I want to make sure I am not missing out on some gem that really stands out as not only the best Criterion, but overall best release for a DVD. We know Criterion has a remarkable track record for putting out the best of the best, though on lesser known films, but i don't want to miss out.

I know we've had Criterion threads to death, but I don't think we've had an overall best (in your opinion) thread.

So, let me know what you think...

I have a feeling and really looking forward to "The Third Man" release coming in May. I have a feeling that will blow me away because i am simply enamorate of the movie upon first and only viewing and the extras slated seem so immersive.

So far for me in terms of great movie and extras I will go with "The Killer".

Armageddon

Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, The Rock, and Dazed and Confused in terms of extra features. RoboCop is my favorite with regards to impact (the unrated cut!).

Short Cuts and Straw Dogs are also great presentations. Loads of extras, great movies.

Peeping Tom. 1st and still the best some years ago.

Do The Right Thing

No one ever seems to list in these threads, but i love the extras and the film is amazing.

The Seventh Seal
D. Ingmar Bergman
Spin #11

Best Box Set (and Best Overall): The BRD Trilogy

Best Single Disc Release: Notorious

Best Two Disc Release: Videodrome

Best Three Disc Release (Single Film): Seven Samurai

Brazil 3 Disc Box Set

I've only seen a handful of Criterions, but my pick is:

Seven Samurai Re-release

My favorite movie is Charade so that wins for me. It also has one of the best commentary tracks I have listened to.

http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showthread.php?t=495093&page=1