X-Men DVD's Question
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 5,420
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
X-Men DVD's Question
I'm looking to get some or all of the X-Men dvd's from either DP or DDD with the 20% sale.
There are a lot of dvd's out there (Triology, Steelbook, regular versions...)
Which dvd's do you recommend ?
I haven't seen any of them (except for parts of X1 and X2) on cable. I heard the 3rd one wasn't too good.
There are a lot of dvd's out there (Triology, Steelbook, regular versions...)
Which dvd's do you recommend ?
I haven't seen any of them (except for parts of X1 and X2) on cable. I heard the 3rd one wasn't too good.
#2
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: May 2007
Posts: 2,656
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Phantom Zone
My recommendation:
- Get the X-Men 1.5 steelbook dvd (a Best Buy exclusive though). This is the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. If you really don't want to buy from Best Buy, just go with the regular version of 1.5 in the digipak packaging (exactly the same except for the packaging).
- Get the X2 steelbook dvd (available everywhere). This is also the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. The regular 2-disc edition of X2 is exactly the same, just not packaged in steelbook. Be careful though, as there were 1-disc editions of X2 subsequently released, and it may not be easy to differentiate from the 2-disc release.
- Get any version of the X3 dvd. AFAIK the "Collector's Edition" is just the basic 1-disc with the addition of a comic, *not* a second disc. If you can manage to track it down, try to find the Future Shop exclusive steelbook edition of the 1-disc. Probably have to resort to Ebay at this point though.
** Avoid the trilogy 3-pack. AFAIK it includes the 1-disc edition of all 3 movies, which is the only version available for X3, but for the first two you really want the 2-disc editions. **
- Get the X-Men 1.5 steelbook dvd (a Best Buy exclusive though). This is the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. If you really don't want to buy from Best Buy, just go with the regular version of 1.5 in the digipak packaging (exactly the same except for the packaging).
- Get the X2 steelbook dvd (available everywhere). This is also the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. The regular 2-disc edition of X2 is exactly the same, just not packaged in steelbook. Be careful though, as there were 1-disc editions of X2 subsequently released, and it may not be easy to differentiate from the 2-disc release.
- Get any version of the X3 dvd. AFAIK the "Collector's Edition" is just the basic 1-disc with the addition of a comic, *not* a second disc. If you can manage to track it down, try to find the Future Shop exclusive steelbook edition of the 1-disc. Probably have to resort to Ebay at this point though.
** Avoid the trilogy 3-pack. AFAIK it includes the 1-disc edition of all 3 movies, which is the only version available for X3, but for the first two you really want the 2-disc editions. **
Last edited by Yavin; 06-15-07 at 09:27 AM.
#4
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jan 2001
Posts: 5,069
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Bay Area, CA
I bought the X trilogy on sale for $17.99 online a few months ago thinking i wouldnt mind the 1 disc editions. Just sold it hoping for a better set in the future when Wolvie comes out to theatres. Id go for the steelbooks if you want the best out there now.
#5
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Mar 2000
Posts: 5,420
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Yavin
My recommendation:
- Get the X-Men 1.5 steelbook dvd (a Best Buy exclusive though). This is the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. If you really don't want to buy from Best Buy, just go with the regular version of 1.5 in the digipak packaging (exactly the same except for the packaging).
- Get the X2 steelbook dvd (available everywhere). This is also the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. The regular 2-disc edition of X2 is exactly the same, just not packaged in steelbook. Be careful though, as there were 1-disc editions of X2 subsequently released, and it may not be easy to differentiate from the 2-disc release.
- Get any version of the X3 dvd. AFAIK the "Collector's Edition" is just the basic 1-disc with the addition of a comic, *not* a second disc. If you can manage to track it down, try to find the Future Shop exclusive steelbook edition of the 1-disc. Probably have to resort to Ebay at this point though.
