Award show overkill (merged)
#1
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Award show overkill
(note: if this has been done before i am sorry, i will close this if it has been done to death.)
Peoples choice awards
Golden Globe awards
Academy awards
Screen Actors Guild awards
CMA awards
Grammy awards
Juno awards (Canadian)
& probally more that i don't know about.
i just want to know if people hate these award shows with a passion or like them or think its time to stop talking about how good they are and make more movies.
personally i think these award shows are out of hand. the actors paycheck should be award enough in my opinion.
i have respect for surtain actors and movies but i don't want these critics telling me what the best movie of the year is cause most of the time its not the case in my mind.
in the movie department they seem to pick a movie like "Dreamgirls" & call it the best movie of the year before its even out.
in the tv department they always pick the worst show out of the bunch like this year at the golden globe awards calling "Greys Anatomy" the best tv drama.
in my opinion its overrated GARBAGE.
what do you think?
Peoples choice awards
Golden Globe awards
Academy awards
Screen Actors Guild awards
CMA awards
Grammy awards
Juno awards (Canadian)
& probally more that i don't know about.
i just want to know if people hate these award shows with a passion or like them or think its time to stop talking about how good they are and make more movies.
personally i think these award shows are out of hand. the actors paycheck should be award enough in my opinion.
i have respect for surtain actors and movies but i don't want these critics telling me what the best movie of the year is cause most of the time its not the case in my mind.
in the movie department they seem to pick a movie like "Dreamgirls" & call it the best movie of the year before its even out.
in the tv department they always pick the worst show out of the bunch like this year at the golden globe awards calling "Greys Anatomy" the best tv drama.
in my opinion its overrated GARBAGE.
what do you think?
#5
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Brooklyn, New Yawk
Posts: 1,640
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I watch 'em, and most of the time I don't agree with their choice. However, they don't tell me what the best picture is. If I don't agree, I don't agree. Don't take what they say as fact and maybe you won't hate them so much.
I love watching them. I like to see what everyone is wearing, and what everyone looks like, and I still like to see who wins.
I love watching them. I like to see what everyone is wearing, and what everyone looks like, and I still like to see who wins.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
I want to watch, but they are always so painful to me. The jokes are really unfunny, and the speeches are so boring that I can't stand to watch, but I feel like if I don't I'm going to miss something.
#12
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Those award giving bodies have never stated that YOU should consider what they call the best "the best". It's entirely subjective.
Although, I'd bet that if they crowned what you thought was the best as "the best" you wouldn't be complaining in several different threads now would you?
Although, I'd bet that if they crowned what you thought was the best as "the best" you wouldn't be complaining in several different threads now would you?
#13
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by nateman241
(note: in the movie department they seem to pick a movie like "Dreamgirls" & call it the best movie of the year before its even out.
in the tv department they always pick the worst show out of the bunch like this year at the golden globe awards calling "Greys Anatomy" the best tv drama.
in my opinion its overrated GARBAGE.
what do you think?
in the tv department they always pick the worst show out of the bunch like this year at the golden globe awards calling "Greys Anatomy" the best tv drama.
in my opinion its overrated GARBAGE.
what do you think?
Dreamgirls game out December 15th. You just didn't see it.
but if your not a member of the hollywood foreign press, it doesn't matter what your opinion is. thats the peoples choice award.
are these awards of any merit? no more or less than the employee of the month award you might recieve...its just people wanting to say they appreciate something you did. doesn't make you a better person, but you can be greatful someone thought of you.
#14
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by conscience
Those award giving bodies have never stated that YOU should consider what they call the best "the best". It's entirely subjective.
Although, I'd bet that if they crowned what you thought was the best as "the best" you wouldn't be complaining in several different threads now would you?
Although, I'd bet that if they crowned what you thought was the best as "the best" you wouldn't be complaining in several different threads now would you?
#15
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by Cameron
Dreamgirls game out December 15th. You just didn't see it.
but if your not a member of the hollywood foreign press, it doesn't matter what your opinion is. thats the peoples choice award.
are these awards of any merit? no more or less than the employee of the month award you might recieve...its just people wanting to say they appreciate something you did. doesn't make you a better person, but you can be greatful someone thought of you.
but if your not a member of the hollywood foreign press, it doesn't matter what your opinion is. thats the peoples choice award.
are these awards of any merit? no more or less than the employee of the month award you might recieve...its just people wanting to say they appreciate something you did. doesn't make you a better person, but you can be greatful someone thought of you.
