Traxan

This is my favorite film, and I've been furious at the delays. So I can't wait to hear the good word.

Adam Tyner

Shortly after we receive a copy to review, hopefully. Fox has been pretty great at providing DVD Talk with review copies, so it shouldn't be much longer, hopefully.

Traxan

When did Fox get so slow? They used to send them out several weeks in advance, some times too far in advance.

Adam Tyner

DVD Talk just got in its copy earlier today. It'll take some time to get it mailed off to a reviewer from the home office, watched, and reviewed, but hopefully that'll all be tackled before next weekend.

Astrofan

In the original SD review the Video got five stars. In the Blu ray it got three. Is this because the video is not up to Blu ray quality or is it that the Blu ray brings out defects in the original?

Adam Tyner

My impression is that it's a combination of a deliberate photographic style and a fairly old master.

Josh Z

The DVD is good by DVD standards. The Blu-ray looks pretty much identical to the DVD. There's very little visual upgrade between the two.

Astrofan

Thank you for your responses. Fry's had it on sale for $14 and I bought it but I wasn't going to open it until after I read some comments. Since $14 is even cheaper than the SD DVD, at least for the SE, I'll go ahead and keep it.

Thanks for the info.

johnmcboston

Of course now there are two blu-ray M&C's on Amazon....

Randy Miller III

They're essentially the same releases except for the packaging. For some reason, the (newer) digibook release uses the old 2-Disc DVD artwork but includes none of those bonus features. A blown opportunity to make a definitive edition, but it's not the first time.

johnmcboston

Thanks. Translates to "buy whichever is cheapest". :-)