LorenzoL

"Papa's Cabin"

Originally Aired: February 27, 2007

Rypro 525

I hope our CW network doesn't mess up the feed again. For the past 2 weeks, almost every thirty seconds, the scene would freeze and block up, and then fix itself, maybe missing a few words here and there. It became so annoying that I had to find other means to view the episodes.

Breakfast with Girls

If you're talking about the OTA HD feed, it sounds like you just don't have a strong enough signal.

joefrog91

Ha! I knew it. The killer was . Loved how VM figured it out at the end.

Patman

It was a little obvious, and too obvious by the way the clues were being fed to VM. I was hoping for something more out of left field.

"Taps"?

JayDerek

same here. the rapist conclusion had me fooled...this one felt way too easy

Adam Tyner

I was certain it was Tim the TA for a while (again, more of a "who's the least likely suspect" than any clues pointing his way), but the episode did a great job convincing me I was wrong till the scene with the big reveal, so I won't hold that against 'em.

Really enjoyed the episode. Kinda nice that it broke from tradition and didn't have Veronica in mortal peril.

dhmac

Even though figuring this mystery out was easier than usual (it was the person I've suspected all along), it was nice to see Veronica solve it without being first put in peril (a cliche used in every other "arc" mystery so far).

Birrman54

I enjoyed the episode and felt the conclusion was pretty satisfying. I also picked Tim but I hadn't established a solid motive. Revenge for the bad recomendation and positioning himself as the new professor was a pretty good one.

Are we due for another break?

aktick

Does this mean Veronica will teach the class now?

KingFunk

I may have misheard what was said, but during the promo after the show I believe they mentioned 6 new episodes would begin airing on May 1. Wouldn't that bring the total to 21 and not the previously stated 20? Are we getting an extra episode?

MrX

"I'm just trying to figure out which Gilmore Girl you are"

Pretty good episode.

Count Dooku

Six more new eps would be 21 total, but I wouldn't trust the CW promo dept to know what the frak they're talking about.

dhmac

I thought the motive provided was a rather weak one. (The Dean was going to end the Professor's career as said on the bug tapes, so the TA's problem with the Professor was solved already - yet he then kills the Dean and sets it up to look like a suicide?)

But I've suspected the TA ever since we were told the murder of the Dean was done like Veronica's "perfect murder" story, which only 3 people should've been able to read: Veronica (innocent), the Professor (too obvious), and the TA (just right).

starseed1981

Saw that one coming a mile away. The rapist arc really had me fooled ; but the moment the recording on the DVD was played it confirmed my suspicions.

Tracer Bullet

So, everyone that thought the identity of the murderer was obvious: please give us all a link to your posts where you identified the TA as the culprit.

Adam Tyner

Here's one. I posted something a good bit earlier on another Veronica Mars thread on another forum, but I'd have to track down which one it is.

Like I said earlier, though, it wasn't that all signs were pointing to Tim. According to the usual mystery formula -- where the killer has to be a previously established character who no one has suspected or hasn't suspected in a while -- there were only two characters it could be: Tim and the dean's goth-drummer kid. Tim had more of a presence on the show and was therefore the most likely of the two.

wmansir

My Last week thoughts on Tim were that he was perfect for the crime except we hadn't even been given a whiff of motive. In this episode they didn't provide it until Mindy and the prof were acting guilty as hell, which brings me to my one question: Why did Mindy run?

EDIT: I think a good clue would have been to drop a hint in "There's got to be a morning after pill" that Tim was having a hard time finding a teaching job to support his expecting girlfriend.

Adam Tyner

Apparently this arc was trimmed down when the order went from 22 episodes to 20, and maybe that sort of thing was what got yanked.

wmansir

Also, why did Tim expose himself by faking Landry's alibi? If he didn't want to pin it on the Prof, then he wouldn't have worn Landry's cloths while doing the deed and/or planted them for the cops to find. EDIT: I guess Tim's motive was to fake the alibi and then expose it as a fake, thereby making Landry look even more guilty, but it still seems risky and unnecessary.

I think Veronica mentioned her "how to get away with murder" paper was publicly posted.

Tracer Bullet

I wasn't actually calling anyone out. I just get sick of all the "I called it as X months ago! It was so obvious!" posts after every VM arc wrap-up episode. One or two people legitimately call out the right culprit, and it's like a bunch of other people feel left out.

rfduncan

Mine is here from last week's "Mars, Bars". I think I got the motive wrong (of course who could have known that until last night?), but my suspicion of Tim was correct.

Poor Wallace. That was indeed the quote of the night for me.

So now I get a break from VM while Top Model runs which is good for me. I can watch House on HD once AI stops running 5 hours a week.

This took 6 episodes to do. So to set up another there needs to be one semi-standalone episode. It would be nice to have another 6-7 episode mini mystery. I enjoy the whole season arcs, but if a cautious CW wanted to break the whole season into 3 separate arcs and keep it on the air, I'm happy!

joefrog91

I was actually thinking the same thing. But here's my post from last week. I really did call it.

Adam Tyner

The last batch of episodes are standalones. There's no mystery arc.

rfduncan

But I understand that

Hmm. That has never happened before. I just can't see the staff writers not having any arcs across the remainder of the season!