An Inconvenient Truth: Global Warming / Al Gore documentary - May 24, 2006
#1
DVD Talk Godfather
Thread Starter
An Inconvenient Truth: Global Warming / Al Gore documentary - May 24, 2006
An Inconvenient Truth
[Trailer]
Eloquently weaves the science of global warming with Al Gore’s personal history and lifelong commitment to reversing the effects of global climate change. A longtime advocate for the environment, Gore presents a wide array of facts and information in a thoughtful and compelling way. The film is not a story of despair but rather a rallying cry.
<hr>
I've heard nothing of this film until I saw a banner ad for it today. It looks interesting although internal flags are being raised for the inclusion of Al Gore. Not because I don't like the man, but simply because I think this is not a subject that needs to be politicized. (The "next president" line on the trailer doesn't help its cause).
I don't know how interesting this would be for the average American. Maybe with gas prices hitting a nominal high some people might want to know more about this. Maybe not.
I may see it, just because I like seeing documentaries in theatres.
The trailer is fantastic.
[Trailer]
Eloquently weaves the science of global warming with Al Gore’s personal history and lifelong commitment to reversing the effects of global climate change. A longtime advocate for the environment, Gore presents a wide array of facts and information in a thoughtful and compelling way. The film is not a story of despair but rather a rallying cry.
<hr>
I've heard nothing of this film until I saw a banner ad for it today. It looks interesting although internal flags are being raised for the inclusion of Al Gore. Not because I don't like the man, but simply because I think this is not a subject that needs to be politicized. (The "next president" line on the trailer doesn't help its cause).
I don't know how interesting this would be for the average American. Maybe with gas prices hitting a nominal high some people might want to know more about this. Maybe not.
I may see it, just because I like seeing documentaries in theatres.
The trailer is fantastic.
#2
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Looks good.
Gore's involvement shouldn't really be made a partisan issue (although that won't stop some people from doing so) because he's been talking about this same topic for two decades or so - it's not just some sort of partisan political agenda he parrots just to look good in opinion polls. This is a topic that's close to his heart.
Gore's involvement shouldn't really be made a partisan issue (although that won't stop some people from doing so) because he's been talking about this same topic for two decades or so - it's not just some sort of partisan political agenda he parrots just to look good in opinion polls. This is a topic that's close to his heart.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
The two times I've seen this trailer play with an audience (both with Thank You For Smoking), people have laughed at it. Not a good sign at all.
I am very interested in seeing it. I am not a Gore fan, but I am curious to what he has to say (and the nature images should look good on a big screen).
I am very interested in seeing it. I am not a Gore fan, but I am curious to what he has to say (and the nature images should look good on a big screen).
#4
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Larry David's wife, Laurie, is a producer on this. She directed the very similar (minus Gore), "Too Hot Not to Handle", which is airing on HBO this month.
#5
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: Gateway Cities/Harbor Region
Posts: 63,299
Received 1,816 Likes
on
1,131 Posts
I posted the link to this trailer in a "Global Warming" thread in Politics a few weeks ago. No one had anything to say. But then again I think I'm on many "ignore" lists over there.
#6
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by Matthew Chmiel
The two times I've seen this trailer play with an audience (both with Thank You For Smoking), people have laughed at it. Not a good sign at all.
Originally Posted by Giantrobo
I posted the link to this trailer in a "Global Warming" thread in Politics a few weeks ago. No one had anything to say. But then again I think I'm on many "ignore" lists over there.
http://forum.dvdtalk.com/showthread.php?p=6940939 (Post #34)
Last edited by movielib; 04-26-06 at 07:43 AM.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
I was interested in seeing this until I read taa455's perceptive & eloquent critical assessment of the film...now I'm not as sure.
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Join Date: Dec 2000
Posts: 7,937
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by dhmac
Looks good.
Gore's involvement shouldn't really be made a partisan issue (although that won't stop some people from doing so) because he's been talking about this same topic for two decades or so - it's not just some sort of partisan political agenda he parrots just to look good in opinion polls. This is a topic that's close to his heart.
Gore's involvement shouldn't really be made a partisan issue (although that won't stop some people from doing so) because he's been talking about this same topic for two decades or so - it's not just some sort of partisan political agenda he parrots just to look good in opinion polls. This is a topic that's close to his heart.
#12
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Tennessee, USA
Posts: 3,514
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Jaymole
I was interested in seeing this until I read taa455's perceptive & eloquent critical assessment of the film...now I'm not as sure.
#14
Video Game Talk Editor
Join Date: Jul 1999
Location: Westchester, Los Angeles
Posts: 4,097
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Well, I don't think the South Park guys are too impressed with Al Gore's movie. They just skewered him with a parody turning Global Warming into a quest to stop ManBearPig, a fake freak of nature.
They even added a bit about him making it into a movie. Because he's super serial about ManBearPig.
They even added a bit about him making it into a movie. Because he's super serial about ManBearPig.
#15
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
I wonder if, in the 70s, Gore also bought in to the "Global Cooling" scare.