#16
DVD Talk Hero
Join Date: Jun 2000
Location: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Posts: 34,101
Received 729 Likes
on
532 Posts
Originally Posted by nateman241
i thought dreamgirls opened christmas day.
If you don't like awards shows, why do you watch? I'm in the industry and I don't watch them, therefore they don't bother me. You're not being forced to watch, you do have the freedom of choice.
#17
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by nateman241
personally i think these award shows are out of hand. the actors paycheck should be award enough in my opinion.
Well any organization I've been a part of has given out awards. Whether its a company, a profession, a school, sports league, or a charity. Simply because actors do it too seems normal to me, and they're televised because people want to watch them.
That being said, no one will agree with all the choices.
I'd also add, that the only "official" movie awards are the Oscars (at least domestically). The rest are just private organizations choosing to give out their own awards. In which case if you think there are too many award shows, you should complain to MTV and Blockbuster, not about the Actors themselves.
Last edited by Jericho; 01-17-07 at 10:40 AM.
#18
DVD Talk Legend
What I watch:
MOVIES
Academy Awards
TV
Emmy Awards
MUSIC
Grammy Awards
American Music Awards
MIX
Golden Globes
I used to LOVE the MTV Video Awards, but I gave up on it. Genre awards (soul train, CMAs) do nothing for me. SAG awards & Director's Guild just aren't on my radar. I never gort into People's Choice as it seems the winners know their award ahead of time (and that's no fun).
MOVIES
Academy Awards
TV
Emmy Awards
MUSIC
Grammy Awards
American Music Awards
MIX
Golden Globes
I used to LOVE the MTV Video Awards, but I gave up on it. Genre awards (soul train, CMAs) do nothing for me. SAG awards & Director's Guild just aren't on my radar. I never gort into People's Choice as it seems the winners know their award ahead of time (and that's no fun).
#20
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Location: Export, PA
Posts: 5,589
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As a kid I always dreamed of going to the Oscars. These days it's such a joke and popularity contest most of the time that I don't even watch the show on TV. I'd rather watch the MTV Movie Awards because they treat it like a joke and they don't make it out to be something real or serious.
#21
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I like watching the Oscars. I often disagree with them, but I like watching anyway.
I haven't seen any other awards show for probably 30 years, and I don't really follow who wins.
I haven't seen any other awards show for probably 30 years, and I don't really follow who wins.
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2005
Posts: 377
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I watch most film award shows but like almost everyone else I pay special attention to the Oscars. Often because I hope someone who I enjoyed is recognized for their work. This year I'm especially pulling for Helen Mirren in the Queen, even though it appears she has her award all but won already. Also cinematography in Children of Men is deserving of multiple awards and I was disappointed with the HFPA not recognizing the film at all. That said you don't have to agree. Was Crash the best film of last night, not in my mind.
The other benefit of the Oscars is limited run films like The Queen and Last King of Scotland get much wider releases for their Oscar push.
The other benefit of the Oscars is limited run films like The Queen and Last King of Scotland get much wider releases for their Oscar push.
#23
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: North America
Posts: 1,296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
YAWN -- SAG, Golden Globes, Oscars... Why...
Why am I so disinterested in the "Awards Season" this year? The SAG awards came and went. Same is true with regard to the Golden Globes. Now, whenever I hear "Oscar" I quite literally shrug.
Is any other movie lover here as "over it" as I am? -- due to the revelation last year that the voting is usually rigged and most of the judges not only let their personal prejudices interfere, some actually don't even bother to view all the nominated movies!!!
I had hoped my feelings would have changed by now, but alas Oscar is dead for me. Unfortunately he seems to have taken the other awards with him!
Is any other movie lover here as "over it" as I am? -- due to the revelation last year that the voting is usually rigged and most of the judges not only let their personal prejudices interfere, some actually don't even bother to view all the nominated movies!!!
I had hoped my feelings would have changed by now, but alas Oscar is dead for me. Unfortunately he seems to have taken the other awards with him!
#24
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
#25
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: North America
Posts: 1,296
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Aaron of AIM
The SAG awards don't air until next Sunday.