** Avoid the trilogy 3-pack. AFAIK it includes the 1-disc edition of all 3 movies, which is the only version available for X3, but for the first two you really want the 2-disc editions. **
- Get the X-Men 1.5 steelbook dvd (a Best Buy exclusive though). This is the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. If you really don't want to buy from Best Buy, just go with the regular version of 1.5 in the digipak packaging (exactly the same except for the packaging).
- Get the X2 steelbook dvd (available everywhere). This is also the best version of the film in a 2-disc set and a nice steelbook case. The regular 2-disc edition of X2 is exactly the same, just not packaged in steelbook. Be careful though, as there were 1-disc editions of X2 subsequently released, and it may not be easy to differentiate from the 2-disc release.
- Get any version of the X3 dvd. AFAIK the "Collector's Edition" is just the basic 1-disc with the addition of a comic, *not* a second disc. If you can manage to track it down, try to find the Future Shop exclusive steelbook edition of the 1-disc. Probably have to resort to Ebay at this point though.
** Avoid the trilogy 3-pack. AFAIK it includes the 1-disc edition of all 3 movies, which is the only version available for X3, but for the first two you really want the 2-disc editions. **
#6
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,132
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boston, MA
Originally Posted by orion1998_1
next week best buy will have steelbook 1.5 on sale
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
And for what it's worth, steelbooks are hot items, very much in demand. Definitely have the best re-sale value, especially the exclusive ones. I do not care myself about the X-Men 1.5 steelbook, but I know it's going to be a collectible item since it's an exclusive and the print-run is probably not that high, so I'll always be able to unload it for something on my want list if I don't want it anymore.
#13
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,132
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Boston, MA
Originally Posted by uncle-frank
honestly you should wait on X-3, ive waited almost a year now. i kno that as soon as i buy it a 2 disc will be announced
#14
Originally Posted by orion1998_1
next week best buy will have steelbook 1.5 on sale
16.99 + tax
Last edited by laserdogg; 06-15-07 at 09:42 PM.
#17
New Member
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is there anybody here with the X-Men 3 steelbook case willing to sell it? I've been searching Craigslist and eBay and Yielded no results. I'm only looking to purchase the case, and will provide my standard WS case in exchange along with paymnt, but I will purchase it with the disc if necessary.
#18
You'd do better by posting your request in our DVD Exchange Forum.
#21
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by Macho King
Hey brothers, Macho King's been looking for a steelbook edition of X2 so where's the best place to find it brothers?
Oooooh Yeeeaaaaah!!!!! DIG IT!!!!
Oooooh Yeeeaaaaah!!!!! DIG IT!!!!
Oh no... you didn't!!!!
#22
Member
Joined: Feb 2003
Posts: 200
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: California
Originally Posted by Defiant1
I have the R3 version of X3 and it's a 2-disc SE, which I think will eventually be released for R1.
#24
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 376
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Florida
i just got back from my local Bestbuy and they had X-men 1.5 steelbook marked wrong for $14.99 and x-men 2 steelbook for $14.99 and they had to give it to me for that price... unless its a sale they are having but was last one they had in the 1.5, she was trying to say that they cant sell it to me for that price because its a limited edition case.. i said bull crap.....
thanks to this site about it only being at bestbuy...
thanks to this site about it only being at bestbuy...
#25
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by Struz
I'm looking to get some or all of the X-Men dvd's from either DP or DDD with the 20% sale.
There are a lot of dvd's out there (Triology, Steelbook, regular versions...)
Which dvd's do you recommend ?
I haven't seen any of them (except for parts of X1 and X2) on cable. I heard the 3rd one wasn't too good.
There are a lot of dvd's out there (Triology, Steelbook, regular versions...)
Which dvd's do you recommend ?
I haven't seen any of them (except for parts of X1 and X2) on cable. I heard the 3rd one wasn't too good.
There is this member who gave the definitive information about the X3 dvd release:
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showthread....&page=14&pp=25



