kvrdave

Has anyone played both? I want to pick one of these up, but I don't know that I want to spend my time actually "golfing" with the wiimote. Tell me all you can.

Mopower

Wii duh. Motion plus ftw.
I assume you are talking about 2010? Right? That comes out in two weeks?
Oh well nevermind.

redbill

I got ALOT of play out of TW2008 for the Wii. I played the ps3 demo for 2010, and the graphics are better, and I'm sure they'll be more features and stuff. But I doubt I'd play it as much as I would for the Wii. Its about the only game I whip out anymore for the Wii...

ElementZ

360

dx23

Nes

DVDChris

i'm thinking of getting the Wii version with motion plus, but I'm looking for a different experience I guess this time around.

orangecrush

On one of the podcasts I listen to (IGN Nintendo FWIW), they were talking about the new Wii version and said it was hands down the best version of the game. Apparently, it mimics a real golfing swing quite acuratly. For me, that would be a negative. I would go for Mario Golf on the GC. Much cheaper and more "arcady." But I like arcade golf much more than sim golf.

kvrdave

That's my problem. When I play Tiger Woods, I enjoy a rum and coke, some good music, and sitting around playing some golf. I don't know that I want to give up a relaxing video game to go with standing up, swinging away for each shot, swinging away for a putt, etc.

Spiderbite

Then why even consider the Wii version in the first place?

Personally, playing golf on the Wii is one of the few enjoyable motion controls that seems to fit with the system. A friend and I enjoy drinking a beer and hitting thru some holes all the time with We Love Golf!

The new motion plus for the new Tiger game is icing on the cake in my opinion. One of the few Wii games I may actually buy day of release.

kvrdave

I had wondered if it might be an either/or thing, which would be nice.

dick_grayson

I'll be getting it for the PS3. I have a wii also, but don't like playing golf on it. I think it fucks with my tempo.........and since I use the rhythm method, I gotta be on time.

Spicollidriver1

Could wait til the fall and play the full graphic version that will be playable on pc and mac but is completely browser based so system requirements is low. The only down fall is that it is subscription based and there are no details yet on price per month,

Mopower

You could get Hot Shots Golf: Out of Bounds for PS3. It should be on sale now and is cartoony but very deep and possibly the best golf game ever made.

kvrdave

I will give that a look. Thanks.

kvrdave

Just looked it up. I don't like the simple button interface. The analog stick swing is my preferred.

Mopower

Hot Shots has both.

Sonny Corinthos

The demo is out now for the 360. It will be released on the PS3 June 4th.

kvrdave

I will download that badboy. Thanks.

SoSpacey

I have bought every release of Hot Shots golf since the PS2. It may be one of the greatest games on any console for those of us who don't want to spend 10 hours/day playing FPS or role playing games.

For us casual gamers, Hot Shots is awesome.

I like Tiger as well, but Hot Shots rules. And I don't want to play either on Wii. I have Swing Away for Wii and it's too much work.

davidcar1

is tiger woods 2010 any good

nickdawgy

My step dad raves about the game. He says it's fun and looks really good. He has the PS3 version.

drmoze

TW10 on the Wii is awesI honestly don't get the couch potato mentality when you can actually have what amounts to a home golf simulator. (The response with M+ is miles beyond previous versions, and the putting WORKS.) Playing a 'real' swing-the-club golf game online with friends is a plus, and the disc golf bonus is a huge plus imo.

I've checked out many golf video games, from the TG16 and Gameboy thru modern systems. I just don't see the thrill of pressing a button or 2 at the right time when the physical swing is so much more satisfying.

dvdsteve2000

Then why not just go golfing? It's not like racing or flight simulators when you either can't afford a jet, or don't have a vehicle to go 200mph, just go to a course a swing away. When I play video games, it's relax time, so sitting down pushing buttons is just fine by me. Also, I do alot of gaming after my kids go to bed, so hopping around the house isn't always an option.

RichC2

Tiger Woods Golf 2010 (Wii) - $59.99

1 round of golf at TPC Sawgrass (non-member) in 100+ degree weather - $495/pp (though I do believe that includes a night at the hotel, which is required for non-members)

Plus you have to dedicate 4.5 hours to it.

I wonder. The accuracy is pretty cool in the game and it isn't noisy/you aren't exactly hoping around the house. Though you will swear more. So I guess that counts.

People generally play golf because it's relaxing to them (I call these people "crazy") by that same thought process, Wii golf should be just as relaxing (read: not at all.) -- buy whichever one you'll enjoy more, simple as that. I personally never understood the appeal of Golf games on a game controller (outside of a few mini-golf games).

darkside

I'm not sure where you live, but it isn't that easy for some of us to just head to the golf course several times a week for the golf fix. I agree real golfing should be part of it, but Tiger Woods on Wii is a great supplement. I finally got to play the Wii version and it was down right amazing. The 360 version is still good, but seems mostly a carbon copy of 09, 08 and so on. The Wii version is definitely the one to get and disc golf is also a blast to play in the Wii version. This is the second straight game I have played (with Ghostbusters being the first) that was more fun to play on the Wii.