Which reality shows are actual reality shows and not game shows?
#1
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Which reality shows are actual reality shows and not game shows?
Most reality shows have nothing to do with reality. Survivor is a game show. Next Top Model, Next Food Network Star, etc. are all game shows. There is really little difference between them and Deal Or No Deal.
But shows that are actually reality shows are like Deadliest Catch. What are others?
But shows that are actually reality shows are like Deadliest Catch. What are others?
#2
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: IL
Posts: 3,509
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Though the subject matter may not necessarily be based in "reality," Ghosthunters is a great example.
And what about shows like The Osbornes, The Girls Next Door, etc?
And what about shows like The Osbornes, The Girls Next Door, etc?
#4
DVD Talk Legend
I think Survivor is a reality show. It shows them "living life" (at camp inbetween challenges) as if the cameras aren't there (except for interviews). That's cinema verite.
Deal or No Deal and American Idol don't have the "living life as if cameras aren't there" component. They're just game shows/talent shows.
I think that's the difference.
Deal or No Deal and American Idol don't have the "living life as if cameras aren't there" component. They're just game shows/talent shows.
I think that's the difference.
#5
DVD Talk Legend
The term 'reality show' covers a pretty large canvas. I think of game shows as shows set in a studio like Deal or No Deal, Millionaire, Jeopardy, etc. Stuff like Survivor, Amazing Race, Top Model I would consider competitive reality shows. Things like Deadliest Catch are more like documentaries... an interesting term I heard for this type of show was reality drama or unscripted drama. Which I suppose would make something like The Osbournes a "reality comedy"?
#7
DVD Talk God
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by GuessWho
I think Survivor is a reality show. It shows them "living life" (at camp inbetween challenges) as if the cameras aren't there (except for interviews). That's cinema verite.
It probably does depend a lot on what people think "reality" means.
#9
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by kvrdave
But they are put in a situation for the show. That isn't reality. In the end, they are competing to win money. That's a game show to me.
It probably does depend a lot on what people think "reality" means.
It probably does depend a lot on what people think "reality" means.
And let's face it, no matter the concept, if you are following people around constantly with a camera, you are at least slightly altering the reality of their lives. I would say that one of the only shows that doesn't do that is Big Brother because they have cameras all over the house but no cameramen inside the house filming (at least that I know of). I think this would achieve the closest thing to reality, although admittedly a slightly manufactured reality, because it's a situation where people can more easily forget about the cameras.
Last edited by clckworang; 05-22-06 at 09:28 PM.
#10
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Seattle
Posts: 2,712
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Here's something simple: When people are playing for a cash prize, it's a Game Show.
Survivor, Amazing Race, Big Brother, Real World/Road Rules Challenge... Game Shows.
American Idol, America's Next Top Model... Talent Shows.
Survivor, Amazing Race, Big Brother, Real World/Road Rules Challenge... Game Shows.
American Idol, America's Next Top Model... Talent Shows.
#13
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,259
Received 1,793 Likes
on
1,121 Posts
Originally Posted by Breakfast with Girls
Basically anything on VH1. Hogan Knows Best, The Surreal Life, My Fair Brady
I watch them all.
I watch them all.
Same here. They all rock! Did you see the previews for My Fair Brady? Wow....
#14
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,259
Received 1,793 Likes
on
1,121 Posts
PBS has Texas Ranch House and the rest of the "house" series. You actually learn historical facts during these shows and you get to see modern folks live in situations from the past.
Texas Ranch House
1900 House
1940's House
I think there's more but I can't remember the names.
Texas Ranch House
1900 House
1940's House
I think there's more but I can't remember the names.
#17
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Exit 10, NJ
Posts: 2,751
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What is actually real about any reality show? These shows are as real as Curb Your Enthusiasm is real. Now, Big World Little People, Deadliest Catch, Dog, Cops, An American Family and even The Osbornes and Hogan Knows Best are not reality shows, per se. They are documentaries. In some cases it's banal and trivial but they document something. The drama (conflict) are produced by editing (sometimes) not by writers/producers. Survivor, Amazing Race, Top Chef, Big Brother, The Bachelor(ette), Bigest Loser are game shows. period. There is no reality to them. The others like the VH1/MTV reality tv shows (Real World, Surreal Life, etc) are sitcoms. They might not be scripted but they are driven by scenarios and situations created by the producers.
