A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ontario, Canada
A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
You know you all want this to go down sometime:
http://www.rebelliouspixels.com/2009...ilight-remixed
http://www.rebelliouspixels.com/2009...ilight-remixed
#2
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
Funny but a bit long, they should've made it about 30 seconds for maximum humour value I think.
#3
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ontario, Canada
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
According to the video's creator it wasn't as much about humor as it was about exposing the creepy and pathetic nature of Twilight's so-called hearthrob vampire.
I threw in pathetic, but it's still valid isn't it?
I threw in pathetic, but it's still valid isn't it?
It’s an example of transformative storytelling serving as a visual critique of Edward’s character and generally creepy behavior. Seen through Buffy’s eyes some of the more patriarchal gender roles and sexist Hollywood tropes embedded in the Twilight saga are exposed in hilarious ways.
#4
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2008
Posts: 345
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
In fairness, all the clips of Buffy concern her dealings with two vampire boyfriends, one of whom stalked and even attempted to rape her while the other just sulked all the damn time. Then again, Whedon actually addressed those things over the series, and you can see it in these clips when Buffy calls them on their shit; Twilight, on the other hand, pushes the creepy sides of such characters as the romantic ideal. Which is one of dozens of reasons why it's a P.O.S. I've watched this video like 8 times because I love it so much.
#5
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
I haven't seen Twilight, but if those clips are any indication of the quality of the acting and writing, colour me glad I didn't even waste my time purchasing a ticket to see it, let alone actually watching it.
Having seen Buffy and being a big fan of the show, you can really tell the difference between how Whedon & Co. handled the relationships and what seems to have been done in Twilight. Angel was a good guy until they had sex and he turned back into Angelus. Age difference aside (Buffy was like 15 years old or whatever and Angel was perpetually a 30 year-old), their relationship up until that point wasn't all that bad. When he turned into Angelus the relationship went sour and after that they realized it wouldn't work. You could argue that it was handled in a more realistic manner and the characters in the show were more or less mature about it; they recognized the positives and negatives of the relationship and never lied about what was going on or tried to make it better than it actually seemed.
As for Spike, his feelings for Buffy were, dare I say, more complicated than those of Angel. He was clearly unhealthily and creepily obsessed with her and at one point she does give in and is herself reckless about it. But again, they handled it correctly and showed the good and the bad of it. The worst, the rape, was very difficult to watch, and yet conveyed both sides of the event fairly. Spike was clearly in the wrong, but you can see where he is coming from. Importantly, he is very hurt by his own actions and leaves to become a better person, etc. Then he himself restrains his feelings and does whatever is in Buffy's best interest, expecting nothing in return. Again, the relationship is handled well and we get to see both sides of it, the good and the bad. It isn't glamorized in the least, and if anything this one is portrayed in a much more polarizing and negative way than her relationship with Angel (which is arguably the more romanticized of the two).
From the footage, none of what I said about Buffy seems to be present in Twilight. It looks instead (and from the trailers and what people have told of the series I haven no reason to doubt) that it glamorizes the unhealthy relationship and portrays it as how people in love really behave and feel. I'm sure this would be more evident if I watched Twilight, but with far better vampire material out there, I don't see a point to even give it the time of day.
Having seen Buffy and being a big fan of the show, you can really tell the difference between how Whedon & Co. handled the relationships and what seems to have been done in Twilight. Angel was a good guy until they had sex and he turned back into Angelus. Age difference aside (Buffy was like 15 years old or whatever and Angel was perpetually a 30 year-old), their relationship up until that point wasn't all that bad. When he turned into Angelus the relationship went sour and after that they realized it wouldn't work. You could argue that it was handled in a more realistic manner and the characters in the show were more or less mature about it; they recognized the positives and negatives of the relationship and never lied about what was going on or tried to make it better than it actually seemed.
As for Spike, his feelings for Buffy were, dare I say, more complicated than those of Angel. He was clearly unhealthily and creepily obsessed with her and at one point she does give in and is herself reckless about it. But again, they handled it correctly and showed the good and the bad of it. The worst, the rape, was very difficult to watch, and yet conveyed both sides of the event fairly. Spike was clearly in the wrong, but you can see where he is coming from. Importantly, he is very hurt by his own actions and leaves to become a better person, etc. Then he himself restrains his feelings and does whatever is in Buffy's best interest, expecting nothing in return. Again, the relationship is handled well and we get to see both sides of it, the good and the bad. It isn't glamorized in the least, and if anything this one is portrayed in a much more polarizing and negative way than her relationship with Angel (which is arguably the more romanticized of the two).
From the footage, none of what I said about Buffy seems to be present in Twilight. It looks instead (and from the trailers and what people have told of the series I haven no reason to doubt) that it glamorizes the unhealthy relationship and portrays it as how people in love really behave and feel. I'm sure this would be more evident if I watched Twilight, but with far better vampire material out there, I don't see a point to even give it the time of day.
Last edited by kstublen; 06-22-09 at 08:53 PM.
#6
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ontario, Canada
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
A big difference is that Angel didn't stalk Buffy at all, while Angelus did, and that wasn't even his sole (not soul
) focus. Angel made himself known to her by relaying her information to help her, doing the same for Giles.
You're absolutely right - Twilight seems to show "stalking girls is romantic". I too haven't seen Twilight and never will.
) focus. Angel made himself known to her by relaying her information to help her, doing the same for Giles.You're absolutely right - Twilight seems to show "stalking girls is romantic". I too haven't seen Twilight and never will.
#7
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
A big difference is that Angel didn't stalk Buffy at all, while Angelus did, and that wasn't even his sole (not soul
) focus. Angel made himself known to her by relaying her information to help her, doing the same for Giles.
You're absolutely right - Twilight seems to show "stalking girls is romantic". I too haven't seen Twilight and never will.
) focus. Angel made himself known to her by relaying her information to help her, doing the same for Giles.You're absolutely right - Twilight seems to show "stalking girls is romantic". I too haven't seen Twilight and never will.
#8
Banned
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 6 Likes
on
6 Posts
From: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
Damn..never seen Twilight, nor did I want to, but damn...does that acting suck major ass..and the dialogue is horrendous. "My own brand of heroine.." WHAT THE FUCK, man!?!?
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#13
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2003
Posts: 3,586
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Ontario, Canada
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
If only these Twilight freaks could have seen Buffy / Angel in their heyday...they might have elevated it beyond the 'cult status' and it would have been rightly deserved unlike this crap. Perhaps this newer generation (if you can call it that) is getting the vampire-themed story they deserve. Sucks for them.
#14
Banned by request
Re: A fan's dream: When Buffy Killed Edward "Twilight" Cullen
The fans of Twilight don't want to see complex relationships. That's why they read and watch Twilight.




