Original Desmond

There are a lot of new shows, seem more than usual to me.

I reckon this thread will be useful for a easy reference to what people have thought have been good and bad

so far here's mine

Nikita - B
Mike and Molly - C-
Outlaw - C+
Chase - C-
Hawaii Five O - B+
Hellcats - B-

today i'm gonna watch the Event, the Defenders, Undercovers and the Whole truth

Count Dooku

Hellcats: C
Nikita: B-
Lone Star: Incomplete
Terriers: A-

DJariya

It's tough to rate a series as a whole in it's rookie season based off a few episodes. Some shows start off rough or mediocre, but get better as the season progresses and as the writers get more comfortable writing the characters.

I've tried alot so far with more to come:
Hellcats: B
Terriers: B
Nikita: B+
Outlaw: C-
Chase: C+
Hawaii Five-O: A
Undercovers: B-
Top Chef: Just Desserts: B (I know it's a competition, but it's still new)

scorpion

Only ones I've seen this season:

Terriers: A
Hawaii Five-0: A-
The Event: C-

Gdrlv

Boardwalk Empire - A+
Hawaii Five 0 - B-
The Event - C
Mike & Molly - D

wmansir

I was going to start this thread, or just a recommend a new show thread, myself because there are so many pilots and I don't think I have time for them all.

Nikita: B+
Hawaii 5-0: B-
The Event: incomplete (bailed after 15 minutes)

Red Dog

Good:
The Event
Lone Star
The Defenders
Good Guys
Boardwalk Empire
Blue Bloods

Meh:
Hawaii-5-0
Hellcats

Crap:
Outlaw
Shit Dad Says

RichC2

Boardwalk Empire: A-
Hawaii Five-O: B
Raising Hope: B
Better With You: B-
Chase: C
The Event: C

KaBluie

Raising Hope
1st episode - put me to sleep
2nd episode - Liked it, maybe I'll try the first one again
3rd episode - funny

Running Wilde
1st episode - huge disapointment
2nd episode - I give up
3rd episode - laughfed once at The Office joke, The Blue Man Group ref seemed a little desperate

Outsourced
1st episode - didn't care for
2nd episode - not bad

Haven't watched any of these since.

maingon

The Event: B
Shit Dad Says: D
Outsourced: C-

JuryDuty

Nikita - Thumbs up! Nice surprise.
Hawaii 5-0 - Thumbs up! Pretty good.
Raising Hope - Thumbs up! Loved it.
The Event - Thumbs up! Redeemed at the end.
Undercovers - Thumbs up! Fun.

Lone Star - Undecided...very well done, but an unlikable lead.

Outsourced - Thumbs down...ok, but nothing must-see about it.
Running Wilde - Thumbs down...awkward. (But hoping it'll get better!)

zekeburger1979

Boardwalk Empire: A+
Rubicon: A
Terriers: A
Lone Star: A-
The Defenders: B
Detroit 187: B-
The Event: B-
Raising Hope: B-
Blue Bloods: C+
Mike and Molly: C+
Hawaii Five-O: C
Chase: C
Undercovers: C
Better with You: C-
The Whole Truth: D+
Running Wilde: D- (Reference to AD prevents it from an F rating)
Shit My Dad Says: F
Outlaw: F
Outsourced: F

Still need to Watch:

Blue Bloods
Law and Order: L.A.
My Generation
Ordinary Family

NORML54601

When the hell do you work or sleep?

kstublen

Chase: C-
The Event: TBD
The Increasingly Poor Decisions Of Todd Margaret: B+
Lone Star: TBD
Mike & Molly: C
Outsourced: D-
Raising Hope: A+
Running Wilde: D-
Shit My Dad Says: F
Terriers: A

Shit My Dad Says gets an F because I couldn't even make it through the show and won't be giving it a second chance. As of right now, with only one episode, Running Wilde and Outsourced both get a D-, but expect that to change to an F if things don't significantly improve in the second episode.

EDIT: After watching the second episode of Running Wilde, I think I'll still leave it as a D-, because as bad as it was, Shit My Dad Says Was Worse. That said, I'm done with the show for now and don't plan to ever revisit it in the future unless I hear some VERY positive word of mouth about any of the other episodes. Expect Outsourced to be downgraded to an F though.

HE Pennypacker

Outsourced - D

So close to a minus.

zekeburger1979

I usually work at night, so I record everything and watch it during the day. Having a dual tuner DVR and single tuner Tivo helps along with fast forwarding through the commercials.

DJariya

LOL...I have 2 dual tuner Directv HD DVR's and between both of them, I have around 55 shows (new this season and old) on the To Do List.

And I also work nights most of the time as well.

bigjim25

Remember, these are just the new shows. Just think of all the returning ones he is watching too.

Here's mine:


Hellcats
Nikita
Terriers
The Defenders


$#*! My Dad Says


Hawaii Five-O
Mike and Molly
Better with You

Lone Star (changed after about 30 minutes)

I still have a few comedies to check out plus some that haven't aired yet and will add them later.

meritocracy

Rubicon: A-
Boardwalk Empire: A-
Lone Star: B+
Hawaii Five-O: B
Nikita: B-
Undercovers: B-
The Event: C
Outsourced: D

Original Desmond

Undercovers - B-

I haven't given any show a season pass at this stage. Hellcats is closest

riley_dude

Good:
Raising Hope
Hawaii 5 O
Undercovers
Blue Blood


Crap:
Nikita
Running Wilde
Hell Cats


Have not seen yet but am DVRing.
Law and Order: L.A.
My Generation
Ordinary Family

Original Desmond

The Defenders - D

superdeluxe

Great, moving to season pass:
Raising Hope

Good, will stick with it for a few episodes:
Hawaii 5-0
The Event

Crap, I'm done:
Runnnig Wilde

Original Desmond

Whole Truth - D

Original Desmond

Shit my dad says - D+