OldBoy

probably Rage will have some votes...

Tarantino

Mine is Brink. It sounded like such an awesome game and had a kickass trailer. I bought it for $10 used a few months after it's terrible reviews and dumped it after playing for about an hour. Awful game.

Dead Island was disappointing as well...after getting really good reviews, it was just really boring.

discostu1337

Battlefield 3. Bad Company 2 is the all-time best online game ever, and BF3 makes zero improvements and hundreds of problems. This could actually be my biggest disappointment of all-time.

edstein

Rage for me. I usually keep games forever until they're worth nothing but this game I returned as soon as I beat the campaign. Graphics were awesome and the game play wasn't bad but the story sucked and the ending was the worst I've seen in a long time.

Homefront would be another I'd add to the list.

Deftones

my biggest disappointment is spiderman: edge of time. was nothing like shattered dimensions.

foxdvd

Brink....I talked 5 of my friends into buying it and hyped it up so even they could not wait....

ultimaton

Dragon Age II. It was clearly rushed out the door and as a result it ended up being not only a half of a game, but a repetitive and dull on with that, that also featured an inexcusable amount of bugs and glitches, including a few game breakers.

Dan

Duke Nukem Forever.

starseed1981

L.A. Noire. Without a doubt.

MrX

Dragon Age II

Deftones

that's probably 2nd on my list.

slop101

Arkham City - not that it was bad, it was actually really good, but I was just expecting it to be way better than Asylum and not only was it not better, it wasn't even as good. It's all about expectations.

movie diva

Dragon Age II

nickdawgy

I think Dragon Age II is a great choice. Didn't even feel like the first one.

I would say Saints Row The Third as well.

chuckd21

Battlefield 3, easily. The only game to make me legitimately angry this year.

jdpatri

BF3 has been growing on me despite my early distaste. LA Noire was a good game but grew tiresome. Arkham City on the other hand feels like Grand Theft Gotham and that has been a big turnoff. I played 30 mins or so and I just haven't gone back yet. Arkham Asylum is a favorite game of this gen. There's nothing terrible about it... It's just not what I wanted.

nickdawgy

Arkham City was great. Not sure how it could have disappointed.

mattysemo247

Another vote for Rage

MoviePage

Rage, easily.

JasonF

Every game that isn't Skyrim.

Also, I haven't played the new Spider-Man, but I really liked the first, so the terrible reviews of the new one are pretty disappointing.

glassdragon

Rage

Match

Homefront

Groucho

Batman: Arkham City for me as well. It wasn't a bad game by any means, and it did correct some problems from the first game -- but overall the experience wasn't nearly as amazing.

Michael Corvin

Biggest disappointment has to be Nintendo completely abandoning the Wii for the first 10 months of 2011.

Fandango

Batman AC being sold out within a minute of it going live.