vader is different van Obi Wan versus Vader episode 4 and Obi Wan versus Vader episode 3, but obi wan versus Anakin in episode 3 and Obi Wan versus Vader episode 3 are the same. by the time they fight at the end of the movie Anakin is vader.

Players list:

cruzness 0
goat3001 0
ivelostr2 0
Kal-El 0
Boba Fett 0
Michael Corvin 0
wishbone 0
dalbowski 0
Groucho 0
pinata242 0
davidh777 0
bootsy 0
Obi-Wan Jabroni 0
jcheckel 0
cnicholls44 0
Jeremy517 0
Rockmjd23 0
bunkaroo 0
Mordred 0
devilshalo 0
achau9598 0
RagingBull80 0
kgrogers1979 0
hasslien 0
cusm 0
Todd B. 0
rocket1312 0
SterlingBen 0
Shannon Nutt 0
Damfino 20

Controversy to follow

1. S: Name the best lightsaber battle in the movies.

Obi Wan vs Vader = Episode 3
Ben vs Vader = Episode 4

Vader: "He is here."
Tarkin: "Obi-Wan Kenobi? What makes you think so?"
Vader: "A tremor in the Force. The last time I felt it was in the presence of my old master."

Episode 4 is also Vader vs. Obi-Wan, at least from Vader's (and, arguably Ben's) certain point-of-view.

That's it for today, folks. Scoring will continue tomorrow!

That was fun! Great game all!

Tied for first!

I at least got 3 questions in before I had to quit

Peace out homey.

Sorry helping with a provcedure.

"I really, really need to get back to the Sheep resvlts..."

alright back for a few minutes

I love how all the SheepMasters do this at work.