Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon)
#1
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon)
<object width="600" height="391"><param name="movie" value="http://www.traileraddict.com/emd/44302"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><embed src="http://www.traileraddict.com/emd/44302" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" wmode="transparent" width="600" height="391" allowFullScreen="true"></embed></object>
#2
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
that doesn't look preachy at all.
Romper Stomper meets Hotel Rwanda. I'm not sold, even though I like Marc Forster. I loved Quatum of Solace.
Romper Stomper meets Hotel Rwanda. I'm not sold, even though I like Marc Forster. I loved Quatum of Solace.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
Looks good. Gerard Butler has put out some junk lately -- glad to see he's back to the drama / action roles he's made for.
#6
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
Liked it better when Jack Bauer did it at the pre-season of 24 Season 9. Plus Marc Forster? The guy who made the most boring, forgettable, anti-Bond movie of all time that the producers of this film chose to credit Kite Runner in the trailer instead of Quantum of Suck? pass.
#7
#8
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Feb 2000
Location: Home of the 2009 Stanley Cup & Vince Lombardi trophy!!!
Posts: 6,117
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I wish Gerard Butler would've been in "The Next Three Days" instead of Russell Crowe, I can't watch it without thinking how good Butler would've been in the lead. Anyhow, this looks pretty good, I'm just hoping it isn't a 3 hour epic or anything.
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I don't know what it is about an American accent that forces Butler to talk out of the side of his mouth, but for some reason it's distracting.
#11
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
Although I'm glad it's not another Hobo with a Shotgun, I was hoping for a Western. This looks decent but nothing special.
#15
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
Saw this last night. Thought it was good (not great), running time was a bit too long, can be depressing as it shows the suffering that is occurring in the Sudan (with some graphic scenes). I give it a B
#16
Senior Member
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
this movie was really good.
another great film by Marc Forster - this did remind me a bit of The Kite Runner, another quality movie.
Gerard Butler gives the performance of his career, and the story is powerful and poignant.
What's at the heart & soul of this film is a meditation on personal redemption, and also on justice and righteousness.
Great stuff, highly recommended. This is NOT a Tarantino grindhouse feature lol. This is a serious and moving film. THere wasn't a dry eye in the house when the light came up, everyone stood up and clapped.
Go see it, and ignore all the biased leftist reviews that are trying to smother this film.
another great film by Marc Forster - this did remind me a bit of The Kite Runner, another quality movie.
Gerard Butler gives the performance of his career, and the story is powerful and poignant.
What's at the heart & soul of this film is a meditation on personal redemption, and also on justice and righteousness.
Great stuff, highly recommended. This is NOT a Tarantino grindhouse feature lol. This is a serious and moving film. THere wasn't a dry eye in the house when the light came up, everyone stood up and clapped.
Go see it, and ignore all the biased leftist reviews that are trying to smother this film.
Last edited by IstvanTheHun; 06-13-12 at 12:59 AM.
#17
Senior Member
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
And I agree, Marc Forster is one of the best directors around today. His film are generally never less than excellent. Quantum of Solace was by far the best crafted Bond film yet.
#18
Senior Member
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
#19
Senior Member
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
and all have a common-denominator: they can't actually criticize much of the film, they just dislike it because of some whacked left-wing bias. Even Roger Ebert couldn't say much about the film except he had trouble digesting the spiritual themes/conflicts of the movie.
Some idiot even called it "racist christian republican propaganda". laughable; these pseudo-intellectuals always fall prey to their own prejudices and political biases.
The review here, by Jason Bailey, was moderate, but still biased. While his essay reeked with liberal affront, he did actually discuss the one flaw of the film, which is the time compression of the story. I agree, it was a bit wierd how the film jumped ahead in time so often, but it was a necessary flaw, otherwise the film would easily be 4 hours long.
but other, like Eber, didnt bother much to analys the cinematical content of the film, and just blathered and ranted about Christians.
#20
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 309
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I watched this last week, and thought it was ok. It started out with a lot of cliches, and even though it is based on a true story, made me kind of roll my eyes. Picked up around the middle, but the movie felt way longer than it was and overstayed its welcome.
Butler did a good job, and I like Marc Forster so I was mostly into the movie, just kind of underwhelmed. They really over did it with all the scenes of Butler saving people, lost its power around the fourth time it happened.
**1/2 out of ****
Butler did a good job, and I like Marc Forster so I was mostly into the movie, just kind of underwhelmed. They really over did it with all the scenes of Butler saving people, lost its power around the fourth time it happened.
**1/2 out of ****
#21
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 309
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I've read a variety of reviews, all mostly negative.
and all have a common-denominator: they can't actually criticize much of the film, they just dislike it because of some whacked left-wing bias. Even Roger Ebert couldn't say much about the film except he had trouble digesting the spiritual themes/conflicts of the movie.
Some idiot even called it "racist christian republican propaganda". laughable; these pseudo-intellectuals always fall prey to their own prejudices and political biases.
The review here, by Jason Bailey, was moderate, but still biased. While his essay reeked with liberal affront, he did actually discuss the one flaw of the film, which is the time compression of the story. I agree, it was a bit wierd how the film jumped ahead in time so often, but it was a necessary flaw, otherwise the film would easily be 4 hours long.
but other, like Eber, didnt bother much to analys the cinematical content of the film, and just blathered and ranted about Christians.
and all have a common-denominator: they can't actually criticize much of the film, they just dislike it because of some whacked left-wing bias. Even Roger Ebert couldn't say much about the film except he had trouble digesting the spiritual themes/conflicts of the movie.
Some idiot even called it "racist christian republican propaganda". laughable; these pseudo-intellectuals always fall prey to their own prejudices and political biases.
The review here, by Jason Bailey, was moderate, but still biased. While his essay reeked with liberal affront, he did actually discuss the one flaw of the film, which is the time compression of the story. I agree, it was a bit wierd how the film jumped ahead in time so often, but it was a necessary flaw, otherwise the film would easily be 4 hours long.
but other, like Eber, didnt bother much to analys the cinematical content of the film, and just blathered and ranted about Christians.
#22
Moderator
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I used to like Gerard Butler - but the roles he's picked recently all seem the same.
Last edited by Giles; 10-13-11 at 11:30 PM.
#23
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Sitting on a beach, earning 20%
Posts: 9,917
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
IstvanTheHun, it sounds like the most defined bias is the one you have yourself. Someone isn't a "whacked left-winger" simply because they disagree with you.
It's a shame about how quickly this film vanished. I quite wanted to see it.
It's a shame about how quickly this film vanished. I quite wanted to see it.
#24
Senior Member
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I am not a professional reviewer, hence my bias is that, my bias. I am not being paid to objectively critique cinema. Roger Ebert is. And he wasn't particularly fair in his review, because he disagreed with Childers himself, and not the movie.
#25
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: Machine Gun Preacher (9/23/11, Dir: M. Forster/G. Butler, M. Monaghan, M. Shannon
I saw it. It was cliche as hell. Really wanted to like it. Had some good moments but it's mediocre scripting killed it. It's average. A bit too preachy for it's own good..which in the way it was done went to the cliche fast.
Could have been a much much better film but...to me..it's the cliche factor that kills this movie the most. I know and understand who the character is but..it's done poorly. Like it was said..it really makes you roll your eyes.
Could have been a much much better film but...to me..it's the cliche factor that kills this movie the most. I know and understand who the character is but..it's done poorly. Like it was said..it really makes you roll your eyes.