Great directors that aren't Great anymore
#1
Banned
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Seeing the fav directors thread made me see that a lot of directors are "great" but in the case of some...they stopped being great a long time ago. Just wanted to see which Directors lost their "Great" status to youse guys....
For me...it's....*gasp*
Francis Ford Coppola, I love his work on The Godfather (parts I and II), The Conversation and Apocalypse Now..but...he really kinda lost his greatness for me. Like Apocalypse Now was his peak (this is debatable of course), and after that...he never really was that big again. And his films were mixed..and of course The Godfather Part III (which we can all agree sucked very bad)...Dracula, which I like but not love, never booted him further as one would think after a Dracula film would possibly do.
For me...it's....*gasp*
Francis Ford Coppola, I love his work on The Godfather (parts I and II), The Conversation and Apocalypse Now..but...he really kinda lost his greatness for me. Like Apocalypse Now was his peak (this is debatable of course), and after that...he never really was that big again. And his films were mixed..and of course The Godfather Part III (which we can all agree sucked very bad)...Dracula, which I like but not love, never booted him further as one would think after a Dracula film would possibly do.
Last edited by Solid Snake; 08-01-09 at 09:00 PM.
#2
Banned
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Bellefontaine, Ohio
Posts: 5,628
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Coppola still has got it IMO.
Robert Zemeckis is my pick and the one who used to make enjoyable films and now makes utter shit. I sat frozen in agape horror/disgust as i watched the trailer for A Christmas Carol yesterday. It perplexing how something can cost over $100 million to make and look like it cost about $3.50 to make.
Robert Zemeckis is my pick and the one who used to make enjoyable films and now makes utter shit. I sat frozen in agape horror/disgust as i watched the trailer for A Christmas Carol yesterday. It perplexing how something can cost over $100 million to make and look like it cost about $3.50 to make.
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Seeing the fav directors thread made me see that a lot of directors are "great" but in the case of some...they stopped being great a long time ago. Just wanted to see which Directors lost their "Great" status to youse guys....
For me...it's....*gasp*
Francis Ford Coppola, I love his work on The Godfather (parts I and II), The Conversation and Apocalypse Now..but...he really kinda lost his greatness for me. Like Apocalypse Now was his peak (this is debatable of course), and after that...he never really was that big again. And his films were mixed..and of course The Godfather Part III...Dracula, which I like but not love, never booted him further as one would think after a Dracula film would possibly do.
For me...it's....*gasp*
Francis Ford Coppola, I love his work on The Godfather (parts I and II), The Conversation and Apocalypse Now..but...he really kinda lost his greatness for me. Like Apocalypse Now was his peak (this is debatable of course), and after that...he never really was that big again. And his films were mixed..and of course The Godfather Part III...Dracula, which I like but not love, never booted him further as one would think after a Dracula film would possibly do.
#6
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2008
Location: Pekin, IL
Posts: 603
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Definitely Tarintino. He had so much potential after Jackie Brown, but the Kill Bill movies and Grindhouse were both disapointments. Id love to see him do more indie stuff like he originally started with. Not a fan of everything else. Is it just me, or are his lastest "homages" really starting to seem like blatant rip offs...
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
John Landis. He was never a great director to begin with, but he has made some genre classics. When the 80's ended, so did his talent.
#8
#9
Moderator
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Martin Scorsese
Wim Wenders
Wim Wenders
#10
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 2001
Location: Under a dead Ohio sky
Posts: 5,820
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
John Carpenter
Until Munich I would have put Steven Speilberg in this category
John McTiernan
John Woo
Until Munich I would have put Steven Speilberg in this category
John McTiernan
John Woo
#14
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 3,039
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Definitely Tarintino. He had so much potential after Jackie Brown, but the Kill Bill movies and Grindhouse were both disapointments. Id love to see him do more indie stuff like he originally started with. Not a fan of everything else. Is it just me, or are his lastest "homages" really starting to seem like blatant rip offs...
#15
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: USDA Zone 6a
Posts: 1,753
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Not 'great' directors, but at one time hot:
John Hughes (what's he doing nowadays?)
Jan De Bont
Renny Harlin
John Hughes (what's he doing nowadays?)
Jan De Bont
Renny Harlin
#17
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: So Cal
Posts: 7,071
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
A lot of directors listed here aren't great directors. in fact, they're just one-hit-wonders.
Brian Singer for instance. Usual Suspects was one of the most well-made films around, wonderfully shot and acted, with great pacing. I've hated every single one of his movies since, because they failed in all those categories.
