My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
Long story short.
My girlfriend, the love of my life, is staying with me for a week while she is on spring break. She brought her cat (that happens to be cute 90% of the time). In the 10% of the time he is not cute, he somehow manages to push over the TV causing a few irreparable cracks in the screen.
I checked every way I could possibly save my year old $1000 investment. I have the Best Buy warranty which doesn't cover accidents. The Westinghouse warranty doesn't either and cannot be fixed since it is the screen which is 80% of the cost. I even checked with my homeowners insurance and as expected, it won't cover it.
Is this a lost cause?
Furthermore, if I were to put a broken year old 42" on Ebay, would anybody buy it for parts or would they just laugh and throw trash at me when they drive by on the interstate?
I figure its a lost cause but I still have 900 bucks to pay off on it so i figure its worth asking.
My girlfriend, the love of my life, is staying with me for a week while she is on spring break. She brought her cat (that happens to be cute 90% of the time). In the 10% of the time he is not cute, he somehow manages to push over the TV causing a few irreparable cracks in the screen.
I checked every way I could possibly save my year old $1000 investment. I have the Best Buy warranty which doesn't cover accidents. The Westinghouse warranty doesn't either and cannot be fixed since it is the screen which is 80% of the cost. I even checked with my homeowners insurance and as expected, it won't cover it.
Is this a lost cause?
Furthermore, if I were to put a broken year old 42" on Ebay, would anybody buy it for parts or would they just laugh and throw trash at me when they drive by on the interstate?
I figure its a lost cause but I still have 900 bucks to pay off on it so i figure its worth asking.
#2
DVD Talk Legend
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
You bought a $1,000 TV a year ago and you still owe $900? Methinks you have bigger problems than just the broken TV.
That said, there is no magical fairy dust that is going to come to your rescue, unless your girlfriend offers to help pay for a replacement since it was her cat that did the damage.
That said, there is no magical fairy dust that is going to come to your rescue, unless your girlfriend offers to help pay for a replacement since it was her cat that did the damage.
#3
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Honolulu, Hawaii
Posts: 1,831
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
Looks like you are out of luck unless somehow the credit card you used covers things like that.
I'm thinking that repair costs for the TV would be about the same as buying another one.
I'm thinking that repair costs for the TV would be about the same as buying another one.
#4
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
You bought a $1,000 TV a year ago and you still owe $900? Methinks you have bigger problems than just the broken TV.
That said, there is no magical fairy dust that is going to come to your rescue, unless your girlfriend offers to help pay for a replacement since it was her cat that did the damage.
That said, there is no magical fairy dust that is going to come to your rescue, unless your girlfriend offers to help pay for a replacement since it was her cat that did the damage.
3 years with 0% interest. 10 dollar payments. Product Service Plan for an extra 100 some bucks. Nothing the matter with that.
And yes, she has practically insisted on paying for a new TV which seems unnecessary. It was an accident so I'm not mad at her and don't want her to go 1000 bucks in the hole.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
#6
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
How on earth did a cat knock over a 42" set? Obviously not a wall mount. But my 46" LCD requires some effort to move it while on its pedestal...just how big is this cat?
#7
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
But its only $10 a month
Talk to Bestbuy, you never know, may get a manager on a good day.
Talk to Bestbuy, you never know, may get a manager on a good day.
Now if I talk to a manager, should I bring the TV in with me or what? I'm not good at this sort of thing. I either push to hard or not enough. Any advice would be appreciated.
Oh, and the one good thing about this is now I can toment her cat without her getting mad at me. Mind you, I'm not mean, but I love to do things like play with his paws which gets him pissed...he is a Maine Coon so he is moody anyway and forgives me within a minute.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
...he is a Maine Coon
#9
DVD Talk Hero
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
Bigger problems?
3 years with 0% interest. 10 dollar payments. Product Service Plan for an extra 100 some bucks. Nothing the matter with that.
And yes, she has practically insisted on paying for a new TV which seems unnecessary. It was an accident so I'm not mad at her and don't want her to go 1000 bucks in the hole.
3 years with 0% interest. 10 dollar payments. Product Service Plan for an extra 100 some bucks. Nothing the matter with that.
And yes, she has practically insisted on paying for a new TV which seems unnecessary. It was an accident so I'm not mad at her and don't want her to go 1000 bucks in the hole.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
But actually the top concern I always have with pets around the house is them chewing wires in general. Something to keep in mind for the next tv you get.