#18
Political Exile
Part of the initial popularity of some of these reality shows like Survivor were that the contestants were non-actors with real jobs like accountant or truck driver, etc, who were put into these extraordinary circumstances. This even held true for talent shows like American Idol and dating shows like Bachelor. The reality of these shows was that these were not actors and their responses to situations given to them were honest and unpredicable.
Unfortunately with the popularity brings in the 'ringers' which are people who already want to be actors or models or whatever and go on these reality shows to beef up their resume. They play the role that the producers want to get as much face time as possible.
Even with American Idol, Kelly Clarkson wasn't really a waitress in Texas who dreamed of singing, she was already a recording artist who had moved to L.A. to shop a demo. Performers like Bo Bice and Taylor Hicks have performed hundreds of shows in front of large audiences before Idol.
Unfortunately with the popularity brings in the 'ringers' which are people who already want to be actors or models or whatever and go on these reality shows to beef up their resume. They play the role that the producers want to get as much face time as possible.
Even with American Idol, Kelly Clarkson wasn't really a waitress in Texas who dreamed of singing, she was already a recording artist who had moved to L.A. to shop a demo. Performers like Bo Bice and Taylor Hicks have performed hundreds of shows in front of large audiences before Idol.
#19
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Exit 10, NJ
Posts: 2,751
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PerryD
Part of the initial popularity of some of these reality shows like Survivor were that the contestants were non-actors with real jobs like accountant or truck driver, etc, who were put into these extraordinary circumstances. This even held true for talent shows like American Idol and dating shows like Bachelor. The reality of these shows was that these were not actors and their responses to situations given to them were honest and unpredicable.
#20
DVD Talk Hero
American Hot Rod on Discovery Channel. Boyd Coddington and his crew somehow get cool cars built under deadline despite themselves.
The Real Housewives of Orange County. I started a thread about that but it doesn't show up in a search.
Gastineau Girls on E! Here's a thread I started:
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showthread....ight=gastineau
The Real Housewives of Orange County. I started a thread about that but it doesn't show up in a search.
Gastineau Girls on E! Here's a thread I started:
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showthread....ight=gastineau
#21
DVD Talk Limited Edition
There is no such thing as "actual reality" on a reality show. I don't care what show it is. All reality shows are staged to a degree, including re-filming 'real-life' so they can get it at a better angle or a better take.
I saw some of a reality show being filmed (no challenges involved or anything, just supposed to be the person living their daily life) and the person was just signing their name on a piece of paper...The producer made them walk into the room, sign the paper, and sit down for 3 seperate takes until they got the one that they liked. They told him to walk in the room, sign his name in on the sign in sheet, and then go sit in the corner. Basically, it wasn't him living his life, it was him doing (and re-doing) what they wanted him to do.
I saw some of a reality show being filmed (no challenges involved or anything, just supposed to be the person living their daily life) and the person was just signing their name on a piece of paper...The producer made them walk into the room, sign the paper, and sit down for 3 seperate takes until they got the one that they liked. They told him to walk in the room, sign his name in on the sign in sheet, and then go sit in the corner. Basically, it wasn't him living his life, it was him doing (and re-doing) what they wanted him to do.
#23
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Seantn
There is no such thing as "actual reality" on a reality show. I don't care what show it is. All reality shows are staged to a degree, including re-filming 'real-life' so they can get it at a better angle or a better take.
I saw some of a reality show being filmed (no challenges involved or anything, just supposed to be the person living their daily life) and the person was just signing their name on a piece of paper...The producer made them walk into the room, sign the paper, and sit down for 3 seperate takes until they got the one that they liked. They told him to walk in the room, sign his name in on the sign in sheet, and then go sit in the corner. Basically, it wasn't him living his life, it was him doing (and re-doing) what they wanted him to do.
I saw some of a reality show being filmed (no challenges involved or anything, just supposed to be the person living their daily life) and the person was just signing their name on a piece of paper...The producer made them walk into the room, sign the paper, and sit down for 3 seperate takes until they got the one that they liked. They told him to walk in the room, sign his name in on the sign in sheet, and then go sit in the corner. Basically, it wasn't him living his life, it was him doing (and re-doing) what they wanted him to do.
#24
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally Posted by Canadian Bacon
America's Most Wanted
Cops
all other "reality" shows are staged crap
Cops
all other "reality" shows are staged crap
#25
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by davidh777
I've heard Dog the Bounty Hunter described as a "real-life show" as opposed to a reality show
I despise reality shows with a passion, but have recently caught a few episodes of Dog. It is a pretty solid show. I like it. Definitely NOT a game show.