I'd put Scorsese up there, if only because he really hasn't tapped the kind of talent that he should. I felt like The Aviator, Gangs of New York, and The Departed would have been monumentally better if they had better casting. And his movies just don't have that cinema verite that they used to. I felt bored watching those movies, waiting for that Scorsese touch that made them unique.
Brian Singer for instance. Usual Suspects was one of the most well-made films around, wonderfully shot and acted, with great pacing. I've hated every single one of his movies since, because they failed in all those categories.
I'd put Scorsese up there, if only because he really hasn't tapped the kind of talent that he should. I felt like The Aviator, Gangs of New York, and The Departed would have been monumentally better if they had better casting. And his movies just don't have that cinema verite that they used to. I felt bored watching those movies, waiting for that Scorsese touch that made them unique.
#18
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
John Carpenter -He had an amazing streak: Halloween, The Fog, Escape from New York, The Thing, Christine, and Starman, and ten years later was doing movies like Village of the Damned, Vampries, and Ghosts of Mars.
#20
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
The two that come to mind are Coppola and Scorsese. They've had a few masterpieces each and now fall far short of that. Coppola has had a much bigger dropoff in quality, while Scorsese seems to have fallen into the Hollywood school of filmmaking.
Tarantino had major potential with Pulp Fiction, but only seems to be concerned with rehashing old films and ideas by homaging them and having the whole film rely on that. Not only does he NOT have anything original to say, he doesn't even have an original way of presenting those films.
Tarantino had major potential with Pulp Fiction, but only seems to be concerned with rehashing old films and ideas by homaging them and having the whole film rely on that. Not only does he NOT have anything original to say, he doesn't even have an original way of presenting those films.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
John Hughes-Home Alone being a huge success was the worst thing that happened to this guy. He didn't direct, but after this all he did were kiddie movies. You would never be able to tell from his latter day stuff that this was the guy responsible for most 80s teen movies.
Peter Bogdanavich
William Friedkin
Francis Coppola- don't know if this counts, as he seems content doing little art-house movies no one cares about.
Richard Donner
I don't know if I would add Scorsese to the list. His movies are still worlds better than most of the crap we see, though I found "Bringing Out the Dead" pretentious. "Shutter Island" gives off a "Cape Fear" vibe of being a paint by the numbers thriller, though the book is quite good. However, I know that its ending is something that has been done many times before.
Peter Bogdanavich
William Friedkin
Francis Coppola- don't know if this counts, as he seems content doing little art-house movies no one cares about.
Richard Donner
I don't know if I would add Scorsese to the list. His movies are still worlds better than most of the crap we see, though I found "Bringing Out the Dead" pretentious. "Shutter Island" gives off a "Cape Fear" vibe of being a paint by the numbers thriller, though the book is quite good. However, I know that its ending is something that has been done many times before.
#23
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Harold Ramis. I doubt he's going to replicate some of his most successful films. Year One really made me wonder if he's lost it for good.
Rob Reiner. There was a time his name on a movie made it an automatic must see for me, regardless of what it was about or who was in it. But he just isn't what he used to be.
Kevin Smith. He had a handful of great, funny, and inventive comedies and it seemed like he's been trying to copy those movies ever since.
Rob Reiner. There was a time his name on a movie made it an automatic must see for me, regardless of what it was about or who was in it. But he just isn't what he used to be.
Kevin Smith. He had a handful of great, funny, and inventive comedies and it seemed like he's been trying to copy those movies ever since.
Last edited by calhoun07; 08-02-09 at 11:04 AM.
#24
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
According to his IMDB page, the last movie he directed was 1991's Curly Sue. It seems among a boat load of Beethoven movies, his most recent movie he's written was Drillbit Taylor.
But the man made some of the best comedies of the 80's that stand the test of time. Why did he stop directing so long ago?
But the man made some of the best comedies of the 80's that stand the test of time. Why did he stop directing so long ago?
#25
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Great directors that aren't Great anymore
Coppola was the first person to pop into my head.
Is it unfair to put Spielberg on this list? His last truly "great" movie was over ten years ago ("Saving Private Ryan"), but he's made enough "good" movies since then, I think, to probably keep him off this list.
Zemeckis is a great call. "Contact" was the last movie from him that I really enjoyed.
Is it unfair to put Spielberg on this list? His last truly "great" movie was over ten years ago ("Saving Private Ryan"), but he's made enough "good" movies since then, I think, to probably keep him off this list.
Zemeckis is a great call. "Contact" was the last movie from him that I really enjoyed.