#11
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
I can easily picture an animal pushing over my 50" Plasma. It would take some effort, but a decent brush against it would definitely get it rocking a bit.
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 1,742
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
I'd expect it's not so much the pushing it off as it's likely the cat tried to jump on top and either knocked it over at that point or knocked it over when it jumped off the tv. I used to have that problem with tower speakers. Cats would jump up just fine, but it was their kicking off motion when jumping off the speaker that would send it to the floor.
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
I don't know how many of you are familiar with Maine coon cats, but they're the size of small dogs.
#14
Banned
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
Sorry about your tv...doesn't sound like you'll be able to recoup your investment, unless you end up marrying your girlfriend. Then it can always be a source of amusement at family gatherings (or a bone of contention).
Even if she was not the love of your life, I wouldn't recommend suggesting that she turn tricks to pay for the set. You might discount the cost from the engagement ring, though.
However, you might find creative ways to make Fuzzy "disappear". But then you would have Pet Semetary-type nightmares.
Thanks for posting, though. We have seven cats, including some who love to climb. Your post has got me seriously thinking how to anchor our 50" Plasma.
>Edit: Just had a thought. If you have homeowner's insurance & a friend who is a good shot with a rifle, place the set by the window facing the road & open the window. Then have him shoot out the back of the set. If you get the cat to pose behind the set, you might get a two-fer. Justice will be served.
Even if she was not the love of your life, I wouldn't recommend suggesting that she turn tricks to pay for the set. You might discount the cost from the engagement ring, though.
However, you might find creative ways to make Fuzzy "disappear". But then you would have Pet Semetary-type nightmares.
Thanks for posting, though. We have seven cats, including some who love to climb. Your post has got me seriously thinking how to anchor our 50" Plasma.
>Edit: Just had a thought. If you have homeowner's insurance & a friend who is a good shot with a rifle, place the set by the window facing the road & open the window. Then have him shoot out the back of the set. If you get the cat to pose behind the set, you might get a two-fer. Justice will be served.
Last edited by creekdipper; 03-18-09 at 07:35 AM.
#15
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
The good news (?) is that you can get the 2009 entry 42" Panasonic plasma for $899 or less.
That must have been a big cat. I don't know how a cat could even knock over my 23" lcd - the base on this must weigh 20lbs easy.
That must have been a big cat. I don't know how a cat could even knock over my 23" lcd - the base on this must weigh 20lbs easy.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
I had a situation a few years ago when I bought a DVD player on the advice of one of their reps, but the thing did a really crappy job of playing DVD-r's. They looked terrible. Technically they played, but the quality was so poor I couldn't stand watching anything. I calmly explained my situation to a manager and he gave me the "employee discount".
SInce it's obvious you're buying a new TV, do your research like any other purchase then go in to BB last with the model you're interested in and ask for a manager's best price.
As a guy who's been married 23 years I'll give you my 2¢ over the girlfriend situation. If she has the money, let her buy the freakin TV. Her cat broke the TV, she owes it to you. IF you end up married, it's both your money anyway. If you end up apart, get your TV as a consolation prize. Don't think that by being Mr. Understanding it will have any bearing on the future of the relationship. If anyone sees you as unreasonable for expecting the TV to be replaced they're doucebags.
#17
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
As a guy who's been married 23 years I'll give you my 2¢ over the girlfriend situation. If she has the money, let her buy the freakin TV. Her cat broke the TV, she owes it to you. IF you end up married, it's both your money anyway. If you end up apart, get your TV as a consolation prize. Don't think that by being Mr. Understanding it will have any bearing on the future of the relationship. If anyone sees you as unreasonable for expecting the TV to be replaced they're doucebags.
#21
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2008
Posts: 80
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: My 42" LCD just turned into a giant paper weight
I appreciate all the advice. Right now my girlfriend is finishing up grad school. She already is practically paying for a trip to Atlanta for the two of us. We were originally going to split the price but she is telling me not to pay her back...this was before the TV thing anyway. She is really good to me and understands how tight money is for me. Money isn't as big of a problem for her since she doesn't have nearly as many bills and will be making at least twice as much as my teacher salary (granted she is able to get a job in this lovely world we are facing). I told her if she gets a good job I will consider letting her buy me a TV along with a car and other goodies. Hell, I already have the house and furniture and crap like that so I figure then it is not that extreme to let her make up her share by getting me that new TV at that point.
But never underestimate the destructive nature of cats.
But never underestimate the destructive nature of cats.
#24
DVD Talk Hall of Fame