I don't care what facts they present. Yes, global warming is happening. It has happened before. And the earth has cooled before. Whether or not humans are screwing with the process is still a big QUESTION. The science is far from in.
I see this as nothing more than propaganda. The inclusion of Gore only makes it more so. I only hope the American people can see this for what it is.
I agree with taa455 on this one: garbage.
I don't care what facts they present. Yes, global warming is happening. It has happened before. And the earth has cooled before. Whether or not humans are screwing with the process is still a big QUESTION. The science is far from in.
I see this as nothing more than propaganda. The inclusion of Gore only makes it more so. I only hope the American people can see this for what it is.
I agree with taa455 on this one: garbage.
#16
DVD Talk Limited Edition
This film is based off a speech Gore has been giving for years, so those that are opposed to Gore's inclusion, should probably not watch it, because he's the progenitor of the doc's idea.
#19
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Oregon
Posts: 746
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by bravesmg
The "next president" line brings up harsh feelings on both sides and takes away from the aim of the movie.
#20
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by Duder
Exactly. I love how in the trailer he says that AND he says that "it's not a political issue, it's a moral one." BS, Gore. Global warming is probably the most politicized environmental issue there is. It's impossible to get any objective scientific facts on it without heavy spin and a lot of emotional rhetoric.
Most scientists agree with the view that global warming is happening, and most of those scientists attribute it to human activity. It's only a rather small minority of scientists who disagree with either of these views (most agree that warming is happening but disagree with it being caused by human activity, while it's just a very small few who think global warming is not happening at all).
So Al Gore's view on global warming is closer to the view of the majority of the scientific community, and not just some political spin and rhetoric that ignores science.
#21
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by dhmac
Yeah, he makes the joke "I'm Al Gore, I used to be the next president of the United States" and that is a political statement, but it has nothing to do with the main topic of the documentary, global warming. But he is correct that that topic, global warming, shouldn't be a political issue but a moral issue. And based on the trailer, it looks like Gore backs up his speech with a lot of scientific evidence (ex. "the 10 hottest years on record happened in the last 14 years", etc.).
Most scientists agree with the view that global warming is happening, and most of those scientists attribute it to human activity. It's only a rather small minority of scientists who disagree with either of these views (most agree that warming is happening but disagree with it being caused by human activity, while it's just a very small few who think global warming is not happening at all).
So Al Gore's view on global warming is closer to the view of the majority of the scientific community, and not just some political spin and rhetoric that ignores science.
Most scientists agree with the view that global warming is happening, and most of those scientists attribute it to human activity. It's only a rather small minority of scientists who disagree with either of these views (most agree that warming is happening but disagree with it being caused by human activity, while it's just a very small few who think global warming is not happening at all).
So Al Gore's view on global warming is closer to the view of the majority of the scientific community, and not just some political spin and rhetoric that ignores science.
And consider one of the main arguments in the trailer - that global warming is causing the period of more and stronger hurricanes. That is something with which the vast majority of skeptics and alarmists disagree (it is a part of a natural cycle of hurricane ups and downs which we have perceived for at least a century). Yet it is presented in the trailer as a fact. Perhaps the rhetoric on this point will be tempered in the actual film but I doubt it. Gore has been doomsaying and scaremongering for a couple of decades now. I doubt this film will be any different.
#22
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Oregon
Posts: 746
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yeah, I can't speak for what's in the rest of the film, but the bit about the hurricanes is so scientifically unsupported that I have a hard time taking the movie seriously.
#23
The major reason why I think the movie is "liberal spin" is the fact that thanks to all those church monks writing notes since circa 6th Century AD we have fairly good knowledge of the weather in Europe. As such, we know that until about the 13th Century Europe was actually much warmer than it is even today (they were growing wine grapes in what is now the UK!), until some unknown event caused Europe to become very cold in winter.
Besides, I don't trust a person whose last few speeches are more like screamfests.
Besides, I don't trust a person whose last few speeches are more like screamfests.
#24
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Church monks and grapes?
I like the trailer and poster for this film. My degree is in Environmental Science so I'll see it to know about it. In case the discussion would come up.
I like the trailer and poster for this film. My degree is in Environmental Science so I'll see it to know about it. In case the discussion would come up.
#25
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally Posted by RayChuang
The major reason why I think the movie is "liberal spin" is the fact that thanks to all those church monks writing notes since circa 6th Century AD we have fairly good knowledge of the weather in Europe. As such, we know that until about the 13th Century Europe was actually much warmer than it is even today (they were growing wine grapes in what is now the UK!), until some unknown event caused Europe to become very cold in winter.
My view is Global Warming is happening, but may or may not be caused or assisted by human industrial-age activity. However, changing the way we are living is crucial no matter what. If human activity is causing the warming, then changing this activity to reduce pollution will help slow down the process. But if our activity is not causing it, then changing our activity will still decrease pollution worldwide. A win-win situation either way.
Last edited by dhmac; 05-01-06 at 12:23 PM.